CAPTAIN'S QUARTERS ~ A Gem!

CAPTAIN'S QUARTERS ~ Key West Vintage, 3 bedroom home with a cottage and large private pool!

Location

1017 Varela Street
33040 Key West , FL
United States
24° 33' 18.72" N, 81° 47' 28.5" W
See map: Google Maps
Florida US

CAPTAIN'S QUARTERS ~ A Gem!

Request More Information

Wonderful Vacation Rental

Reviewed by Unknown on 2025-04-28
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Captain's Quarters was a perfect place for a small group of 6 to celebrate a birthday. I would not recommend more than 6.

This place is old, so expect some creaky floors and small inconveniences.

TLDR;
1. Location is good, only a few blocks from Duval
2. House is very old, but the rental company keeps up with the age.
3. Pool is nice to have on those hot days.
4. Kitchen is well stocked for cooking.
5. Main bathroom is not good for older or shorter people.

A quick trip

Reviewed by Unknown on 2025-04-21
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Beautiful and serene property. Very clean and well stocked. Excellent location with lots of walkability. Generally quiet neighborhood, with some over head plane noise (near impossible to avoid that in KW though). Only issue was that the master bathroom toilet had issues flushing without opening the tank lid. So we opted to use other bathrooms during our stay.

Wonderful

Reviewed by Unknown on 2025-03-04
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
9 ladies thoroughly enjoyed this place for a long weekend. We spent most of our time by the pool which is in a lovely position for sun all afternoon. They gave us plenty of towels and the kitchen was well appointed. We also enjoyed mornings on the front porch. We liked the neighborhood- very quiet and residential with close shops and restaurants. The home itself was very charming with its wood interior and high ceilings. We can’t wait to plan another trip back to enjoy this rental.

Authentic Key West Vibe

Reviewed by Shannon C. on 2025-01-26
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We spent 4 days and 3 nights. Captains Quarters was wonderful. Great location with avg Lyft cost of $8. Loved the front porch and the neighborhood. Keep in mind there is an early noise ordinances at 8pm so you need to be mindful at the pool if night swimming. Woke up with the chickens every morning and relaxed in this home. The bathtub is high and for older folk would be difficult but there are two other showers one outdoors which was great under the stars! The beds and pillows were top notch and we all slept very well. Biggest issue was the deck door to the pool was very difficult to open. It stuck a lot. Thank you to the host for the great communication and I highly recommend using their free concierge service. We had food waiting for us after a very stressful travel day. They really aided in our decompression. I will be back and will stay here again.

Wonderful Getaway

Reviewed by Jennifer G. on 2025-02-04
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house is charming. It is very well laid out and easily accommodated 8 of us (4 bedrooms (one is outside in a little attached cottage). The pool and pool area are fantastic. It is slightly off the beaten track so quiet, but still in walking distance if everything. Will stay here again!

Captain's Quarters Update

Reviewed by Unknown on 2024-06-30
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Our "friends" vacation to Key West was unforgettable. We really enjoyed staying at the Captain's Quarters. We had four bedrooms, plenty of bathroom space, a great kitchen and dining area, and a beautiful, private pool. We could not have asked for a better experience. Our property manager, Melanie, was helpful and accommodating. She sent us perfect directions, explanations, and suggestions for our stay. We rented golf carts, buzzed throughout the area, enjoyed great food and tourist attractions, and commented to one another on everyone's friendliness, courtesy, and helpfulness. Excellent vacation.
Manager response on 2024-11-19 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Excellent House

Reviewed by Debra W. on 2024-12-02
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Everything was as expected. The house is beautiful and well kept. Location (close to Duval), heated pool (very clean), house amenities and home management company were all excellent. I would def stay here again.
Manager response on 2024-12-14 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this great review Debra! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Amazing!

Reviewed by Linda C. on 2024-05-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Property was incredible. Everything you could want and more. Clean and well equipped. Great for family gathering while allowing everyone their space. And our host melanie was a star
Manager response on 2024-11-19 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us! We would love to welcome you back!

Amazing house !!!

Reviewed by Lisa W. on 2024-07-29
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
everything you need while staying in Key West
Manager response on 2024-11-19 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review, we are so glad the property met your needs while staying with us. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit Key West.

Bachelor trip October 2024

Reviewed by Kim N. on 2024-10-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This house was amazing! Extremely clean and had everything we needed! The pool was way bigger than we thought and Melanie was more than happy to heat it for us which was Awesome! We felt very secure and there was plenty of room for eight adults. All of our activities were easy to get to, but our location was quiet and peaceful. Melanie answered the phone, no matter what time I called her. She could not have been more attentive than she was. We enjoyed the separate dining room area, the washer and dryer were appreciated and the kitchen was amazing.Bathrooms were pretty and everything worked great. We were within walking distance of a grocery store, liquor store, other small restaurants, and Duval Street was easily walkable. We did have a golf cart for getting around and it was always easy to find parking close to the house. We would definitely stay here again!
Manager response on 2024-11-19 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review Kim, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Amazing Time at Captain's Quarters

Reviewed by Kelly M. on 2024-09-09
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
First of all, stunning historical home and very clean. Every single room was perfectly appointed with antiques and nautical art. We started off with touring each room checking out all the details.The kitchen had everything we needed to cook at home and saved a ton of money not eating out. The pool outside was incredible, deep and the perfect temperature. We had a ball taking a break from the sweltering mid-day heat and enjoyed the pool and snacks at home. The front and backyard were so private it felt like our own little oasis. The management was very communicative and accommodating. I would love to stay again. This is truly a Key West dream home.
Manager response on 2024-11-19 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so happy you found this property and its location ideal for your get away in Key West. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit!

Lovely Home

Reviewed by Theo P. on 2024-09-07
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The home is beautiful and clean. It is located
in a quite area with a lovely swimming pool in the back. The home is well equipped with anything you may need such as hair dryers, ironing board and iron. Restaurants are close by as well as a grocery and liquor store within walking distance. We were lucky to be able to check in at 12:00 instead of waiting until 4:00. I would consider renting this property in the future.
Manager response on 2024-11-19 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us! We would love to welcome you back!

Girl's Trip-Key West

Reviewed by Unknown on 2023-05-06
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Captain's Quarters worked well for 8 women there to take-in Key West. Great location-able to walk to Duval, marina area& local stores/restaurants. Enjoyed the pool area for relaxing.
Manager response on 2023-11-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for taking the time to review your stay Donna. We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

CAPTAIN'S QUARTERS

Reviewed by Scott L. on 2023-03-21
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
CAPTAIN'S QUARTERS was as described and ready for our arrival We only hope that is available for all our future visits to Key West This was perfect spot
Manager response on 2023-11-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for taking the time to post a review of our property Scott. We are so happy to hear that you enjoyed your time in Key West. Our goal is always to exceed your expectations! If there's anything we can help you with during your next visit, please don't hesitate to let us know.

Best Place and Best Value.

Reviewed by Chris P. on 2023-06-02
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great house in great location. Everyone really enjoyed it. The pool and BBQ made outside living really nice. There is a cool market right around the corner so that made it nice. It looks like 8 people could sleep here comfortably, we only had 4. It is about a 15 minute walk to Duval St. but very doable.
Manager response on 2023-11-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your fantastic review Chris. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Nice Key West Getaway

Reviewed by Dan L. on 2023-06-26
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Nice home to come back to after a long day out n about in Key West. Comfort and coziness for a restful and fun stay. Relaxing backyard pool area to beat the heat! A 20-30 min walk to the main Duval Street activities.
Manager response on 2023-11-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Dan. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Wonderful backyard

Reviewed by Joanne D. on 2023-06-28
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Absolutely loved this house! It had tons of space inside and was decorated so cute. The backyard is amazing with a huge pool and had plenty of seating. It was a very short golf cart ride to all restaurants and bars. I would definitely rent this house again!
Manager response on 2023-11-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Joanne. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Best in Stay 2023

Reviewed by Unknown on 2023-09-09
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Our stay at the Captain’s Quarters was a perfect setting for a birthday trip! The house is uniquely decorated, and the wood paneling keeps the house cool during the sticky days. All the amenities were spot on, and the pool was a perfect spot to sit and enjoy the day. What made our stay perfect was the quick response from Melaine. Her response time was short, and she offered to go above and beyond for each of our asks! We would not only recommend staying with our family and friends but will be returning!!
Manager response on 2023-11-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review Lacey, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

KW Group

Reviewed by John W. on 2024-02-11
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house was exactly what we were looking for, it handled all 9 of us great. Good location, short walk or Uber to anything in minutes.
Manager response on 2024-04-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for sharing a review of your recent experience. Our team here at Best of Key West Rentals is committed to providing high-quality guest service, and we’re thrilled to hear that we made a good impression on you. We hope you’ll visit us again soon.

Best kept secret.

Reviewed by Unknown on 2023-11-29
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house was lovely.
Manager response on 2024-04-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this short and sweet five star review, we hope to have the pleasure to host you again next time you visit the island.

Enjoyable stay!

Reviewed by Unknown on 2023-12-06
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had 10 people and accmodated us well. Only suggestion is to have mirrors in all bedrooms with a large group. Very satisfied with property!
Manager response on 2024-04-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review. We are thrilled you loved this home and hope to host you again soon!

A lovely and comfortable stay

Reviewed by Unknown on 2023-10-19
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a great weekend stay at the Captain's Quarters. The house and pool were lovely. We had everything we needed and were close to a bike rental which is a great way to travel around Key West. Check in and out were easy. Thank you
Manager response on 2023-11-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this great review Terri! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Fantastic house!

Reviewed by Jackie H. on 2024-03-12
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house was absolutely beautiful! Favorite part was the pool and the front porch for sure! Management company was wonderful to work with! They were extremely responsive and informative!
Manager response on 2024-04-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this great review Jackie! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

ahhhmazing

Reviewed by kristine c. on 2024-02-12
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We really enjoyed our stay. The house was very clean and comfortable. We had a larger group and the home had everything we needed.
Manager response on 2024-04-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review. We are thrilled you loved this home and hope to host you again soon!

Beautiful backyard oasis

Reviewed by Unknown on 2024-04-24
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house was clean and well maintained. Stocked with essentials. The backyard was a wonderful, private space with lots of lounge chairs and outdoor seating. Plenty of room for 6 adults.
Manager response on 2024-04-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so happy you found this property and its location ideal for your get away in Key West. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit!

Captain's Quarter 2 Day Stay

Reviewed by Unknown on 2024-03-20
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Awesome
Manager response on 2024-04-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this short and sweet five star review, we hope to have the pleasure to host you again next time you visit the island.

Celebration of life

Reviewed by Tania R. on 2024-04-09
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We got together as a family to celebrate my father-in-law‘s life. A third generation conch that has lived his life in Key West.
Captain’s Quarters was perfect.
Manager response on 2024-04-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so happy you found this property and its location ideal to celebrate your father in law's life. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit our beautiful island!

Fabulous Family Vacation

Reviewed by Unknown on 2022-01-04
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Awesome! It is a beautiful home that exudes charm and character. The whole family loved the design, layout, decor, everything! Private pool and beautifully landscaped backyard, so relaxing!
Perfect location for everything, a short block to Fausto's and Sandy's had us very spoiled. Both the rental experience and the management company were wonderful. We so much appreciate the flexibility afforded us when we had to delay our trip due to COVID lockdown over a year ago. It was so worth the wait and VRBO, Truman, and Zintsmaster helped make this our best vacation ever. Thanks to Zintsmaster for recommending and reserving Viva on New Year's Eve. Wonderful way to end the old year and welcome 2022! We definitely will be back! Thank you all so much.
Manager response on 2022-01-11 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this fantastic review Marcia! We are thrilled you and your family had the best vacation ever and hope you welcome you again next time you visit the island!

Great house with lots of character

Reviewed by Unknown on 2021-07-07
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Had a great time. House was very nice and comfortable. Rental agent was very responsive and easy to work with.
Manager response on 2021-07-08 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so glad you had a great stay with us Rick, we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit Key West!

AMAZING1

Reviewed by Michelle T. on 2021-03-04
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
As a group of friends that go to KW every year - this by far was the best place we have stayed! The home is absolutely charming and the pool is amazing. Super convenient location with a full grocery near by. Book this home - you wont be disappointed! We are already planning to go back for our trip next year!
Manager response on 2021-03-12 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your recent review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back again soon!

Quaint Historic Home Close to All the Sites

Reviewed by Penny M. on 2021-02-10
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We stayed at this lovely historic home for 4 days and found it very comfortable. It is close to Duval street so you can walk to all the restaurants, shops and sites. The pool is very warm and we really enjoyed lounging around the pool during our stay and using the barbecue. The home is also full of very interesting antiques and vintage pieces which makes it a very special home to stay at.
Manager response on 2021-02-23 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your recent review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back soon!

Superior Experience

Reviewed by Bruce M. on 2021-11-06
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a fantastic time. The quality of the house was stellar and the location ideal. Very clean and the property manager was extremely responsive and helpful. Its a great place to enjoy Key West.
Manager response on 2021-11-16 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review Bruce, we are glad your experience was superior and hope you will be staying with us again next time you visit Key West!

Wonderful

Reviewed by Karen D. on 2021-04-18
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Clean, Roomy, Charming home a mile or so to shops, beach. We loved the big lizards that came to say hello at the pool they don’t bother you and are neat to see. The bedrooms are comfortable-I stayed in the bungalow off of the pool - a real Key West vacation. The Airplanes fly low and directly above the pool -my dad being a pilot-I loved it! Pool very nice-we spent much time swimming-nice relaxing porch front of house for a change of scenery. Def recommend and will be back. Suggestion-Fly into Key West airport it is a very short cab ride to and from location.
Manager response on 2021-04-22 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your kind words. We enjoyed hosting you in Paradise and hope to see you back soon!

Perfect Spot

Reviewed by Robert K. on 2021-03-13
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Pool area sold the property, enough room for 8 to chill and not have to deal with a busy beach! Close walk to good food, shopping and the Marina. A perfect spot to Celebrate my 50th Birthday with fiends and family!
Manager response on 2021-03-30 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review. Please come back and see us soon!

Beautiful and Conveniently Located Key West Home

Reviewed by Toni B. on 2021-10-15
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had an amazing time in this home. It's really conveniently located. We had a party store less than a block away for refreshments, Sandy's Cuban counter restaurant for food, breakfast and fantastic coffee and a short bike ride away from everywhere else we wanted to go. The home itself was perfectly sized, even for 8 adults. The manager was really accommodating with any of our requests. The only warning is the 5 day trash pickup process that occurs before 6 a.m. There's a day where a guy comes to put the trash cans out, comes another day for different trash cans, trash pickup occurs on two days then another day to bring the cans back. I'm assuming it's done so early for a reason, but I would warn guests in advance because it's loud and alarming to hear people within the gates, dragging cans across rocks that early.
Manager response on 2021-11-02 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so glad you enjoyed your stay so much Toni! We are sorry to hear the trash pick up disturbed you, they only come once a week so we have someone get it out and in that same day but that's it. We have no control over the city's schedule but hope you will come and stay with us again next time you visit the island!

5 stars***

Reviewed by Rebecca V. on 2021-05-21
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
great rental property and the property manager was amazing! very responsive to text messages and was extremely pleasant to work with. will definitely be back!
Manager response on 2021-06-01 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review. We are so happy you had a great time and hope to see you again!

Birthday vacation!

Reviewed by Eileen E. on 2021-05-04
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The property I rented was awesome(despite the outside needed a huge cosmetic makeover ) . The house was perfect for my family. The beds were very comfortable and overall we enjoyed the house very much. The pool/ deck area was our primary hangout place.
Manager response on 2021-05-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you again soon!

A Fantastic Stay in Key West

Reviewed by Henry M. on 2022-01-30
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We loved our stay at Captain's Quarters. There were 7 of us and we never felt as if we were on top of each other. The house was clean. The pool was amazing (and cleaned twice a week). The location was good. It's a little farther from most places you want to go in Key West, but not too far and away from the noise indeed. We spent our time walking more than Ubering. I dare say the Pool House bedroom may be the best in the bunch, separated from the main house, but next to an outdoor shower and connected to a bathroom. Also, Melanie, at the management company was extremely responsive with any request or need. We could not have asked for more. I definitely recommend this property for your Key West stay.
Manager response on 2022-02-07 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review Henry, we are so glad you and your group enjoyed the property so much! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

A wonderful place to stay!

Reviewed by Mary C. on 2021-09-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The property was absolutely beautiful and conveniently located, rooms were clean and comfortable.
Manager response on 2021-10-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Mary. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

Great Key West Home!

Reviewed by Clare P. on 2022-05-16
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Such a great home in Key West! So clean and spacious. The pool was definitely the best part! Our primary contact, Melanie, was very helpful and kind over the phone and made sure we had everything we needed during our stay. I would definitely recommend this home to a medium sized group of family or friends.
Manager response on 2022-05-31 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Clare. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Best Rental Yet!

Reviewed by Sherrie R. on 2022-05-11
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We couldn’t have found a more accommodating rental (thank you Melanie!) for our girls trip! Very close to Duval, restaurants and the Faustos Grocery store right around the corner was a def plus! Loved the fact that Sandy’s cafe right around the corner delivered breakfast every morning and it was delish! Would definitely stay here again....and again!!
Manager response on 2022-05-13 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your incredible review Sherrie! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this Key West retreat and we are looking forward to hosting you again next time you visit the island. Thank you for being our guest!

Great house

Reviewed by Timothy K. on 2022-05-31
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great location
Nice pool
Manager response on 2022-06-14 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Timothy. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Captains Quarters - The absolute best!

Reviewed by Michelle T. on 2022-03-29
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This was our second time staying at this property and it once again did not disappoint! We 100% recommend this property and definitely plan to stay there again.
Manager response on 2022-04-19 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Michelle. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

A Truly Great Stay!

Reviewed by Sarah H. on 2022-06-21
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Our group of 9 thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Lots of space, great bedrooms, and we loved the pool and back patio! The management company was always quick to respond and answer questions. We would definitely stay here again!
Manager response on 2022-07-15 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Sarah. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Captain Quarters Getaway

Reviewed by Diane M. on 2022-04-25
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We loved our stay at Key West Captain Quarters. The house was beautiful and the outside pool area was the icing on the cake. We appreciate the accommodations made when we arrived before check in time too. We highly recommend this home to any families/group visiting Key West.
Manager response on 2022-04-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Diane. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Key West

Reviewed by Eric H. on 2022-04-15
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Wonderful property!
Manager response on 2022-04-19 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your fantastic review Eric. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Perfect Location for Key West Trip!

Reviewed by DACE G. on 2022-01-10
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The location was perfect as you're not far away from Duval street which is about a half mile walk down the road. You're also far enough away from party goers you won't be disturbed. No complaints except you won't be able to turn the heat up on the pool as it's locked at 84 degrees. There was one night cool enough we wished we could have turned it up a little. A minor annoyance was the main shower ran out of hot water pretty quickly and the shower head looks nice, but the water pressure coming out was not great. I used a different shower and got much hotter water and better pressure. We knew someone would be coming to clean the pool and someone else to clean the grounds. I would recommend to the owners to have the grounds keeper come first before the pool cleaner as the ground keepers blows off the back yard and lots of debris ended up in the perfectly clean pool and I had to clean it all out before we could use the pool. As far as Parking is concerned, we missed the fact you are not SUPPOSED to park on the street in front of the house and there is no parking on the property. We found a spot in front of the house off the street and left it to chance if we received a $50 parking fine. Luckily, we stayed for 6 days and never received a fine. :) I believe the parking garages charge $32 per day so we felt like the $18 difference would be worth it being able to park our car right in front of the house. Other recommendations: We ate at Blue Heaven which was fantastic and worth the wait! Sushi Song was right down the road and open until like 3 am! We ordered it for delivery and it was great! Lobster rolls at DJ's clam shack is a must featured on Dives, Diners, and Drive-ins. Not much seating though. And lastly, our family enjoyed the Butterfly garden which was just amazing and not to mention a nice spot to cool off for minute.
Manager response on 2022-01-11 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Dace, we are thrilled you enjoyed your stay at Captain's Quarters. We are taking note of the small issues you encountered and will be addressing them right away. We hope to host you again next time you visit the island!

A gem in Key West

Reviewed by Christopher F. on 2022-10-14
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
A beautiful house in a quiet neighborhood but close enough to the nightlife for a perfect blend. Pool, deck, BBQ, 4 bedrooms, large kitchen makes for a great stay.
Manager response on 2022-10-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us Chris! Thank you for being our guest!

Quick Getaway

Reviewed by Lori D. on 2022-10-08
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This place was quite the charming place and exactly what we were looking for. We were approx 4 blocks from Duvall Street so if we wanted just a quick walk uptown, there was no need for a uber. The house was very roomy and it was nice to have the pool to ourselves. We would definitely stay here again. We were able to check in early and had no issues with working with the Property Manager.
Manager response on 2022-10-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this great review Lori! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Great location!!

Reviewed by Joyce M. on 2022-08-05
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
It was so convenient and well appointed. Had everything we needed. Enjoyed the pool in the evening after being out on the hot days. We biked everywhere we went.
Manager response on 2022-09-12 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us Joyce! We would love to welcome you back!

Captain's Quarters

Reviewed by Michael and Lisa M. on 2022-06-04
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This is a great place to stay and had everything we needed. Loved the pool and all.
Manager response on 2022-06-14 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review! It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Great Escape

Reviewed by Unknown on 2022-12-14
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Celebrated a 50th Birthday in Key West with 9 other friends. House was clean, spacious, beds were comfortable. Kitchen needs some attention. Outside pool area was beautiful. Many loose bricks on the walkway around the house, have to be careful. Pool was heated and clean.
Manager response on 2022-12-30 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for bringing these concerns to our attention Barbara. We will share your feedback with our team and address the issues you mentioned. We are glad you enjoyed your celebratory get away with your friends and hope to welcome you again next time you visit key West!

It was great places

Reviewed by Iralia v A. on 2022-08-03
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The houses was perfect for me and my family
and it was clean too.
Manager response on 2022-09-12 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review William. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Gem in Key West

Reviewed by Melissa S. on 2022-12-10
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Lovely place to stay! We stayed here with 7 adults comfortably. It's a beautiful home with character. It's kept nice, clean and a great location. Since it was winter and dark early we mostly called cars to go to Duval Street at night but it could be walkable. The back yard is nice with a heated pool, lounge chairs for everyone, table and grill. The outdoor shower is a nice addition. It would comfortable stay 8 adults, any more they would have to go in the small living room and it would be tight. Would be a nice house to rent with kids as well. Felt safe and the front gate locked. Communication with the property manager was great! Awesome cuban coffee around the corner.
Manager response on 2022-12-30 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review Melissa, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Captains Quarters - The perfect Key West vacation rental!

Reviewed by Unknown on 2023-02-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house was not only charming - it was the perfect size for our family of 10. The backyard and pool were where we spent most of our time. The location is ideal in that you can walk one way to the beach, or head the other way to Mallory Square. We rented a wagon for the littlest guests. Truman & Company is a stellar vacation management company. Melanie was delightful and helped us with anything we needed. Check in and check out couldn’t be easier! I highly recommend them.
Manager response on 2023-02-24 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your incredible review Lynn! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this Key West retreat and we are looking forward to hosting you again next time you visit the island. Thank you for being our guest!

Wonderful Getaway in the Keys

Reviewed by Amy S. on 2023-03-19
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Relaxing, well-kept property - close to the beach, harbor, and Duval street. The heated pool was a huge plus. Parking was hit or miss depending on the time of day.
Manager response on 2023-11-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so happy you found this property and its location ideal for your get away in Key West Amy. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit!

Valentine wedding Margaritaville

Reviewed by Cora V. on 2019-05-15
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Comfortable well equipped cool in every sense of the word. Can’t wait to go back and relax.
Manager response on 2019-05-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Cora, Thank you for your incredible review on Captain's Quarters. We are so thrilled to hear that your wedding weekend in Paradise was perfect. We loved hosting you in Paradise and hope to see you on your next trip to the Florida Keys! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Perfect Vacation Rental

Reviewed by Kortnee A. on 2019-03-04
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This house was perfect for a group of friends in town for a wedding. The beds were so comfortable, and we all had plenty of privacy. Loved the decor and overall feel of the home.
Manager response on 2019-03-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Kortnee, We are so happy to hear how much you loved your time spent at Captain's Quarters! The house really is perfect for a group of friends traveling together. Thank you for the wonderful feedback and please come back and see us soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Fantastic House!

Reviewed by Shane H. on 2019-10-10
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This home is located very close to local stores (walking a block or 2) and is also a short walk to popular destinations like Duval. It has amazing charm to it and it’s perfect for a small group to stay and enjoy beautiful Key West. The pool and back patio is incredible and a fantastic place to spend a nice sunny day.
Manager response on 2019-10-10 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Shane, Thank you for your wonderful review! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this incredible home and we hope to see you back soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Awesome house!

Reviewed by Lisa T. on 2019-08-23
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We really enjoy our stay in Key West at Captain's Quarters. Perfect size house for four couples. There were no surprises, everything was as listed. We especially loved the pool and home decor! The only thing we found that needs to be fixed is the door handle in the front left bedroom.
Manager response on 2019-08-25 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Lisa, Thank you for your 5 star review! We are so happy that you and your party had such an enjoyable time in Key West. We loved hosting you in Paradise and hope to see you back soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Key west adventure

Reviewed by Kathy B. on 2020-01-06
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Excellent. Pool was amazing. Location was perfect. Character of home was nice. Only small issue was not enough silverware for ten of us. And some of the towel hooks came out of the wall because they were not installed correctly.
Manager response on 2020-01-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Hi Kathy, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this home. We will look into the silverware inventory immediately as well as the towel hooks. Please come back and see us soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great time!

Reviewed by Ashley T. on 2019-05-17
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house was super cute and ended up sleeping 10 of us comfortably (2 on the couches). We had everything we needed, the pool was great, and even the little poolside cottage was comfortable! We ended up renting bikes two different days from the bike shop across the street, highly recommend! Jorge was also very accommodating in letting us leave our bags on the property since our flight was in the afternoon after check out.
Manager response on 2019-05-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Ashley, Thank you for your 5 star review on Captain's Quarters. We are so happy to hear that your party of 10 enjoyed this incredible Key West home. We appreciate all your feedback and hope to see you back in Paradise again soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Amazing house & pool is everything!

Reviewed by Unknown on 2019-10-20
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We stayed at Captain's Quarters with 3 other couples for 4 nights. We all didn't want to leave! The pool and outdoor area was amazing. The house itself was perfect, everyone loved the kitchen and living room. We took a 3-4 min Uber ride to downtown most days and never had to wait for a car. The area where the house is located is great! 20 min walk to Duval St., and lots of good coffee and food less than a block away. Can't wait to come back!!
Manager response on 2019-10-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Katie, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how perfect this home was for your Key West visit. We hope to see you again soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great place to spend with family or friends

Reviewed by Bennetto P. on 2019-10-09
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The experience was good but I feel it could be great to excellent with a few small details being added.
Manager response on 2019-10-09 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Bennetto, Thank you for your recent review. We are so happy to hear how much you enjoyed this incredible home in Key West. We would love to hear more on your thoughts of what could be added so feel free to reach out anytime. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Perfect Place

Reviewed by JOHN T. on 2019-06-06
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Excellent as described!
Manager response on 2019-06-07 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear John, Thank you for your incredible review on Captain's Quarters. We are so happy to hear how much you loved this amazing Key West retreat. The house is well equipped and comes with a spacious pool making this the perfect island destination. We appreciate your feedback and hope to see you back very soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Very Nice House

Reviewed by Jeffrey L. on 2020-02-24
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Three generations of our extended family , ranging in age from 1 up to 65 enjoyed this house in Feb 2020. Rooms are large and ceilings are high so we never felt crowded. Pool is large too.We recommend the house, but did find it a bit far from Duval and "the action". We like to walk places, but would suggest bikes and/or car.
Manager response on 2020-02-28 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Jeffrey, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you loved this home. This home is desirably located for those that want to be close to downtown but far enough for some peace and quiet. We hope you had a wonderful vacation! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Fun Vacation experience

Reviewed by Lisa E. on 2020-01-10
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a great time in Key West. The property was clean and well- decorated and we loved the pool, especially in the evenings after a long hot day (yes, it was warm in December!). The concierge service was vey helpful and arranged several outings for us at the last minute. The location was great too, on the edge of Old Town- renting bikes is the way to go. The neighbors that we met were all very friendly and it seems to be a mix of rentals and full time homeowners so the places are all well kept. We had a great time!
Manager response on 2020-01-12 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Lisa, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you enjoyed your time at this home and hope to see you back again soon. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Captains quarters

Reviewed by Ashleen S. on 2019-08-19
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great place!!! Would def book here again!!!!
Manager response on 2019-08-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Joy, Thank you for your kind words on your recent stay. We are so happy that you loved this home and would stay here again. We hope to be hearing from you soon to book your next visit! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Key West Christmas!

Reviewed by Rosemary D. on 2019-12-28
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We rented this house for the week before Christmas rather than giving gifts. It was a wonderful opportunity to spend time together with family. The house was perfect for our family. We didn’t need a car and walked out biked everywhere. The weather wasn’t fabulous but we still had a great time. The pool area was great, the kitchen well supplied, and the front porch was a great place for our grandchildren to hang ou with neighborhood cats!
Manager response on 2019-12-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Rosemary, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you enjoyed this amazing home and we hope to see you back soon. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great Stay!

Reviewed by Eric J. on 2020-02-03
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We loved our stay at Captain Quarters! We had a group of 4 couples. Captains Quarters was a great place to stay the house is exactly what you think Key West should be. It was a great central location. We loved the central location and there were some great restaurants near by. We will be recommending this house to all of our friends.
Manager response on 2020-02-03 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Eric, Thank you for your incredible review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and we hope to see you back soon. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Captain's Quarters

Reviewed by Mark K. on 2020-01-13
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great home and heated pool; wish we had more time to stay there.
Manager response on 2020-01-13 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Mark, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you enjoyed this home and hope to see you back soon. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Captain's Quarters Key West

Reviewed by john m. on 2020-04-03
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Nice house, great pool, great location.
Manager response on 2020-04-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear John, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and we hope to see you again. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Gorgeous Home

Reviewed by Laura C. on 2020-03-15
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The Captain’s Quarters was absolutely perfect! The home was spacious and very clean. The pool area was exceptional! Location was a little further from Duval than we were used to staying, but with car services so readily available it was never a problem. If walking isn’t your thing, consider renting a bike or scooter. The neighbor is residential- felt quiet and safe. Would definitely recommend!
Manager response on 2020-03-18 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Laura, Thank you for your review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this home and hope to see you back soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great Get-a-way

Reviewed by Debbie O. on 2021-01-25
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a fantastic time. The house was amazing and extremely clean. There were 10 of us and we all had plenty of room. I chose to sleep in the guest house which was absolutely amazing. We left the door and window open all night along with the fan running and had a fantastic cross breeze. It was very centrally located and we walked or biked to everything. As you can imagine our favorite spot was by the pool. Thank you for a great experience.
Manager response on 2021-01-26 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your kind words. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you again very soon!

Capt Qtrs Key West

Reviewed by Lisa P. on 2020-02-16
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Celebrating a 60th anniversary with family
Manager response on 2020-02-17 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Bernard, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you in the future! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Captain's Quarters Key West

Reviewed by john m. on 2020-04-05
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Nice house in a great location with an even nicer pool.
Manager response on 2020-04-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear John, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and we hope to see you again. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Fabulous Home in a Quiet Neighborhood!

Reviewed by Unknown on 2020-07-17
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a wonderful stay at Captain’s Quarters. The home was perfect for our group of 5 adults and 4 kids (9, 10, 13, 14). The pool area was very private and we spent most of our time there swimming or lounging. There was ample seating for us! The house is gorgeous and the beds were comfy. We cooked more than we originally anticipated, but with fresh fish from a fishing excursion, the kitchen provided everything we needed to whip up several tasty meals. We enjoyed walking to Sandy’s to grab coffee and breakfast-just around the corner. Cuban coffee, pastries, and Cuban sandwiches were delicious! There is also a market that had everything we needed very close as well. Great location in a quiet neighborhood but an easy bike ride to Higgs beach to catch beautiful sunrises. Duval St is walkable but we preferred to bike. Even with kids we were able to bike there within 10 minutes. The property manager, Melanie, was excellent and available for anything we needed.
Manager response on 2020-07-19 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you so much for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to host you again soon.

We Can't Wait Till Next Year

Reviewed by Unknown on 2021-02-02
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
A group of 6 adults have been traveling to Key West for the past 5 years. This is the best house we have stayed! All the rooms are large and everything in on one level. The best part is the pool. It is hard to find a full size pool and ample pool deck space and this house has both! We hope to stay again next year!
Manager response on 2021-02-08 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back again soon!

Awesome House

Reviewed by Christopher B. on 2020-10-06
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Very cool house with a great backyard! Pool was a perfect way to cool off after exploring and after a long day of fishing. Will be back.
Manager response on 2020-10-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to see you back soon!

Fantastic!

Reviewed by Kim R. on 2020-10-28
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We absolutely loved this house! It was clean, beautiful and just as described. The management company was responsive and quick to act when we complained about the pool heater, they came right out and turned it off. The concierge service was a great help in booking reservations and bike rentals, delivered right to the house! We loved it, and next time I am in Key West I'll definitely plan to stay here again. The location was great, a quick 3-5 minute bike ride anywhere on the island, right around the corner from a grocery store, a liquor store and the best cuban sandwiches (Sandy's). Oh, and an outdoor shower which isn't advertised but was a great surprise! Two thumbs up!
Manager response on 2020-10-28 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you again soon.

Christmas at Captains Quarters

Reviewed by Matthew W. on 2020-12-28
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Loved the property, well kept and maintained. The private pool was a huge plus. Melanie Wilson was very professional and helpful.
Manager response on 2020-12-30 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review! We hope to see you again soon!

CAPTAIN'S QUARTERS ~ A Vintage Key West Retreat that is full of Charm!!

Unit Code: CQ

CAPTAIN'S QUARTERS ~ A Gem!

CAPTAIN'S QUARTERS ~ Key West Vintage, 3 bedroom home with a cottage and large private pool!
HISTORIC OLD-WORLD CHARM WITH MODERN AMENITIES AND A LAGOON-STYLE POOL.... Once you step through the threshold of this Old Town home you feel enveloped in vintage Key West.  Dade County wood surfaces, nautical accents plus appealing and comfortable decor make this a true "Captain's Quarters". Hang out in the living room with flat screen TV. ***PRIMARY GUEST MUST BE AT LEAST 25 YEARS OF AGE SLEEPING ARRANGEMENTS... You will have many sleeping options while staying in this stunning home as it comfortably sleeps 8-10 guests. There are three bedrooms located in the main house and a one bedroom cottage off the rear deck by the pool.  As you enter the main hallway, there are two queen guest bedrooms immediately to your left and right. They each have TVs, storage for clothing and the option of using the hall or rear bathrooms. The master bedroom is fitted with a king size bed, flat screen, closet and has an interior door that leads to a full bathroom.  You will find a cast iron clawfoot tub with rain shower as well as a vintage pedestal sink. The rear bathroom off the family room has a tiled shower with glass door and a pedestal sink. There is a powder room off the kitchen that houses the washer and dryer. It has a door to the rear deck that can double for cottage use.  The cottage is your fourth bedroom with a queen size bed, pedestal sink, dresser and flat screen with a view of the pool!  If you have one or two more guests they can use the sleeper sofa in the family room.  AMENITIES... Captains' Quarters had updates completed in the spacious homes layout and decor in 2015. Impressively rich Dade County pine and high ceilings make this property a real stand out. The kitchen is fully equipped to meet your cooking needs and has a formal dining room steps away. Your family can dine together at the table for six or use the space to play games or cards.      OUTDOOR LIVING... Lush tropical landscaping greets you at the front gate and wraps around the property. Once inside, you will find a covered porch with a swing and seating area perfect for your morning coffee or to curl up with a book.  A winding path will take you around the side yard to a real gem; the lagoon-style pool!  The large private, heated pool is situated in the rear yard surrounded by a composite deck with plenty of seating. There is a gas grill and outdoor table covered with a large umbrella meant for six to dine al fresco and grill your fresh catch of the day.  If you are a sun worshiper you can kick back and relax on one of the five lounge chairs that surround the pool. Enjoy an outdoor shower to rinse off and head into town! PARKING... This home does not have designated parking but there is on street parking in the surrounding neighborhood.  Please refrain from parking in spots marked “residential”. Guests may also park at the Old Town Parking Garage which allows daily and monthly rates. DISTANCES TO BEACHES... Higgs Beach is 0.8 mi South Beach is 0.9 mi Smathers Beach is 1.7 mi Fort Zachary Taylor Beach is 1.7 m CONCIERGE SERVICES... Enjoy our concierge service to assist you with planning activities for your trip, from bike/scooter/golf cart rentals to any excursion you can think of including snorkeling and sunset cruises, jet ski rentals, parasailing, kayaking, fishing, paddle boarding and much more. They can also have your fridge stocked with all the necessities in advance of your arrival! CANCELLATION... Bookings canceled at least 30 days before the start of stay will receive a 100% refund. Bookings canceled at least 14 days before the start of stay will receive a 50% refund. ISLAND TIME AWAITS...
May 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
June 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
 
July 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
Age 18 and under.
DatesPrice
05/09/2025 - 05/09/2025$395 /nt
05/10/2025 - 05/10/2025$560 /nt
05/11/2025 - 05/11/2025$467 /nt
05/12/2025 - 05/12/2025$491 /nt
05/13/2025 - 05/13/2025$465 /nt
05/14/2025 - 05/14/2025$520 /nt
05/15/2025 - 05/15/2025$634 /nt
05/16/2025 - 05/16/2025$761 /nt
05/17/2025 - 05/17/2025$765 /nt
05/18/2025 - 05/18/2025$642 /nt
05/19/2025 - 05/19/2025$455 /nt
05/20/2025 - 05/20/2025$429 /nt
05/21/2025 - 05/21/2025$465 /nt
05/22/2025 - 05/22/2025$625 /nt
05/23/2025 - 05/23/2025$938 /nt
05/24/2025 - 05/24/2025$942 /nt
05/25/2025 - 05/25/2025$1,009 /nt
05/26/2025 - 05/26/2025$605 /nt
05/27/2025 - 05/27/2025$507 /nt
05/28/2025 - 05/28/2025$554 /nt
05/29/2025 - 05/29/2025$652 /nt
05/30/2025 - 05/30/2025$744 /nt
05/31/2025 - 05/31/2025$959 /nt
06/01/2025 - 06/01/2025$791 /nt
06/02/2025 - 06/02/2025$743 /nt
06/03/2025 - 06/03/2025$711 /nt
06/04/2025 - 06/04/2025$700 /nt
06/05/2025 - 06/05/2025$872 /nt
06/06/2025 - 06/06/2025$999 /nt
06/07/2025 - 06/07/2025$1,022 /nt
06/08/2025 - 06/08/2025$710 /nt
06/09/2025 - 06/09/2025$580 /nt
06/10/2025 - 06/10/2025$659 /nt
06/11/2025 - 06/11/2025$668 /nt
06/12/2025 - 06/12/2025$779 /nt
06/13/2025 - 06/13/2025$833 /nt
06/14/2025 - 06/14/2025$829 /nt
06/15/2025 - 06/15/2025$666 /nt
06/16/2025 - 06/16/2025$459 /nt
06/17/2025 - 06/17/2025$452 /nt
06/18/2025 - 06/18/2025$597 /nt
06/19/2025 - 06/19/2025$723 /nt
06/20/2025 - 06/20/2025$768 /nt
06/21/2025 - 06/21/2025$818 /nt
06/22/2025 - 06/22/2025$735 /nt
06/23/2025 - 06/23/2025$696 /nt
06/24/2025 - 06/24/2025$694 /nt
06/25/2025 - 06/25/2025$725 /nt
06/26/2025 - 06/26/2025$842 /nt
06/27/2025 - 06/27/2025$583 /nt
06/28/2025 - 06/28/2025$865 /nt
06/29/2025 - 06/29/2025$722 /nt
06/30/2025 - 06/30/2025$709 /nt
07/01/2025 - 07/01/2025$706 /nt
07/02/2025 - 07/02/2025$761 /nt
07/03/2025 - 07/03/2025$976 /nt
07/04/2025 - 07/04/2025$1,062 /nt
07/05/2025 - 07/05/2025$1,112 /nt
07/06/2025 - 07/06/2025$957 /nt
07/07/2025 - 07/07/2025$784 /nt
07/08/2025 - 07/08/2025$754 /nt
07/09/2025 - 07/09/2025$800 /nt
07/10/2025 - 07/10/2025$926 /nt
07/11/2025 - 07/11/2025$1,051 /nt
07/12/2025 - 07/12/2025$1,056 /nt
07/13/2025 - 07/13/2025$885 /nt
07/14/2025 - 07/14/2025$813 /nt
07/15/2025 - 07/15/2025$807 /nt
07/16/2025 - 07/16/2025$826 /nt
07/17/2025 - 07/17/2025$950 /nt
07/18/2025 - 07/18/2025$986 /nt
07/19/2025 - 07/19/2025$965 /nt
07/20/2025 - 07/20/2025$756 /nt
07/21/2025 - 07/21/2025$693 /nt
07/22/2025 - 07/22/2025$698 /nt
07/23/2025 - 07/23/2025$762 /nt
07/24/2025 - 07/24/2025$840 /nt
07/25/2025 - 07/25/2025$944 /nt
07/26/2025 - 07/26/2025$1,007 /nt
07/27/2025 - 07/27/2025$913 /nt
07/28/2025 - 07/28/2025$903 /nt
07/29/2025 - 07/29/2025$1,178 /nt
07/30/2025 - 07/30/2025$1,379 /nt
07/31/2025 - 07/31/2025$1,537 /nt
08/01/2025 - 08/01/2025$1,194 /nt
08/02/2025 - 08/02/2025$1,215 /nt
08/03/2025 - 08/03/2025$969 /nt
08/04/2025 - 08/04/2025$853 /nt
08/05/2025 - 08/05/2025$851 /nt
08/06/2025 - 08/06/2025$883 /nt
08/07/2025 - 08/07/2025$1,058 /nt
08/08/2025 - 08/08/2025$1,246 /nt
08/09/2025 - 08/09/2025$1,277 /nt
08/10/2025 - 08/10/2025$1,047 /nt
08/11/2025 - 08/11/2025$1,002 /nt
08/12/2025 - 08/12/2025$933 /nt
08/13/2025 - 08/13/2025$954 /nt
08/14/2025 - 08/14/2025$1,187 /nt
08/15/2025 - 08/15/2025$1,324 /nt
08/16/2025 - 08/16/2025$1,300 /nt
08/17/2025 - 08/17/2025$997 /nt
08/18/2025 - 08/18/2025$889 /nt
08/19/2025 - 08/19/2025$773 /nt
08/20/2025 - 08/20/2025$765 /nt
08/21/2025 - 08/21/2025$947 /nt
08/22/2025 - 08/22/2025$1,098 /nt
08/23/2025 - 08/23/2025$1,087 /nt
08/24/2025 - 08/24/2025$801 /nt
08/25/2025 - 08/25/2025$705 /nt
08/26/2025 - 08/26/2025$647 /nt
08/27/2025 - 08/27/2025$639 /nt
08/28/2025 - 08/28/2025$808 /nt
08/29/2025 - 08/29/2025$1,345 /nt
08/30/2025 - 08/30/2025$1,283 /nt
08/31/2025 - 08/31/2025$990 /nt
09/01/2025 - 09/01/2025$873 /nt
09/02/2025 - 09/02/2025$657 /nt
09/03/2025 - 09/03/2025$653 /nt
09/04/2025 - 09/04/2025$811 /nt
09/05/2025 - 09/05/2025$901 /nt
09/06/2025 - 09/06/2025$936 /nt
09/07/2025 - 09/07/2025$716 /nt
09/08/2025 - 09/08/2025$411 /nt
09/09/2025 - 09/10/2025$395 /nt
09/11/2025 - 09/11/2025$553 /nt
09/12/2025 - 09/12/2025$709 /nt
09/13/2025 - 09/13/2025$731 /nt
09/14/2025 - 09/14/2025$509 /nt
09/15/2025 - 09/15/2025$401 /nt
09/16/2025 - 09/16/2025$395 /nt
09/17/2025 - 09/17/2025$435 /nt
09/18/2025 - 09/18/2025$615 /nt
09/19/2025 - 09/19/2025$761 /nt
09/20/2025 - 09/20/2025$778 /nt
09/21/2025 - 09/21/2025$490 /nt
09/22/2025 - 09/22/2025$407 /nt
09/23/2025 - 09/23/2025$405 /nt
09/24/2025 - 09/24/2025$447 /nt
09/25/2025 - 09/25/2025$631 /nt
09/26/2025 - 09/26/2025$774 /nt
09/27/2025 - 09/27/2025$796 /nt
09/28/2025 - 09/28/2025$560 /nt
09/29/2025 - 09/29/2025$434 /nt
09/30/2025 - 09/30/2025$406 /nt
10/01/2025 - 10/01/2025$449 /nt
10/02/2025 - 10/02/2025$620 /nt
10/03/2025 - 10/03/2025$751 /nt
10/04/2025 - 10/04/2025$773 /nt
10/05/2025 - 10/05/2025$576 /nt
10/06/2025 - 10/06/2025$487 /nt
10/07/2025 - 10/07/2025$469 /nt
10/08/2025 - 10/08/2025$527 /nt
10/09/2025 - 10/09/2025$701 /nt
10/10/2025 - 10/10/2025$957 /nt
10/11/2025 - 10/11/2025$997 /nt
10/12/2025 - 10/12/2025$752 /nt
10/13/2025 - 10/13/2025$648 /nt
10/14/2025 - 10/14/2025$572 /nt
10/15/2025 - 10/15/2025$548 /nt
10/16/2025 - 10/16/2025$706 /nt
10/17/2025 - 10/17/2025$1,615 /nt
10/18/2025 - 10/18/2025$1,718 /nt
10/19/2025 - 10/19/2025$1,470 /nt
10/20/2025 - 10/20/2025$1,638 /nt
10/21/2025 - 10/21/2025$1,744 /nt
10/22/2025 - 10/22/2025$1,980 /nt
10/23/2025 - 10/23/2025$2,304 /nt
10/24/2025 - 10/24/2025$2,495 /nt
10/25/2025 - 10/25/2025$2,228 /nt
10/26/2025 - 10/26/2025$1,640 /nt
10/27/2025 - 10/27/2025$777 /nt
10/28/2025 - 10/28/2025$805 /nt
10/29/2025 - 10/29/2025$781 /nt
10/30/2025 - 10/30/2025$958 /nt
10/31/2025 - 10/31/2025$1,145 /nt
11/01/2025 - 11/01/2025$1,756 /nt
11/02/2025 - 11/02/2025$1,499 /nt
11/03/2025 - 11/03/2025$1,510 /nt
11/04/2025 - 11/04/2025$1,521 /nt
11/05/2025 - 11/05/2025$1,472 /nt
11/06/2025 - 11/06/2025$1,753 /nt
11/07/2025 - 11/07/2025$1,910 /nt
11/08/2025 - 11/08/2025$1,913 /nt
11/09/2025 - 11/09/2025$1,668 /nt
11/10/2025 - 11/10/2025$1,488 /nt
11/11/2025 - 11/11/2025$1,230 /nt
11/12/2025 - 11/12/2025$912 /nt
11/13/2025 - 11/13/2025$1,134 /nt
11/14/2025 - 11/14/2025$1,260 /nt
11/15/2025 - 11/15/2025$1,317 /nt
11/16/2025 - 11/16/2025$1,097 /nt
11/17/2025 - 11/17/2025$944 /nt
11/18/2025 - 11/18/2025$997 /nt
11/19/2025 - 11/19/2025$1,010 /nt
11/20/2025 - 11/20/2025$1,238 /nt
11/21/2025 - 11/21/2025$1,323 /nt
11/22/2025 - 11/22/2025$1,320 /nt
11/23/2025 - 11/23/2025$1,042 /nt
11/24/2025 - 11/24/2025$824 /nt
11/25/2025 - 11/25/2025$1,235 /nt
11/26/2025 - 11/26/2025$1,211 /nt
11/27/2025 - 11/27/2025$1,393 /nt
11/28/2025 - 11/28/2025$1,510 /nt
11/29/2025 - 11/29/2025$1,073 /nt
11/30/2025 - 11/30/2025$871 /nt
12/01/2025 - 12/01/2025$757 /nt
12/02/2025 - 12/02/2025$788 /nt
12/03/2025 - 12/03/2025$823 /nt
12/04/2025 - 12/04/2025$1,421 /nt
12/05/2025 - 12/05/2025$1,683 /nt
12/06/2025 - 12/06/2025$1,711 /nt
12/07/2025 - 12/07/2025$1,048 /nt
12/08/2025 - 12/08/2025$948 /nt
12/09/2025 - 12/09/2025$922 /nt
12/10/2025 - 12/10/2025$930 /nt
12/11/2025 - 12/11/2025$1,065 /nt
12/12/2025 - 12/12/2025$1,579 /nt
12/13/2025 - 12/13/2025$1,502 /nt
12/14/2025 - 12/14/2025$1,333 /nt
12/15/2025 - 12/15/2025$966 /nt
12/16/2025 - 12/16/2025$920 /nt
12/17/2025 - 12/17/2025$909 /nt
12/18/2025 - 12/18/2025$1,012 /nt
12/19/2025 - 12/19/2025$1,381 /nt
12/20/2025 - 12/20/2025$1,390 /nt
12/21/2025 - 12/21/2025$1,412 /nt
12/22/2025 - 12/22/2025$1,452 /nt
12/23/2025 - 12/23/2025$1,514 /nt
12/24/2025 - 12/24/2025$1,711 /nt
12/25/2025 - 12/25/2025$1,748 /nt
12/26/2025 - 12/26/2025$2,192 /nt
12/27/2025 - 12/27/2025$2,234 /nt
12/28/2025 - 12/28/2025$2,412 /nt
12/29/2025 - 12/29/2025$2,525 /nt
12/30/2025 - 12/30/2025$2,548 /nt
12/31/2025 - 12/31/2025$2,615 /nt
01/01/2026 - 01/01/2026$2,642 /nt
01/02/2026 - 01/02/2026$1,992 /nt
01/03/2026 - 01/03/2026$1,993 /nt
01/04/2026 - 01/04/2026$1,954 /nt
01/05/2026 - 01/05/2026$1,353 /nt
01/06/2026 - 01/06/2026$1,284 /nt
01/07/2026 - 01/07/2026$1,227 /nt
01/08/2026 - 01/08/2026$1,279 /nt
01/09/2026 - 01/09/2026$1,474 /nt
01/10/2026 - 01/10/2026$1,505 /nt
01/11/2026 - 01/11/2026$1,365 /nt
01/12/2026 - 01/12/2026$1,188 /nt
01/13/2026 - 01/13/2026$1,167 /nt
01/14/2026 - 01/14/2026$1,202 /nt
01/15/2026 - 01/15/2026$1,687 /nt
01/16/2026 - 01/16/2026$1,858 /nt
01/17/2026 - 01/17/2026$2,054 /nt
01/18/2026 - 01/18/2026$1,870 /nt
01/19/2026 - 01/19/2026$1,506 /nt
01/20/2026 - 01/20/2026$1,493 /nt
01/21/2026 - 01/21/2026$1,525 /nt
01/22/2026 - 01/22/2026$1,641 /nt
01/23/2026 - 01/23/2026$1,745 /nt
01/24/2026 - 01/24/2026$1,775 /nt
01/25/2026 - 01/25/2026$1,316 /nt
01/26/2026 - 01/26/2026$1,522 /nt
01/27/2026 - 01/27/2026$1,588 /nt
01/28/2026 - 01/28/2026$1,574 /nt
01/29/2026 - 01/29/2026$1,394 /nt
01/30/2026 - 01/30/2026$1,476 /nt
01/31/2026 - 01/31/2026$1,504 /nt
02/01/2026 - 02/01/2026$1,406 /nt
02/02/2026 - 02/02/2026$1,363 /nt
02/03/2026 - 02/03/2026$1,401 /nt
02/04/2026 - 02/04/2026$1,477 /nt
02/05/2026 - 02/05/2026$1,611 /nt
02/06/2026 - 02/06/2026$1,707 /nt
02/07/2026 - 02/07/2026$1,758 /nt
02/08/2026 - 02/08/2026$1,626 /nt
02/09/2026 - 02/09/2026$1,613 /nt
02/10/2026 - 02/10/2026$1,602 /nt
02/11/2026 - 02/11/2026$1,640 /nt
02/12/2026 - 02/12/2026$2,094 /nt
02/13/2026 - 02/13/2026$2,004 /nt
02/14/2026 - 02/14/2026$2,220 /nt
02/15/2026 - 02/15/2026$2,034 /nt
02/16/2026 - 02/16/2026$2,027 /nt
02/17/2026 - 02/17/2026$1,646 /nt
02/18/2026 - 02/18/2026$1,730 /nt
02/19/2026 - 02/19/2026$1,849 /nt
02/20/2026 - 02/20/2026$1,900 /nt
02/21/2026 - 02/21/2026$1,908 /nt
02/22/2026 - 02/22/2026$1,795 /nt
02/23/2026 - 02/23/2026$1,770 /nt
02/24/2026 - 02/24/2026$1,740 /nt
02/25/2026 - 02/25/2026$1,741 /nt
02/26/2026 - 02/26/2026$1,774 /nt
02/27/2026 - 02/27/2026$1,791 /nt
02/28/2026 - 02/28/2026$1,781 /nt
03/01/2026 - 03/01/2026$1,684 /nt
03/02/2026 - 03/02/2026$1,674 /nt
03/03/2026 - 03/03/2026$1,665 /nt
03/04/2026 - 03/04/2026$1,688 /nt
03/05/2026 - 03/05/2026$1,753 /nt
03/06/2026 - 03/06/2026$2,203 /nt
03/07/2026 - 03/07/2026$2,218 /nt
03/08/2026 - 03/08/2026$2,142 /nt
03/09/2026 - 03/09/2026$2,154 /nt
03/10/2026 - 03/10/2026$2,149 /nt
03/11/2026 - 03/11/2026$2,171 /nt
03/12/2026 - 03/12/2026$2,233 /nt
03/13/2026 - 03/13/2026$2,257 /nt
03/14/2026 - 03/14/2026$2,260 /nt
03/15/2026 - 03/15/2026$1,740 /nt
03/16/2026 - 03/16/2026$1,733 /nt
03/17/2026 - 03/18/2026$1,708 /nt
03/19/2026 - 03/19/2026$1,755 /nt
03/20/2026 - 03/20/2026$1,765 /nt
03/21/2026 - 03/21/2026$1,754 /nt
03/22/2026 - 03/22/2026$1,610 /nt
03/23/2026 - 03/23/2026$1,601 /nt
03/24/2026 - 03/24/2026$1,580 /nt
03/25/2026 - 03/25/2026$1,605 /nt
03/26/2026 - 03/26/2026$1,686 /nt
03/27/2026 - 03/27/2026$1,732 /nt
03/28/2026 - 03/28/2026$1,734 /nt
03/29/2026 - 03/29/2026$1,572 /nt
03/30/2026 - 03/30/2026$1,565 /nt
03/31/2026 - 03/31/2026$1,543 /nt
04/01/2026 - 04/01/2026$1,565 /nt
04/02/2026 - 04/02/2026$1,653 /nt
04/03/2026 - 04/03/2026$1,697 /nt
04/04/2026 - 04/04/2026$1,688 /nt
04/05/2026 - 04/05/2026$1,494 /nt
04/06/2026 - 04/06/2026$1,457 /nt
04/07/2026 - 04/07/2026$1,426 /nt
04/08/2026 - 04/08/2026$1,435 /nt
04/09/2026 - 04/09/2026$1,533 /nt
04/10/2026 - 04/10/2026$1,569 /nt
04/11/2026 - 04/11/2026$1,534 /nt
04/12/2026 - 04/12/2026$1,280 /nt
04/13/2026 - 04/13/2026$1,185 /nt
04/14/2026 - 04/14/2026$1,162 /nt
04/15/2026 - 04/15/2026$1,206 /nt
04/16/2026 - 04/16/2026$1,359 /nt
04/17/2026 - 04/17/2026$1,433 /nt
04/18/2026 - 04/18/2026$1,750 /nt
04/19/2026 - 04/19/2026$1,196 /nt
04/20/2026 - 04/20/2026$1,124 /nt
04/21/2026 - 04/21/2026$1,105 /nt
04/22/2026 - 04/22/2026$1,181 /nt
04/23/2026 - 04/23/2026$1,370 /nt
04/24/2026 - 04/24/2026$1,451 /nt
04/25/2026 - 04/25/2026$1,462 /nt
04/26/2026 - 04/26/2026$1,203 /nt
04/27/2026 - 04/27/2026$1,114 /nt
04/28/2026 - 04/28/2026$1,079 /nt
04/29/2026 - 04/29/2026$1,160 /nt
04/30/2026 - 04/30/2026$1,378 /nt
05/01/2026 - 05/01/2026$1,481 /nt
05/02/2026 - 05/02/2026$1,466 /nt
05/03/2026 - 05/03/2026$1,190 /nt
05/04/2026 - 05/04/2026$1,082 /nt
05/05/2026 - 05/05/2026$1,036 /nt
05/06/2026 - 05/06/2026$1,136 /nt
05/07/2026 - 05/07/2026$1,354 /nt
05/08/2026 - 05/08/2026$1,466 /nt
05/09/2026 - 05/09/2026$1,479 /nt
4.8977
(88 Review)

Wonderful Vacation Rental

April 2025
, Woodbridge, CA US

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Captain's Quarters was a perfect place for a small group of 6 to celebrate a birthday. I would not recommend more than 6.

This place is old, so expect some creaky floors and small inconveniences.

TLDR;
1. Location is good, only a few blocks from Duval
2. House is very old, but the rental company keeps up with the age.
3. Pool is nice to have on those hot days.
4. Kitchen is well stocked for cooking.
5. Main bathroom is not good for older or shorter people.

A quick trip

April 2025
, Raleigh, NC United States

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Beautiful and serene property. Very clean and well stocked. Excellent location with lots of walkability. Generally quiet neighborhood, with some over head plane noise (near impossible to avoid that in KW though). Only issue was that the master bathroom toilet had issues flushing without opening the tank lid. So we opted to use other bathrooms during our stay.

Wonderful

February 2025
, Towson, MD United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

9 ladies thoroughly enjoyed this place for a long weekend. We spent most of our time by the pool which is in a lovely position for sun all afternoon. They gave us plenty of towels and the kitchen was well appointed. We also enjoyed mornings on the front porch. We liked the neighborhood- very quiet and residential with close shops and restaurants. The home itself was very charming with its wood interior and high ceilings. We can’t wait to plan another trip back to enjoy this rental.

Nice home in need of some love

February 2025
, North Haven, CT United States

Overall
3
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
3
Location
1
Property condition
2

This home is in need of some attention. It was dusty and looks nothing like the picture. It is quite along walk to the major Key West attractions. Planes fly over so much, and a lot on the weekends. It seems to never stop. It is extremely loud and the planes are very low. We had an issue with the shower drain and they sent someone out very quickly. The kitchen is in need of attention and the front gate was hanging off to one side because the latch is broken. The pool area was the best part. It’s very warm and we really enjoyed that. The shared bathroom is odd and the shower is a bit hard to navigate. It’s a big step in and difficult to get out of. Cute but not very functional.

Wonderful Getaway

January 2025
, Kirkwood, MO US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house is charming. It is very well laid out and easily accommodated 8 of us (4 bedrooms (one is outside in a little attached cottage). The pool and pool area are fantastic. It is slightly off the beaten track so quiet, but still in walking distance if everything. Will stay here again!

Authentic Key West Vibe

January 2025
, Pittsburgh, PA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

We spent 4 days and 3 nights. Captains Quarters was wonderful. Great location with avg Lyft cost of $8. Loved the front porch and the neighborhood. Keep in mind there is an early noise ordinances at 8pm so you need to be mindful at the pool if night swimming. Woke up with the chickens every morning and relaxed in this home. The bathtub is high and for older folk would be difficult but there are two other showers one outdoors which was great under the stars! The beds and pillows were top notch and we all slept very well. Biggest issue was the deck door to the pool was very difficult to open. It stuck a lot. Thank you to the host for the great communication and I highly recommend using their free concierge service. We had food waiting for us after a very stressful travel day. They really aided in our decompression. I will be back and will stay here again.

Review of the captain quarter

January 2025
, Ballston Spa, NY US

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
3
Property condition
3

Overall the house was great. It was very “key west” from architecture to interior design. It was clean and everything worked (appliances, air conditioners, fans, etc.). It’s a little off the beaten path if you are interested in Duval street activities but that could be a positive if you aren’t. There were a couple of little things that could be addressed. The shower in the 2nd bathroom doesn’t drain well and if you are traveling with more than 6 people it’s a little tight. And the clean up requirements for the guests (basically have to clean the whole house) are a little much based off of how much you spend on the rental.

Excellent House

November 2024
, Weston, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Everything was as expected. The house is beautiful and well kept. Location (close to Duval), heated pool (very clean), house amenities and home management company were all excellent. I would def stay here again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Debra! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Bachelor trip October 2024

October 2024
, Monroe, LA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This house was amazing! Extremely clean and had everything we needed! The pool was way bigger than we thought and Melanie was more than happy to heat it for us which was Awesome! We felt very secure and there was plenty of room for eight adults. All of our activities were easy to get to, but our location was quiet and peaceful. Melanie answered the phone, no matter what time I called her. She could not have been more attentive than she was. We enjoyed the separate dining room area, the washer and dryer were appreciated and the kitchen was amazing.Bathrooms were pretty and everything worked great. We were within walking distance of a grocery store, liquor store, other small restaurants, and Duval Street was easily walkable. We did have a golf cart for getting around and it was always easy to find parking close to the house. We would definitely stay here again!

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Kim, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Amazing Time at Captain's Quarters

September 2024
, Hobe Sound, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

First of all, stunning historical home and very clean. Every single room was perfectly appointed with antiques and nautical art. We started off with touring each room checking out all the details.The kitchen had everything we needed to cook at home and saved a ton of money not eating out. The pool outside was incredible, deep and the perfect temperature. We had a ball taking a break from the sweltering mid-day heat and enjoyed the pool and snacks at home. The front and backyard were so private it felt like our own little oasis. The management was very communicative and accommodating. I would love to stay again. This is truly a Key West dream home.

Manager's Response

We are so happy you found this property and its location ideal for your get away in Key West. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit!

Lovely Home

August 2024
, SPRINGBORO, OH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The home is beautiful and clean. It is located
in a quite area with a lovely swimming pool in the back. The home is well equipped with anything you may need such as hair dryers, ironing board and iron. Restaurants are close by as well as a grocery and liquor store within walking distance. We were lucky to be able to check in at 12:00 instead of waiting until 4:00. I would consider renting this property in the future.

Manager's Response

We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us! We would love to welcome you back!

Amazing house !!!

July 2024
, Charleston, WV US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

everything you need while staying in Key West

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review, we are so glad the property met your needs while staying with us. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit Key West.

Captain's Quarters Update

June 2024
, PADUCAH, KY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
5

Our "friends" vacation to Key West was unforgettable. We really enjoyed staying at the Captain's Quarters. We had four bedrooms, plenty of bathroom space, a great kitchen and dining area, and a beautiful, private pool. We could not have asked for a better experience. Our property manager, Melanie, was helpful and accommodating. She sent us perfect directions, explanations, and suggestions for our stay. We rented golf carts, buzzed throughout the area, enjoyed great food and tourist attractions, and commented to one another on everyone's friendliness, courtesy, and helpfulness. Excellent vacation.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Amazing!

May 2024
, Rockland, MA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Property was incredible. Everything you could want and more. Clean and well equipped. Great for family gathering while allowing everyone their space. And our host melanie was a star

Manager's Response

We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us! We would love to welcome you back!

Beautiful backyard oasis

April 2024
, Green Bay, WI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

The house was clean and well maintained. Stocked with essentials. The backyard was a wonderful, private space with lots of lounge chairs and outdoor seating. Plenty of room for 6 adults.

Manager's Response

We are so happy you found this property and its location ideal for your get away in Key West. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit!

Celebration of life

April 2024
, Coral Gables, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We got together as a family to celebrate my father-in-law‘s life. A third generation conch that has lived his life in Key West.
Captain’s Quarters was perfect.

Manager's Response

We are so happy you found this property and its location ideal to celebrate your father in law's life. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit our beautiful island!

Fantastic house!

March 2024
, Daphne, AL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house was absolutely beautiful! Favorite part was the pool and the front porch for sure! Management company was wonderful to work with! They were extremely responsive and informative!

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Jackie! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Captain's Quarter 2 Day Stay

March 2024
, columbus, OH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Awesome

Manager's Response

Thank you for this short and sweet five star review, we hope to have the pleasure to host you again next time you visit the island.

ahhhmazing

February 2024
, st pete beach , FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We really enjoyed our stay. The house was very clean and comfortable. We had a larger group and the home had everything we needed.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We are thrilled you loved this home and hope to host you again soon!

KW Group

February 2024
, Erie, MI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
4
Property condition
4

The house was exactly what we were looking for, it handled all 9 of us great. Good location, short walk or Uber to anything in minutes.

Manager's Response

Thank you for sharing a review of your recent experience. Our team here at Best of Key West Rentals is committed to providing high-quality guest service, and we’re thrilled to hear that we made a good impression on you. We hope you’ll visit us again soon.

Enjoyable stay!

November 2023
, Comstock, MN US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

We had 10 people and accmodated us well. Only suggestion is to have mirrors in all bedrooms with a large group. Very satisfied with property!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We are thrilled you loved this home and hope to host you again soon!

Best kept secret.

November 2023
, Bristol, PA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house was lovely.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this short and sweet five star review, we hope to have the pleasure to host you again next time you visit the island.

A lovely and comfortable stay

October 2023
, Fort Myers, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

We had a great weekend stay at the Captain's Quarters. The house and pool were lovely. We had everything we needed and were close to a bike rental which is a great way to travel around Key West. Check in and out were easy. Thank you

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Terri! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Best in Stay 2023

September 2023
, Waldorf, MD US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Our stay at the Captain’s Quarters was a perfect setting for a birthday trip! The house is uniquely decorated, and the wood paneling keeps the house cool during the sticky days. All the amenities were spot on, and the pool was a perfect spot to sit and enjoy the day. What made our stay perfect was the quick response from Melaine. Her response time was short, and she offered to go above and beyond for each of our asks! We would not only recommend staying with our family and friends but will be returning!!

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Lacey, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Wonderful backyard

June 2023
, Galena, OH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Absolutely loved this house! It had tons of space inside and was decorated so cute. The backyard is amazing with a huge pool and had plenty of seating. It was a very short golf cart ride to all restaurants and bars. I would definitely rent this house again!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Joanne. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Nice Key West Getaway

June 2023
, Chicago, IL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

Nice home to come back to after a long day out n about in Key West. Comfort and coziness for a restful and fun stay. Relaxing backyard pool area to beat the heat! A 20-30 min walk to the main Duval Street activities.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Dan. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Best Place and Best Value.

May 2023
, Laguna Niguel CA, CA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great house in great location. Everyone really enjoyed it. The pool and BBQ made outside living really nice. There is a cool market right around the corner so that made it nice. It looks like 8 people could sleep here comfortably, we only had 4. It is about a 15 minute walk to Duval St. but very doable.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review Chris. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Girl's Trip-Key West

April 2023
, Lawrence, MI United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Captain's Quarters worked well for 8 women there to take-in Key West. Great location-able to walk to Duval, marina area& local stores/restaurants. Enjoyed the pool area for relaxing.

Manager's Response

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay Donna. We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

CAPTAIN'S QUARTERS

March 2023
, Charlotte, NC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

CAPTAIN'S QUARTERS was as described and ready for our arrival We only hope that is available for all our future visits to Key West This was perfect spot

Manager's Response

Thank you for taking the time to post a review of our property Scott. We are so happy to hear that you enjoyed your time in Key West. Our goal is always to exceed your expectations! If there's anything we can help you with during your next visit, please don't hesitate to let us know.

Wonderful Getaway in the Keys

March 2023
, North Liberty, IA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Relaxing, well-kept property - close to the beach, harbor, and Duval street. The heated pool was a huge plus. Parking was hit or miss depending on the time of day.

Manager's Response

We are so happy you found this property and its location ideal for your get away in Key West Amy. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit!

Captains Quarters - The perfect Key West vacation rental!

February 2023
, Hilton Head Island, SC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house was not only charming - it was the perfect size for our family of 10. The backyard and pool were where we spent most of our time. The location is ideal in that you can walk one way to the beach, or head the other way to Mallory Square. We rented a wagon for the littlest guests. Truman & Company is a stellar vacation management company. Melanie was delightful and helped us with anything we needed. Check in and check out couldn’t be easier! I highly recommend them.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your incredible review Lynn! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this Key West retreat and we are looking forward to hosting you again next time you visit the island. Thank you for being our guest!

Great Escape

December 2022
, Mahopac, NY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Celebrated a 50th Birthday in Key West with 9 other friends. House was clean, spacious, beds were comfortable. Kitchen needs some attention. Outside pool area was beautiful. Many loose bricks on the walkway around the house, have to be careful. Pool was heated and clean.

Manager's Response

Thank you for bringing these concerns to our attention Barbara. We will share your feedback with our team and address the issues you mentioned. We are glad you enjoyed your celebratory get away with your friends and hope to welcome you again next time you visit key West!

Gem in Key West

November 2022
, Ann Arbor, MI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Lovely place to stay! We stayed here with 7 adults comfortably. It's a beautiful home with character. It's kept nice, clean and a great location. Since it was winter and dark early we mostly called cars to go to Duval Street at night but it could be walkable. The back yard is nice with a heated pool, lounge chairs for everyone, table and grill. The outdoor shower is a nice addition. It would comfortable stay 8 adults, any more they would have to go in the small living room and it would be tight. Would be a nice house to rent with kids as well. Felt safe and the front gate locked. Communication with the property manager was great! Awesome cuban coffee around the corner.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Melissa, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

A gem in Key West

October 2022
, LUTHERVILLE TIMONIUM, MD US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

A beautiful house in a quiet neighborhood but close enough to the nightlife for a perfect blend. Pool, deck, BBQ, 4 bedrooms, large kitchen makes for a great stay.

Manager's Response

We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us Chris! Thank you for being our guest!

Quick Getaway

September 2022
, Versailles, OH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This place was quite the charming place and exactly what we were looking for. We were approx 4 blocks from Duvall Street so if we wanted just a quick walk uptown, there was no need for a uber. The house was very roomy and it was nice to have the pool to ourselves. We would definitely stay here again. We were able to check in early and had no issues with working with the Property Manager.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Lori! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

It was great places

July 2022
, Lilburn, GA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The houses was perfect for me and my family
and it was clean too.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review William. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Great location!!

July 2022
, Beaufort, NC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

It was so convenient and well appointed. Had everything we needed. Enjoyed the pool in the evening after being out on the hot days. We biked everywhere we went.

Manager's Response

We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us Joyce! We would love to welcome you back!

A Truly Great Stay!

June 2022
, Brookfield, WI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Our group of 9 thoroughly enjoyed our stay. Lots of space, great bedrooms, and we loved the pool and back patio! The management company was always quick to respond and answer questions. We would definitely stay here again!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Sarah. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Captain's Quarters

May 2022
, Birmingham, AL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This is a great place to stay and had everything we needed. Loved the pool and all.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review! It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Great house

May 2022
, Virginia Beach, VA US

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
4
Property condition
5

Great location
Nice pool

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Timothy. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Great Key West Home!

May 2022
, Shelby Township, MI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

Such a great home in Key West! So clean and spacious. The pool was definitely the best part! Our primary contact, Melanie, was very helpful and kind over the phone and made sure we had everything we needed during our stay. I would definitely recommend this home to a medium sized group of family or friends.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Clare. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Best Rental Yet!

May 2022
, Burlington, NC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We couldn’t have found a more accommodating rental (thank you Melanie!) for our girls trip! Very close to Duval, restaurants and the Faustos Grocery store right around the corner was a def plus! Loved the fact that Sandy’s cafe right around the corner delivered breakfast every morning and it was delish! Would definitely stay here again....and again!!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your incredible review Sherrie! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this Key West retreat and we are looking forward to hosting you again next time you visit the island. Thank you for being our guest!

Captain Quarters Getaway

April 2022
, Charlotte, NC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We loved our stay at Key West Captain Quarters. The house was beautiful and the outside pool area was the icing on the cake. We appreciate the accommodations made when we arrived before check in time too. We highly recommend this home to any families/group visiting Key West.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Diane. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Key West

April 2022
, Comstock Park, MI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Wonderful property!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review Eric. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Captains Quarters - The absolute best!

March 2022
, Seven Hills, OH United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This was our second time staying at this property and it once again did not disappoint! We 100% recommend this property and definitely plan to stay there again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Michelle. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

A Fantastic Stay in Key West

January 2022
, Chicago, IL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

We loved our stay at Captain's Quarters. There were 7 of us and we never felt as if we were on top of each other. The house was clean. The pool was amazing (and cleaned twice a week). The location was good. It's a little farther from most places you want to go in Key West, but not too far and away from the noise indeed. We spent our time walking more than Ubering. I dare say the Pool House bedroom may be the best in the bunch, separated from the main house, but next to an outdoor shower and connected to a bathroom. Also, Melanie, at the management company was extremely responsive with any request or need. We could not have asked for more. I definitely recommend this property for your Key West stay.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Henry, we are so glad you and your group enjoyed the property so much! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Fabulous Family Vacation

December 2021
, Cicero, IN US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Awesome! It is a beautiful home that exudes charm and character. The whole family loved the design, layout, decor, everything! Private pool and beautifully landscaped backyard, so relaxing!
Perfect location for everything, a short block to Fausto's and Sandy's had us very spoiled. Both the rental experience and the management company were wonderful. We so much appreciate the flexibility afforded us when we had to delay our trip due to COVID lockdown over a year ago. It was so worth the wait and VRBO, Truman, and Zintsmaster helped make this our best vacation ever. Thanks to Zintsmaster for recommending and reserving Viva on New Year's Eve. Wonderful way to end the old year and welcome 2022! We definitely will be back! Thank you all so much.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this fantastic review Marcia! We are thrilled you and your family had the best vacation ever and hope you welcome you again next time you visit the island!

Perfect Location for Key West Trip!

December 2021
, Green Cove Springs, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

The location was perfect as you're not far away from Duval street which is about a half mile walk down the road. You're also far enough away from party goers you won't be disturbed. No complaints except you won't be able to turn the heat up on the pool as it's locked at 84 degrees. There was one night cool enough we wished we could have turned it up a little. A minor annoyance was the main shower ran out of hot water pretty quickly and the shower head looks nice, but the water pressure coming out was not great. I used a different shower and got much hotter water and better pressure. We knew someone would be coming to clean the pool and someone else to clean the grounds. I would recommend to the owners to have the grounds keeper come first before the pool cleaner as the ground keepers blows off the back yard and lots of debris ended up in the perfectly clean pool and I had to clean it all out before we could use the pool. As far as Parking is concerned, we missed the fact you are not SUPPOSED to park on the street in front of the house and there is no parking on the property. We found a spot in front of the house off the street and left it to chance if we received a $50 parking fine. Luckily, we stayed for 6 days and never received a fine. :) I believe the parking garages charge $32 per day so we felt like the $18 difference would be worth it being able to park our car right in front of the house. Other recommendations: We ate at Blue Heaven which was fantastic and worth the wait! Sushi Song was right down the road and open until like 3 am! We ordered it for delivery and it was great! Lobster rolls at DJ's clam shack is a must featured on Dives, Diners, and Drive-ins. Not much seating though. And lastly, our family enjoyed the Butterfly garden which was just amazing and not to mention a nice spot to cool off for minute.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Dace, we are thrilled you enjoyed your stay at Captain's Quarters. We are taking note of the small issues you encountered and will be addressing them right away.

We hope to host you again next time you visit the island!

Superior Experience

October 2021
, Sparta, NJ US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a fantastic time. The quality of the house was stellar and the location ideal. Very clean and the property manager was extremely responsive and helpful. Its a great place to enjoy Key West.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Bruce, we are glad your experience was superior and hope you will be staying with us again next time you visit Key West!

Beautiful and Conveniently Located Key West Home

October 2021
, Livonia, MI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had an amazing time in this home. It's really conveniently located. We had a party store less than a block away for refreshments, Sandy's Cuban counter restaurant for food, breakfast and fantastic coffee and a short bike ride away from everywhere else we wanted to go. The home itself was perfectly sized, even for 8 adults. The manager was really accommodating with any of our requests. The only warning is the 5 day trash pickup process that occurs before 6 a.m. There's a day where a guy comes to put the trash cans out, comes another day for different trash cans, trash pickup occurs on two days then another day to bring the cans back. I'm assuming it's done so early for a reason, but I would warn guests in advance because it's loud and alarming to hear people within the gates, dragging cans across rocks that early.

Manager's Response

We are so glad you enjoyed your stay so much Toni! We are sorry to hear the trash pick up disturbed you, they only come once a week so we have someone get it out and in that same day but that's it. We have no control over the city's schedule but hope you will come and stay with us again next time you visit the island!

A wonderful place to stay!

September 2021
, Norwood, NJ US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The property was absolutely beautiful and conveniently located, rooms were clean and comfortable.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Mary. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

Great house with lots of character

June 2021
, Rock Hill, SC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Had a great time. House was very nice and comfortable. Rental agent was very responsive and easy to work with.

Manager's Response

We are so glad you had a great stay with us Rick, we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit Key West!

5 stars***

May 2021
, Davie , FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

great rental property and the property manager was amazing! very responsive to text messages and was extremely pleasant to work with. will definitely be back!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We are so happy you had a great time and hope to see you again!

Birthday vacation!

April 2021
, Mayslanding, NJ Unknown

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

The property I rented was awesome(despite the outside needed a huge cosmetic makeover ) . The house was perfect for my family. The beds were very comfortable and overall we enjoyed the house very much. The pool/ deck area was our primary hangout place.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you again soon!

Wonderful

April 2021
, Milton, MA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Clean, Roomy, Charming home a mile or so to shops, beach. We loved the big lizards that came to say hello at the pool they don’t bother you and are neat to see. The bedrooms are comfortable-I stayed in the bungalow off of the pool - a real Key West vacation. The Airplanes fly low and directly above the pool -my dad being a pilot-I loved it! Pool very nice-we spent much time swimming-nice relaxing porch front of house for a change of scenery. Def recommend and will be back. Suggestion-Fly into Key West airport it is a very short cab ride to and from location.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your kind words. We enjoyed hosting you in Paradise and hope to see you back soon!

Perfect Spot

March 2021
, Spring, TX US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Pool area sold the property, enough room for 8 to chill and not have to deal with a busy beach! Close walk to good food, shopping and the Marina. A perfect spot to Celebrate my 50th Birthday with fiends and family!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. Please come back and see us soon!

AMAZING1

February 2021
, Seven Hills, OH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

As a group of friends that go to KW every year - this by far was the best place we have stayed! The home is absolutely charming and the pool is amazing. Super convenient location with a full grocery near by. Book this home - you wont be disappointed! We are already planning to go back for our trip next year!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your recent review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back again soon!

Quaint Historic Home Close to All the Sites

February 2021
, Vancouver, BC CA

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
4

We stayed at this lovely historic home for 4 days and found it very comfortable. It is close to Duval street so you can walk to all the restaurants, shops and sites. The pool is very warm and we really enjoyed lounging around the pool during our stay and using the barbecue. The home is also full of very interesting antiques and vintage pieces which makes it a very special home to stay at.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your recent review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back soon!

We Can't Wait Till Next Year

January 2021
, Knoxville, TN United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

A group of 6 adults have been traveling to Key West for the past 5 years. This is the best house we have stayed! All the rooms are large and everything in on one level. The best part is the pool. It is hard to find a full size pool and ample pool deck space and this house has both! We hope to stay again next year!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back again soon!

Great Get-a-way

January 2021
, Ft. Wright, KY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a fantastic time. The house was amazing and extremely clean. There were 10 of us and we all had plenty of room. I chose to sleep in the guest house which was absolutely amazing. We left the door and window open all night along with the fan running and had a fantastic cross breeze. It was very centrally located and we walked or biked to everything. As you can imagine our favorite spot was by the pool. Thank you for a great experience.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your kind words. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you again very soon!

Christmas at Captains Quarters

December 2020
, HERSHEY, PA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Loved the property, well kept and maintained. The private pool was a huge plus. Melanie Wilson was very professional and helpful.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review! We hope to see you again soon!

Fantastic!

October 2020
, Annapolis, MD US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We absolutely loved this house! It was clean, beautiful and just as described. The management company was responsive and quick to act when we complained about the pool heater, they came right out and turned it off. The concierge service was a great help in booking reservations and bike rentals, delivered right to the house! We loved it, and next time I am in Key West I'll definitely plan to stay here again. The location was great, a quick 3-5 minute bike ride anywhere on the island, right around the corner from a grocery store, a liquor store and the best cuban sandwiches (Sandy's). Oh, and an outdoor shower which isn't advertised but was a great surprise! Two thumbs up!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you again soon.

Awesome House

October 2020
, Longwood, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Very cool house with a great backyard! Pool was a perfect way to cool off after exploring and after a long day of fishing. Will be back.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to see you back soon!

Fabulous Home in a Quiet Neighborhood!

July 2020
, Dunn, NC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a wonderful stay at Captain’s Quarters. The home was perfect for our group of 5 adults and 4 kids (9, 10, 13, 14). The pool area was very private and we spent most of our time there swimming or lounging. There was ample seating for us! The house is gorgeous and the beds were comfy. We cooked more than we originally anticipated, but with fresh fish from a fishing excursion, the kitchen provided everything we needed to whip up several tasty meals. We enjoyed walking to Sandy’s to grab coffee and breakfast-just around the corner. Cuban coffee, pastries, and Cuban sandwiches were delicious! There is also a market that had everything we needed very close as well. Great location in a quiet neighborhood but an easy bike ride to Higgs beach to catch beautiful sunrises. Duval St is walkable but we preferred to bike. Even with kids we were able to bike there within 10 minutes. The property manager, Melanie, was excellent and available for anything we needed.

Manager's Response

Thank you so much for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to host you again soon.

Captain's Quarters Key West

March 2020
, Memphis, TN United States

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
4

Nice house in a great location with an even nicer pool.

Manager's Response

Dear John,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and we hope to see you again.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Captain's Quarters Key West

March 2020
, Memphis, TN United States

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
4

Nice house, great pool, great location.

Manager's Response

Dear John,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and we hope to see you again.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Gorgeous Home

February 2020
, Holmen, WI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

The Captain’s Quarters was absolutely perfect! The home was spacious and very clean. The pool area was exceptional! Location was a little further from Duval than we were used to staying, but with car services so readily available it was never a problem. If walking isn’t your thing, consider renting a bike or scooter. The neighbor is residential- felt quiet and safe. Would definitely recommend!

Manager's Response

Dear Laura,


Thank you for your review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this home and hope to see you back soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Very Nice House

February 2020
, Hyannisport, MA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

Three generations of our extended family , ranging in age from 1 up to 65 enjoyed this house in Feb 2020. Rooms are large and ceilings are high so we never felt crowded. Pool is large too.We recommend the house, but did find it a bit far from Duval and "the action". We like to walk places, but would suggest bikes and/or car.

Manager's Response

Dear Jeffrey,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you loved this home. This home is desirably located for those that want to be close to downtown but far enough for some peace and quiet. We hope you had a wonderful vacation!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Capt Qtrs Key West

February 2020
, Fort Myers Fl, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Celebrating a 60th anniversary with family

Manager's Response

Dear Bernard,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you in the future!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great Stay!

January 2020
, Williamsburg, IA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We loved our stay at Captain Quarters! We had a group of 4 couples. Captains Quarters was a great place to stay the house is exactly what you think Key West should be. It was a great central location. We loved the central location and there were some great restaurants near by. We will be recommending this house to all of our friends.

Manager's Response

Dear Eric,


Thank you for your incredible review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and we hope to see you back soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Key west adventure

December 2019
, Fenton, MI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Excellent. Pool was amazing. Location was perfect. Character of home was nice. Only small issue was not enough silverware for ten of us. And some of the towel hooks came out of the wall because they were not installed correctly.

Manager's Response

Hi Kathy,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this home. We will look into the silverware inventory immediately as well as the towel hooks. Please come back and see us soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Captain's Quarters

December 2019
, Kansas City, MO US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great home and heated pool; wish we had more time to stay there.

Manager's Response

Dear Mark,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you enjoyed this home and hope to see you back soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Key West Christmas!

December 2019
, Bristol, NH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

We rented this house for the week before Christmas rather than giving gifts. It was a wonderful opportunity to spend time together with family. The house was perfect for our family. We didn’t need a car and walked out biked everywhere. The weather wasn’t fabulous but we still had a great time. The pool area was great, the kitchen well supplied, and the front porch was a great place for our grandchildren to hang ou with neighborhood cats!

Manager's Response

Dear Rosemary,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you enjoyed this amazing home and we hope to see you back soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Fun Vacation experience

December 2019
, Wilmington, NC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
4
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a great time in Key West. The property was clean and well- decorated and we loved the pool, especially in the evenings after a long hot day (yes, it was warm in December!). The concierge service was vey helpful and arranged several outings for us at the last minute. The location was great too, on the edge of Old Town- renting bikes is the way to go. The neighbors that we met were all very friendly and it seems to be a mix of rentals and full time homeowners so the places are all well kept. We had a great time!

Manager's Response

Dear Lisa,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you enjoyed your time at this home and hope to see you back again soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Amazing house & pool is everything!

October 2019
, North Bethesda, MD US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We stayed at Captain's Quarters with 3 other couples for 4 nights. We all didn't want to leave! The pool and outdoor area was amazing. The house itself was perfect, everyone loved the kitchen and living room. We took a 3-4 min Uber ride to downtown most days and never had to wait for a car. The area where the house is located is great! 20 min walk to Duval St., and lots of good coffee and food less than a block away. Can't wait to come back!!

Manager's Response

Dear Katie,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how perfect this home was for your Key West visit. We hope to see you again soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great place to spend with family or friends

October 2019
, Pompano Beach, FL US

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
4
Property condition
4

The experience was good but I feel it could be great to excellent with a few small details being added.

Manager's Response

Dear Bennetto,


Thank you for your recent review. We are so happy to hear how much you enjoyed this incredible home in Key West. We would love to hear more on your thoughts of what could be added so feel free to reach out anytime.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Fantastic House!

September 2019
, Portland, OR US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This home is located very close to local stores (walking a block or 2) and is also a short walk to popular destinations like Duval. It has amazing charm to it and it’s perfect for a small group to stay and enjoy beautiful Key West. The pool and back patio is incredible and a fantastic place to spend a nice sunny day.

Manager's Response

Dear Shane,


Thank you for your wonderful review! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this incredible home and we hope to see you back soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Awesome house!

August 2019
, Chesapeake, VA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
5

We really enjoy our stay in Key West at Captain's Quarters. Perfect size house for four couples. There were no surprises, everything was as listed. We especially loved the pool and home decor! The only thing we found that needs to be fixed is the door handle in the front left bedroom.

Manager's Response

Dear Lisa,


Thank you for your 5 star review! We are so happy that you and your party had such an enjoyable time in Key West. We loved hosting you in Paradise and hope to see you back soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Captains quarters

August 2019
, Columbia, SC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great place!!! Would def book here again!!!!

Manager's Response

Dear Joy,


Thank you for your kind words on your recent stay. We are so happy that you loved this home and would stay here again. We hope to be hearing from you soon to book your next visit!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Perfect Place

May 2019
, EAST GRAND RAPIDS, MI United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Excellent as described!

Manager's Response

Dear John,


Thank you for your incredible review on Captain's Quarters. We are so happy to hear how much you loved this amazing Key West retreat. The house is well equipped and comes with a spacious pool making this the perfect island destination. We appreciate your feedback and hope to see you back very soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Valentine wedding Margaritaville

May 2019
, Sugar Loaf, NY United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
5

Comfortable well equipped cool in every sense of the word. Can’t wait to go back and relax.

Manager's Response

Dear Cora,


Thank you for your incredible review on Captain's Quarters. We are so thrilled to hear that your wedding weekend in Paradise was perfect. We loved hosting you in Paradise and hope to see you on your next trip to the Florida Keys!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great time!

April 2019
, Chicago, IL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house was super cute and ended up sleeping 10 of us comfortably (2 on the couches). We had everything we needed, the pool was great, and even the little poolside cottage was comfortable! We ended up renting bikes two different days from the bike shop across the street, highly recommend! Jorge was also very accommodating in letting us leave our bags on the property since our flight was in the afternoon after check out.

Manager's Response

Dear Ashley,


Thank you for your 5 star review on Captain's Quarters. We are so happy to hear that your party of 10 enjoyed this incredible Key West home. We appreciate all your feedback and hope to see you back in Paradise again soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Perfect Vacation Rental

February 2019
, United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
4
Property condition
5

This house was perfect for a group of friends in town for a wedding. The beds were so comfortable, and we all had plenty of privacy. Loved the decor and overall feel of the home.

Manager's Response

Dear Kortnee,


We are so happy to hear how much you loved your time spent at Captain's Quarters! The house really is perfect for a group of friends traveling together. Thank you for the wonderful feedback and please come back and see us soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Beautiful Property with Great location!

August 2018

Overall
5

We had a great time celebrating my daughters birthday! Pool was a plus with the hot weather! You could walk to all attraction in Key West!

Great house, location, and property management

June 2018

Overall
5

We loved our stay in the Captains Quarters. The pool was a huge hit and much needed as the temps were in the 90's. The house was clean and nice and cool when we arrived, the central AC was awesome. At a quick 10 minute walk to Duval street, the location of this house is ideal and nice and quiet at night.

Awesome!

June 2018

Overall
5

The property was everything the description said it would be. First experience with HomeAway and I will most certainly be back. My family loved the property so much, we didnt get in our car once during our entire 4 day stay. It was conveniently located to everything we needed without having to drive anywhere. Loved it. Plan to return soon.

I highly recommend!

May 2018

Overall
5

This house was awesome, we loved the pool area and the big umbrella that kept us dry when it started to rain. A very functional kitchen, spacious bed rooms with comfy beds, and the bathrooms had great showers.

Charming, well-equipped home with beautiful pool deck

April 2018

Overall
5

This house has everything you need for a small group (3-4 couples). The pool is great. The layout of the house works really well. A short-ride (or slightly longer walk) to Key West action. Highly recommend.

Leave a Review
4 Bed
2.5 Baths
Sleeps 10

Search Availability

BANYAN ROSE ~ Key West's Finest!

BANYAN ROSE ~ Chic 4 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom Midtown Location Home w/ Private & Heated Outdoor Pool!

Location

1709 Rose St.
33040 Key West , FL
United States
24° 33' 9.1152" N, 81° 46' 50.124" W
See map: Google Maps
Florida US

BANYAN ROSE ~ Key West's Finest!

Request More Information

AMAZING

Reviewed by Dylan L. on 2024-08-15
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Amazing! The house has everything you could think of and more.
Manager response on 2024-08-15 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this great review Dylan! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

BANYAN ROSE ~ Renovated 4 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom Midtown Home w/ Pool!

Unit Code: BAN

BANYAN ROSE ~ Key West's Finest!

BANYAN ROSE ~ Chic 4 Bedroom, 2 Bathroom Midtown Location Home w/ Private & Heated Outdoor Pool!
PERFECT TROPICAL POOL RETREAT… If you've been searching for the ideal island getaway, look no further. This classic Key West jewel is precisely what your island soul has been yearning to find. This quintessential tropical nest beckons you inside its private gated entrance, where sumptuous living and sultry breezes collide in a perfect storm of blissful pleasure. Tucked into the quiet neighborhood of Midtown, you are close to pristine beaches, White Street Pier, bustling restaurants and a short bike ride to famous Old Town. ***PRIMARY GUEST MUST BE AT LEAST 25 YEARS OF AGE DETAILS AND AMENITIES... Step inside this oasis where you are surrounded by a privacy fence that encompasses lushly landscaped front and back yards. The serene refuge of this home offers respite after a day of adventure under the southernmost sunshine. Craft your icy cocktail in the modern, fully-equipped and beautifully updated kitchen with a gas range and under counter beverage fridge, then ease onto the cozy furnishings in the adjacent living room and relax with your favorite tv show, a good book or dive into a board game together. The spacious dining room is a perfect setting to share stories over delicious cuisine with your friends and family. This home is equipped with wall mounted Roku enabled SmartTVs in every room and free WIFI. throughout. A washer/dryer is available for your convenience as well. SLEEPING ARRANGEMENTS... All of the 4 bedrooms (to include the one in the pool house), offer smart TVs and cooling ceiling fans. The main house features a king bedroom, a queen bedroom and a twin bedroom that can convert to a king bed upon request. The king and queen rooms have desks and a laser wifi printer for those working remotely. The bedroom in the pool house offers twin beds that can also convert to a king (shown as King in photos). Both glass walk-in showers reside in the main house. OUTDOOR LIVING... The impressive backyard oasis is a focal point of this spectacular island gem, boasting a sparkling heated pool, al fresco dining table for 10 and seating with sail shade, large propane grill, cooling outdoor shower, cafe table with seating, and pool loungers. It all adds up to an exquisite day under shaded palms and healing sunshine. Sway on the front yard hammock or hop on of of the 5 beach cruisers so you can stroll the charming lanes of Key West to the nearby Pickleball and Bocce courts! PARKING... There is off street parking available for this home. PETS... Pets are considered at this home. Please include the size/breed when inquiring. MULTI MONTH RESERVATIONS... For monthly reservations, the following fees will be added PER MONTH: Mid-stay clean Pool/hot tub heating fee (if applicable) Pet fee (if applicable) BOOKING DATES... This home is offered only as a monthly rental (28 night minimum). We prefer to book by the calendar month (first day of the month to the last). We may consider alternate dates if the calendar allows or if the owner will make an exception. CANCELLATION... Bookings canceled at least 90 days before the start of stay will receive a 100% refund. Cancellations inside of 90 days may receive a refund if we are able to re-rent any or all of the dates of the stay. The refund amount is dependent upon the rate of the new reservation. For multi-month reservations for January through March, a refund will only be offered in the event we are able to re-rent. The refund amount is dependent upon the rate of the new reservation(s). CONCIERGE SERVICES... Enjoy our concierge service to assist you with planning activities for your trip, from bike/scooter/golf cart rentals to any excursion you can think of including snorkeling and sunset cruises, jet ski rentals, parasailing, kayaking, fishing, paddle boarding and much more. They can also have your fridge stocked with all the necessities in advance of your arrival! THIS IS YOUR HAPPY PLACE...
May 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
June 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
 
July 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
Age 18 and under.
DatesPrice
05/09/2025 - 05/31/2025$286 /nt
06/01/2025 - 06/30/2025$268 /nt
07/01/2025 - 07/31/2025$322 /nt
08/01/2025 - 08/31/2025$323 /nt
09/01/2025 - 09/30/2025$340 /nt
10/01/2025 - 10/31/2025$429 /nt
11/01/2025 - 11/30/2025$465 /nt
12/01/2025 - 12/31/2025$536 /nt
01/01/2026 - 01/31/2026$804 /nt
02/01/2026 - 02/28/2026$844 /nt
03/01/2026 - 03/31/2026$804 /nt
04/01/2026 - 04/30/2026$536 /nt
05/01/2026 - 05/09/2026$429 /nt
5.0000
(1 Review)

AMAZING

July 2024
, Tampa, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Amazing! The house has everything you could think of and more.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Dylan! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Leave a Review
4 Bed
2 Baths
Sleeps 8

Search Availability

SATISFY MY SOUL ~ Island Perfection!

SATISFY MY SOUL ~ 3 Bedroom, 3.5 Bathroom Newly Renovated Home in Midtown Location with Pool!

Location

1415 Von Phister St
33040 Key West , FL
United States
24° 33' 9.774" N, 81° 47' 7.0908" W
See map: Google Maps
Florida US

SATISFY MY SOUL ~ Island Perfection!

Request More Information

SATISFY MY SOUL ~ 3 BR, 3.5 Ba Newly Renovated Mid Town Home w/ Pool!

Unit Code: SMS

SATISFY MY SOUL ~ Island Perfection!

SATISFY MY SOUL ~ 3 Bedroom, 3.5 Bathroom Newly Renovated Home in Midtown Location with Pool!
AUTHENTIC KEY WEST AMBIENCE... This fully renovated mid-century jewel pairs modern allure with classic White Street Gallery District charm. Exhale your worries as you enter this serene and private neighborhood. You are a small distance from the vibrant pulse of downtown Key West so you'll enjoy both island peace and the unique excitement of the Conch Republic. This idyllic retreat is perfectly situated just minutes from Old Town, the historic marina and stunning white sandy beaches. Immerse yourself in the pinnacle of Key West lifestyle! ***PRIMARY GUEST MUST BE AT LEAST 25 YEARS OF AGE. DETAILS AND AMENITIES... Enter the home that lies beyond your privacy fence and embrace your cozy oasis that envelops you with mature tropical foliage and a refuge from reality. Your light-filled living room beckons you inside with its island chic decor, plush furnishings and a wall mounted TV. Merge indoor and outdoor living spaces when you open your sliding doors to the pool and garden. The streamlined and sparkling kitchen overlooks the living area and captivates your inner foodie with every modern culinary appliance and tool you'll require for crafting festive meals and adult concoctions for your friends and family. The living/kitchen area offers a cafe table for 2 as well as kitchen counter seating for 3. Travel down the bedroom hallway where you'll find a washer/dryer closet. This home is equipped with Youtube TV. SLEEPING ARRANGEMENTS... Delight in three bedrooms that each have its own updated en suite shower bathroom - the second bedroom equipped with a wall mounted TV and both king rooms with sliding doors that lead to the outdoor area. A full bathroom with a shower/tub combination resides in the hallway. OUTDOOR LIVING... You will enjoy hours of peaceful repose in your private garden with a heated pool. Nap on one of the loungers in the shade of lush palms cooled by balmy breezes and kick back with your loved ones by the fire pit. A grill and outdoor chairs invite you to gather under tropical stars with an iced cocktail in hand. PARKING... There is off street parking available for this home. PETS... Dogs are considered up to 15 lbs only. Please include the size and the breed in the comments when inquiring. MULTI MONTH RESERVATIONS... For monthly reservations, the following fees will be added PER MONTH: Mid-stay clean Pool/hot tub heating fee (if applicable) Pet fee (if applicable) BOOKING DATES... This home is offered only as a monthly rental (28 night minimum). We prefer to book by the calendar month (first day of the month to the last). We may consider alternate dates if the calendar allows or if the owner will make an exception. CANCELLATION... Bookings canceled at least 90 days before the start of stay will receive a 100% refund. Cancellations inside of 90 days may receive a refund if we are able to re-rent any or all of the dates of the stay. The refund amount is dependent upon the rate of the new reservation. For multi-month reservations for January through March, a refund will only be offered in the event we are able to re-rent. The refund amount is dependent upon the rate of the new reservation(s). CONCIERGE SERVICES... Enjoy our concierge service to assist you with planning activities for your trip, from bike/scooter/golf cart rentals to any excursion you can think of including snorkeling and sunset cruises, jet ski rentals, parasailing, kayaking, fishing, paddle boarding and much more. They can also have your fridge stocked with all the necessities in advance of your arrival! ISLAND TRANQUILITY RESIDES HERE…
May 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
June 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
 
July 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
Age 18 and under.
DatesPrice
05/09/2025 - 06/30/2025$243 /nt
07/01/2025 - 07/31/2025$306 /nt
08/01/2025 - 08/31/2025$289 /nt
09/01/2025 - 10/31/2025$304 /nt
11/01/2025 - 11/30/2025$429 /nt
12/01/2025 - 12/31/2025$447 /nt
01/01/2026 - 01/31/2026$715 /nt
02/01/2026 - 02/28/2026$788 /nt
03/01/2026 - 03/31/2026$715 /nt
04/01/2026 - 04/30/2026$500 /nt
05/01/2026 - 05/09/2026$304 /nt
Leave a Review
3 Bed
4 Baths
Sleeps 6

Search Availability

CONCH HEAVEN ~ Easy Breezy!

CONCH HEAVEN ~ 2Bd/ 2Ba w/ Sleeper Sofa Close to Beach and Duval w/ heated Cocktail Pool!

Location

1103 Fleming St.
33040 Key West , FL
United States
24° 33' 37.728" N, 81° 47' 45.2688" W
See map: Google Maps
Florida US

CONCH HEAVEN ~ Easy Breezy!

Request More Information

Conch Heaven is Heaven

Reviewed by Unknown on 2024-11-21
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Conch Heaven is the cutest little place. Perfect getaway that is close to everything.

Relaxing Getaway

Reviewed by Timothy S. on 2024-11-20
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Conch Heaven was a perfect spot for my wife and another couple. We were close to everything yet tucked away enough to enjoy the front porch and backyard pool area in calm serenity. We hope to be back!

Fishing birthday trip

Reviewed by Michelle T. on 2024-04-30
Overall satisfaction
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The place was very quaint, well decorated and comfortable. Close to restaurants on both sides of thee island. We would definitely stay here again.
Manager response on 2024-05-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Cute little house. Great bathrooms

Reviewed by Patricia H. on 2024-04-23
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The entire thing as far as the house itself went was A-plus! It was perfect for us. It had it all. The two down sides were the pool which was only a dipping pool was not clean. There was mold around the edges and inside. Yuck. Also, there was no allotted parking and we had to literally walk blocks to park. Not fun.
Manager response on 2024-05-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us! We are looking into why the pool wasn't clean, please reach out to your property manager so we can fix any issue as soon as possible and make sure the rest of your trip goes smoothly. We would love to welcome you back!

Cozy retreat close to everything

Reviewed by Jennifer S. on 2024-05-08
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a lovely time at this key west home, close to downtown but relaxing and peaceful street/neighborhood. The tiny pool was a cool welcome, and the home was clean. It would have been helpful if they were able to let us store our luggage or check in earlier, but management was easy to text with.
Manager response on 2024-05-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Jennifer, we are thrilled you enjoyed this property. We wish we could all our guest check in early and check out late. The cleaners are on a tight schedule on our busy island so we must respect that to make sure all our guest enjoy a squeaky clean rental. Our concierge service does offer luggage storage however although we understand it isn't as easy as staying in the home a little longer. We hope this won't keep you from staying with us again. Thank you for being our guest!

Great house

Reviewed by Joseph C. on 2024-10-27
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Enjoyed our stay.

Key West Adventure

Reviewed by Scott H. on 2023-11-17
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Fabulous! Perfect accommodations for 2 couples to share having basically 2 masters with 2 full baths. Walkable to everything!
Manager response on 2023-12-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so happy you found this property and its location ideal for your get away in Key West Scott. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit!

Great Stay!

Reviewed by Regina M. on 2024-02-18
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The description of the property was spot on. We rented bikes during our stay which made getting to and from the heart of town very easy. We had no issues during our stay so did not have to contact the property manager, but they were communicative and responsive prior to our arrival. We loved the heated cocktail pool for relaxing in the afternoon and evening. I would absolutely recommend this home to friends and family.
Manager response on 2024-05-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

Fantastic Property

Reviewed by Sarah W. on 2023-12-06
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The property was perfect, just what we needed. It was comfortable, incredibly clean, in excellent condition and well appointed. Its location is within walking distance to all the popular spots, but still very quiet and private. I would highly recommend the property to others and would love to stay there again!
Manager response on 2024-05-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Coch Heaven

Reviewed by David H. on 2023-11-14
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
If you want to stay in old town Key West this is the place. Clean and very nice. Close to walk for coffee and breakfast. 10 minute walk to Duval street. Full of character. The property manager was quick to respond to questions and everything was excellent. Will stay there again.
Manager response on 2023-12-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for taking the time to review your stay David. We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

key west conch heaven

Reviewed by gustavo r. on 2023-12-12
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great place. Very comfortable and close enough to everything.
Manager response on 2024-05-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Great experience

Reviewed by Cynthia M. on 2024-02-21
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Well appointed well decorated lovely house in excellent neighborhood
Manager response on 2024-05-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this short and sweet five star review, we hope to have the pleasure to host you again next time you visit the island.

Conch Heaven

Reviewed by Unknown on 2024-03-12
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Thank you for our stay! The home was clean and in a great location near the town of Key West. It is a quiet area & that's what we wanted. You could ride bikes into town. The Conch Train was fun for our 7 year old to ride with us and hear about Key West.The property manager responded to our questions quickly and we were able to check in a bit early.Since we drove from Buffalo, NY we were really ready to unpack. Thank you!
Manager response on 2024-05-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your fantastic review Nancy. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Lovely

Reviewed by Brett S. on 2024-02-29
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The home was very clean and perfect for our family. We liked the experience better than staying in a hotel as we did the previous visit to Key West. It was nice to have a “home” to go to after sight seeing. This home is perfect for a small family. The rental process is super easy and Whitney did a fantastic job communicating with us about our stay. I wish we had booked an extra couple of days!
Manager response on 2024-05-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Brett. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Great Vacation!

Reviewed by Michelle G. on 2022-04-25
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The property was exactly as described and pictured online. Perfect location, close enough to the best bars, restaurants and activities but far enough away to escape the noise and activity when ready. The property manager was very responsive and great to work with. Be sure to rent bikes, it's the best way to get around the island. Brunch at Blue Heaven is a must. The highlight of our trip was a full day charter with Captain Mike and Aquaholics Charters.
Manager response on 2022-04-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Michelle. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Cute Key West Bungalow

Reviewed by Annie G. on 2023-01-30
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house was fantastic. So cute. Perfect for 2-4 people. Great plunge pool in the back. Amazing location, walking distance from many restaurants and about 15 min to Duval.
Manager response on 2023-02-27 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Annie. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Conch Heaven

Reviewed by Unknown on 2022-10-17
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Our group enjoy the accommodations at the lovely home on Fleming Avenue. The small little dipping pool was perfect for our evening cocktail hour and we found everything we needed. The property manager was very responsive when we needed help.
Manager response on 2022-12-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you so much for your review Linda. We really appreciate you taking the time out to share your experience with us — and we agree, Brian is truly a gem to have on our team! We count ourselves lucky for guests like you. We look forward to hosting you again in the future!

Off the Beaten Path, But in a Nice Way

Reviewed by Rick M. on 2022-05-16
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Enjoyed this lovely little condo. Plenty or room for a couple (or two couples). The living space is open and comfortable and the little pool is a really nice bonus. While it isn't within walking distance of Duval Street, it is a quick Uber ride to get to anywhere on the island. The surrounding neighborhood is quiet and there is a little grocery store on the same block, which is handy for snacks.
Manager response on 2022-05-31 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Rick. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Key West- Adults Only Getaway

Reviewed by Kati S. on 2022-08-10
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We were a group of two couples- looking to enjoy a kid-free getaway. This did not disappoint! We were in walking distance to everything, and the home was fully stocked with what we needed. A perfect mini-vacation!
Manager response on 2022-09-12 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Kati, we are so glad the property met your needs while staying with us. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit Key West.

Walker Stay

Reviewed by Todd W. on 2022-07-16
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had an amazing time at the house. Location was great house was great concierge service was great
Manager response on 2022-07-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your fantastic review Todd. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Great place and great location

Reviewed by Art S. on 2022-08-18
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great communication, very responsive and I was able to text them which was convenient. We loved the place and will definitely be back. The little pool was perfect for cooling off and socializing after exploring all day.
Manager response on 2022-09-12 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review Art, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Perfect in Paradise

Reviewed by Grayson D. on 2023-03-27
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The Conch Heaven cottage was exactly as it is portrayed in the photos and description on VRBO. There were no surprises; only delights. The house is a quick bike ride or walk to most of Key West, and the free shuttle service, the Duval Loop, has a stop just a block away. If you're heading to Dry Tortugas National Park, the Yankee Freedom ferry is docked 2 blocks away. The house was spotless, and the beds were comfy.
Manager response on 2023-12-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your fantastic review Grayson. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Wonderful Home

Reviewed by Britta T. on 2023-04-25
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Couldn't have asked for a better place to stay. The pictures and description are 100% accurate. We were two families traveling with toddlers, the cocktail pool was perfect for the littles during the day, and adults lounging at night. Location is fantastic, quiet street within walking distance to restaurants, bars, and the water. 11/10!
Manager response on 2023-12-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Britta. We are thrilled you loved this home and hope to host you again soon!

Great Key West vacation

Reviewed by Charles a. on 2023-02-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Really well located vacation home in central Key West. We came for 2 nights with our kids which loved the small pool.

We would recommend this rental
Manager response on 2023-02-27 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this great review Charles! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Conch heaven was great

Reviewed by Unknown on 2023-06-27
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a great time , good location, close to everything, the choices for food within walking distance was great. Parking was not a problem, we drove and rented a jeep. Pool was warm. Nice to cool off in . Relaxing .
Manager response on 2023-12-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review Alice, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Charming and quiet

Reviewed by Robert R. on 2023-05-10
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house is charming, on a quiet street a 15-minute walk from the nightlife on Duval, but with a couple of little restaurants and bakeries within only a few blocks. The upstairs room and bath are spacious, while the downstairs bedroom is fine for a couple but a bit cramped for two singles. The house was immaculate with a cute little backyard and plunge pool.
Manager response on 2023-12-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for taking the time to review your stay Robert. We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

60th bday bash

Reviewed by Unknown on 2023-06-28
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
First the pictured pool was creative photography. It was 4x6 or even less. Not what we planned. The raft was bigger than the pool and we never used it.
There was a smell of mold. The house manager was great and treated the house with an ionizer yo correct the problem. Otherwise location great and was comfortable.
Manager response on 2023-12-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your honest review Cynthia, the pool is smaller which is not uncommon in Key West, sorry you thought the photos were misleading. We will relay your complaints to the ownership and work on improvements in the future. Thank you for being our guest!

Please see terrific review posted on VRBO

Reviewed by Steve R. on 2023-06-01
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Hi there. Already left a review of my terrific stay on VRBO, which was posted.
Manager response on 2023-12-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review on VRBO Steve. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

The perfect home away from home

Reviewed by Marcel D. on 2023-07-02
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
It was our first visit to Key West and the house was absolutely perfect. It was in old town so it was quiet, except for the roosters lol but still close enough to walk to Duvall. We had so much fun and we were able to come back and relax each night. Absolutely, if we ever go to Key West again, we will stay in this home every time.
Manager response on 2023-12-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your fantastic review Marcel. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Super nice, cozy home.

Reviewed by Ashley M. on 2023-08-03
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house was very clean and well appointed. It had all the amenities we needed for our short stay. The communication with the rental company was excellent and always prompt. We will come back and stay here again, no doubt.
Manager response on 2023-12-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review Ashley, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Beautiful Home

Reviewed by Michelle G. on 2020-01-13
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Spent 4 days with family, home was spacious and close to everything
Manager response on 2020-01-13 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Michelle, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this home and how to see you back soon. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Wonderful winter getaway

Reviewed by Unknown on 2020-02-10
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
What a cute little house. Everything we wanted to do was a walk or bike ride away. No car needed. The house was immaculate, and the property manager was kind and helpful throughout our stay. We can’t wait to visit again.
Manager response on 2020-02-14 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Deborah, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you enjoyed this rental and hope to see you back again soon. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Highly recommend! Will book again.

Reviewed by Mindy R. on 2020-11-13
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The place was clean, comfortable, and well-appointed with plenty of linens, beach towels, and kitchen needs. The back is very private. The neighborhood is quiet and friendly and far enough away from Duval that you don't get any disruptions, though a nice, easy walk when you want to head that way. Parking was easy - there was always a nearby available space on the street. We will look to book this place again next year, or at least with this company. The property manager was very nice and responded quickly to all of our questions.
Manager response on 2020-11-17 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your incredible review. We hope to see you again soon!

Diving in key west

Reviewed by Randall B. on 2020-07-31
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The conch was perfect Bikeable to the dive boat and all the nice places on duval and everything else beautiful key west has to offer
Manager response on 2020-08-03 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to see you again soon!

Will always return to this home!

Reviewed by Elena F. on 2020-08-18
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Everything was flawless!!! Absolutely the best communication with the rental company and the house was perfection!!!
Manager response on 2020-08-18 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your fantastic review! We are thrilled that you enjoyed Conch Heaven, we hope to see you again soon!

A Needed Getaway

Reviewed by Unknown on 2020-06-16
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Despite the virus, we had a great time! The place was perfect for the 2 of us! Really enjoyed the 4 nights.
Manager response on 2020-06-16 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Steve, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you loved your stay and hope to see you again. Best, Wendy Zinsmaster and Team

Great overall experience

Reviewed by RICK K. on 2020-11-01
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We were in Key West for my wife’s Birthday and wanted to be close enough to Duval and the other attractions that we could walk comfortably, yet far enough away to insure peace and quiet. Conch Heaven was a 100% match. The house is well appointed and everything works, The property manager, Brian, was very attentive and knowledgeable. We always felt that whatever our need, he would be available to accommodate. We didn’t expect the pool to be important, but we ended up enjoying it every afternoon after our activities. We would definitely recommend Conch Heaven to anyone.
Manager response on 2020-11-02 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled you had such a great time and hope to see you again soon!

Beautiful home! Extremely clean.

Reviewed by Richard B. on 2020-10-04
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great little home! Super clean. Was perfect to walking to one of the trolly stops and restaurants.
Manager response on 2020-10-04 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to see you again soon!

Great Weekend Getaway

Reviewed by Unknown on 2020-10-04
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Rented this cute home for a long weekend. Clean, spacious and had everything you would need. Quiet part of town but great location. Will definitely be back!
Manager response on 2020-10-04 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to see you again soon!

The perfect getaway-every detail

Reviewed by todd h. on 2020-10-04
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We were a part of six with a four year old. The house was immaculate. Beds were comfy. Kitchen has full cooking capabilities & utensils. We cooked every meal for three days. Washed our clothes. Rocking chairs on front porch for chilling. Back deck w/pool & gas grille was perfect also. Uber drivers flood the island and respond in 5 minutes. Although it's a very short walk to Duval. Fleming St is a central as you can get. For a family house, you can't beat iit.
Manager response on 2020-10-04 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to see you again soon!

Adorable

Reviewed by Unknown on 2021-05-07
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This home is adorable and in a great location. We had bikes delivered and rode everywhere we needed to go. It was perfect. The property management people were great! I would absolutely stay here again.
Manager response on 2021-05-14 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review. We hope to see you again soon!

Perfect February Getaway

Reviewed by Stephanie S. on 2021-03-12
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The home was lovely and it was easy to relax. The location was great - close to Duval St, but far enough away that it was quiet and calm. The host was easy to contact and very responsive to any questions that came up.
Manager response on 2021-03-12 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your recent review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back again soon!

Christmas Getaway

Reviewed by Kim E. on 2020-12-25
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Rental was clean and comfortable. Great location with easy bike ride access to all of the sights and restaurants.
Manager response on 2020-12-30 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review! We hope to see you again soon!

Small charm great location and service

Reviewed by Ari F. on 2022-01-11
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Place is cozy but small. It needs a little love and TLC to look and feel more like the pictures. Walls are scuffy and things are starting to show some wear and tear. Kitchen could use a bit more of everything. It was well stocked with supplies to get our 10 day stay off and running which was nice. Brian the Prop Mgr was a great communicator and treated us with ultra white gloves as well.
Manager response on 2022-01-17 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Ari, we are glad you enjoyed your stay and will address the small issues you mentioned as best as we can. We hope to host you again next time you decide to visit Key West!

Heated Pool

Reviewed by ALICIA R. on 2021-02-15
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Nice little home. Clean, spacious and well maintained. Our main reason for renting this place was the heated pool since this was January trip. It was a really nice amenity. It's a quick walk to Duval street and there is a little store on the corner. The only complaint is parking, or lack thereof. Parking is nearly impossible. There is no designated parking spot and most are reserved for permit holders. On arrival we spent almost 90 minutes circling the neighboring blocks looking for a parking place. Once we found one a block away we left the rental car in the same spot for the whole visit. Even during the weekdays all of the spots on the block were filled or reserved.
Manager response on 2021-02-23 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your recent review. We are sorry if you had issues with parking - this home does not come with parking as advertised. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back soon!

A wonderful stay...

Reviewed by Edward H. on 2021-11-25
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We have a wonderful stay at Conch Heaven. The house was perfect for our needs. The house was bright, clean, and easy to use. It was exactly as described. We had one minor issues (we flipped a breaker) and management was quick to respond (it was fixed in no time). Far better than any hotel. Thanks for everything!
Manager response on 2021-12-03 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your great review Edward! It was a pleasure hosting you!

Conch Heaven is just right!

Reviewed by Mary Louise N. on 2022-03-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Conch Heaven is a great house in the perfect location! We were close to our favorite restaurants in a very pedestrian friendly neighborhood. The house is immaculate, well appointed. Special thanks to our property manager, Ryan, for the extra attention and kind assistance during our stay. We enjoyed our visit!
Manager response on 2022-03-24 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this great review Mary! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Great house!

Reviewed by Jenny H. on 2021-11-12
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We really enjoyed staying at the house. It was very clean and nicely decorated. It was close to a lot of restaurants and shops.
Manager response on 2021-11-19 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Jenny, we are thrilled you enjoyed your stay so much and hope to host you again next time you visit Key West!

Perfect place to stay in key west!

Reviewed by Shari C. on 2021-05-31
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The home was spotless upon arrival. It had more than everything we needed. We stopped and bought food and cooked a lot of our meals in the well equipped kitchen. We loved the washer and dryer. The bed upstairs was extremely comfortable. The showers were awesome. Our favorite part was the privacy of the back deck and the cocktail pool. We enjoyed that every day. We were able to walk to Duval quite easily. I will absolutely stay here again! Thanks to Brian for staying up to date with me they texting and being so kind and courteous!
Manager response on 2021-06-01 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review. We are so happy you had a great time and hope to see you again!

Great House

Reviewed by Wendy S. on 2021-07-11
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house was beautiful and very clean. Brian was always very helpful and I would highly recommend this house to anyone. We will be staying here again.
Manager response on 2021-08-04 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so glad you enjoyed your stay with us Wendy! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West!

Heaven in Conch Heaven

Reviewed by Royal B. on 2022-04-16
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great location. Beautiful street and a few blocks from Duval. Spacious well appointed house. Small backyard with private dipping pool.
Manager response on 2022-04-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your fantastic review Royal. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Getaway to Key West

Reviewed by Melissa M. on 2021-09-25
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
It was a lovely getaway.
Manager response on 2021-10-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Melissa, we are thrilled you enjoyed your stay and hope to host you again in the future!

2021 getaway

Reviewed by Dawn M. on 2021-10-03
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Everything was perfect. House was clean and so pretty. Kitchen and bathrooms were well stocked and clean. Loved the back patio and cute pool! Brian was very helpful with check in and check out too!
Manager response on 2021-10-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Dawn. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back soon!

YES, this is a good one!

Reviewed by Unknown on 2021-08-29
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Easy check in, we were fortunate enough to even get in a few hours early! Well appointed, we had everything we needed for light cooking. Very clean! A easy walk to Duvall Street. No problem finding street parking in the area.
Manager response on 2021-08-31 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back soon!

Perfection

Reviewed by Cole T. on 2021-07-14
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This house is absolute perfection... the location, the house, the neighbors... literally everything about this place was perfect. Property management was simple, easy, clears, and no issues at all! Just as described in the home details. The location couldn’t be more perfect for quiet yet in the midst of everything. Rent a golf cart and explore the island!!
Manager response on 2021-07-26 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review Cole, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much and hope you'll choose to stay with us again next time you visit Key West!

Cute!

Reviewed by Unknown on 2021-08-29
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This house is perfect! 2 couples stayed and there was plenty of room for all of us. It is a quiet neighborhood and has a store right down the street to get food and essentials. The pool is small but it was so fun to dip in and hang with friends. The property manager was easy to talk to when arriving and leaving. We will definitely be keeping this gem on our list to return to in the future!
Manager response on 2021-08-30 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us Debra! We are looking forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Fantastic getaway

Reviewed by Chad H. on 2021-12-23
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house was located out of the fray, but near enough to walk anywhere. We rented mopeds to maximize our touring, and it was hands down the best choice. Another bonus was the Azur Restaurant, a block away. We enjoyed this Italian delight so much, we wished we hadn’t eaten anywhere else.

The house is very well appointed with everything you need, and you won’t find a better host!
Manager response on 2022-01-10 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Chad, we are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to welcome you again next time you visit the island!

Key West Prime Location

Reviewed by Darren R. on 2021-12-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great place for a stay in Key West. The neighborhood was very well kept, safe and quiet. Close to shopping, dining and fun. Very clean and maintained home.
Manager response on 2022-01-10 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Darren, it was a pleasure hosting you!

Would definitely stay again!

Reviewed by Unknown on 2022-04-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Perfect, classy home in a great walkable location!
Manager response on 2022-04-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this great review Janice! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Great Bungalow

Reviewed by Lorraine S. on 2019-02-17
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Perfect location just close enough to the action, but quiet at night. Parking can be a challenge, but we walked everywhere. Very cozy, clean and perfect for a small family or two couples. Very nice! Would definitely stay again!
Manager response on 2019-02-18 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Lorraine, Thank you for your wonderful 5 star review on Conch Heaven. We are so happy to hear how much you enjoyed this incredible Key West home and it's perfect location to all the fun. Parking in Old Town Key West can be difficult so we don't recommend driving your personal vehicle around, but to take advantage of Uber on the island. We loved hosting you in Paradise and hope you return soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

The Barbie Dream House

Reviewed by Unknown on 2019-03-07
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This was our second year staying in Conch Heaven for our annual girls getaway. We nicknamed it the our Barbie Dream House. The house and the neighborhood are perfect for our group of four. Easy walk to the crazy fun on and around Duval, but a quiet clean escape at the end of the night. The little pool was perfect for morning dip with coffee and evening dip before bed.

Brian, the property manager, was incredibly helpful and responsive to our questions and requests.
Manager response on 2019-03-08 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Kristen, Thank you for your wonderful 5 star review on Conch Heaven aka The Barbie Dream House! We are thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this unit in terms of location and amenities. We loved having you as our guest and hope to see you back in Paradise very soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great experience!

Reviewed by Danielle S. on 2019-03-31
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Everything about our stay was great! Brian was very helpful with the up-front communication, check-in instructions, and even came out to check on the temperature of the pool for us. Location was great and house was in a quiet spot, yet a quick walk or bike ride to Duval street and other local attractions. Would definitely recommend and stay here again!
Manager response on 2019-04-01 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Danielle, Thank you for your wonderful review on Conch Heaven! We are thrilled to hear how much you loved this incredible Key West home located in Old Town Key West. Brian is a real gem to our company and we are so happy to hear that he was so helpful during your stay. We loved having you as our guest and hope you come back and see us soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great stay

Reviewed by Unknown on 2018-12-25
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great location & spce. Brian was very helpful in setting us up for arrival and departure. Would definitely rent again.
Manager response on 2018-12-25 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Ryan, Thank you for your wonderful review on Conch Heaven! We are so happy to hear how great your trip was in this perfectly located Key West home. We appreciate the great feedback and look forward to seeing you again in Paradise! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Girls Trip

Reviewed by Lori H. on 2019-03-28
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a wonderful time. The home has a great location. Very central. Close enough to walk or bike, yet quite enough for relaxing. Everything was clean and organized and the management company did a great job with communication.
Manager response on 2019-03-28 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Lori, Thank you for your 5 star review on Conch Heaven. We appreciate all your wonderful feedback on your recent Key West stay and are so happy that you loved this incredible home in the perfect location. We hope you come back to Key West soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Vacation

Reviewed by Stephen F. on 2019-04-19
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Had a wonderful time and the accommodations were fantastic.
Manager response on 2019-04-22 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Stephen, Thank you for your 5 star review on Conch Heaven! We are so happy to hear that you loved this incredible Key West retreat. We loved having you as our guest in Paradise and hope to see you back here soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great Getaway!

Reviewed by Unknown on 2019-03-08
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
A lovely private rental with everything you need!
Manager response on 2019-03-11 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Andrew, Thank you for your 5 star review on Conch Heaven! We are so happy to hear how much you loved this incredible Key West home and hope you decide to come back and see us soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Loved Canch Heaven

Reviewed by Michele f. on 2019-04-01
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great place would stay again
Manager response on 2019-04-02 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Michele, Thank you for your wonderful 5 star review on Conch Heaven! We are so happy to hear that you loved this incredible Key West home. We enjoyed having you as our guest in Paradise and hope to see you again very soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

A most relaxing and beautiful home!

Reviewed by Anne S. on 2019-03-21
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We all loved Conch Heaven! Beautifully furnished, very clean, great open layout with kids downstairs and parents up, short walk to Pepe's, Old Town Bakery, marina, quiet residential area but close enough to Duval. Private back deck and dipping pool was kid's favorite! Brian was awesome and very responsive! An overall excellent stay and highly recommend Conch Heaven!
Manager response on 2019-03-22 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Anne, Thank you for your incredible 5 star review on Conch Heaven! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this incredible Key West home and that your stay was relaxing and most enjoyable. The location is very convenient to some of the island's best restaurants. Thank you for being our guest and please come back and see us soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Adorable

Reviewed by Unknown on 2019-05-11
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Loved this place. Located in a charming neighborhood. The dipping pool is the perfect place to relax. We lucked out and found one of the few free parking spots nearby, so we just left our car parked and walked everywhere. (Just be sure the spot does not say resident permit) Perfect for two couples.
Manager response on 2019-05-13 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Karen, Thank you for your wonderful 5 star review on Conch Heaven! We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed the desirable location and refreshing dip pool. We hope you had the best time while in Key West and that you come back very soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Conch HEAVEN! Truly is Heaven

Reviewed by Dia W. on 2019-04-19
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This was an exclusive rental property. Clean, cheery and comfortable located in an awesome central location. Brian the rental manager was TOP NOTCH! I will only be contacting Best of Key West Rentals for my next vacation. They are a local company that responds to your concerns immediately.
Manager response on 2019-04-22 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Dia, Thank you for your wonderful 5 star review on Conch Heaven! We are so thrilled to hear that your vacation in Key West was so amazing at this centrally located home. We loved having you as our guest and hope to see you back in Paradise soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Awesome place

Reviewed by Rory R. on 2019-06-01
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great location
Great house
Perfect for Key West
Manager response on 2019-06-03 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Rory, Thank you for your wonderful review on Conch Heaven! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this Key West retreat. We appreciate your incredible feedback and hope to see you back in Paradise very soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Adorable house, great location!

Reviewed by Unknown on 2019-06-18
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We went down with another couple to celebrate my birthday and had the absolute best time. The house is even cuter in person.

We walked almost everywhere that we needed to go and took full advantage of the kitchen. It is well stocked with dishes, utensils and cooking tools.

We thought that the pool might be too small from the pictures, but it turned out to be the perfect size for lounging. We had 4 adults staying on site and for the most part, we fit 3 people in the pool at a time and one person sun bathed. It was perf.

Brian, the home manager was stellar and made our stay very easy. Would definitely rent from both this company and this specific house again.
Manager response on 2019-06-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Emily, Thank you for your incredible review on Conch Heaven. We are so thrilled to hear how wonderful your birthday celebration was at this incredible Key West home. We enjoyed hosting you in Paradise and hope to see you back very soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Key West Dream

Reviewed by Charlene M. on 2019-11-11
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a wonderful time. The house was lovely and it came with all of the essentials we would need. Even came with beach towels. Brian the manager was attentive and informed us of anything we needed to know
Manager response on 2019-11-11 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Charlene, Thank you for your incredible review! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and we hope to see you back again soon. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great Stay in our little Key West House!

Reviewed by Krystal B. on 2019-08-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a wonderful stay at the house. Everything was provided for, check in was super easy, all of the appliances worked perfectly, and we had an awesome property manager that not only responded quickly, but also made sure the house was perfectly comfortable and clean when we arrived. We would definitely recommend staying at this great house on Fleming which is near some of our favorite places in old town Key West!
Manager response on 2019-08-23 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Krystal, Thank you for your kind words on your recent stay. We are so happy to hear that your entire experience was so incredible and we hope to have you back as our guest soon! Best Regards, Wendy ZIntsmaster and Team

Great House!

Reviewed by Unknown on 2019-09-29
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Rented house for a birthday trip with family. Was able to check in early and the house was very clean. Nice bedrooms and bathrooms with plenty of towels. Kitchen was small but had full size appliances and a washer/dryer. The back deck was small but enough room for us and the pool was great for relaxing. Very private out on deck. Stairs to upstairs were a little narrow but the room was great. Location was quiet and not far from shopping and dining, most in walking distance. Also the Duval Loop free bus stop was just a short walk from house. Would definitely recommend this house!
Manager response on 2019-10-01 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Charlotte, Thank you for your wonderful review! We are so thrilled to hear how perfect this home was for your Key West vacation. We appreciate your feedback and hope to see you back very soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Perfect!

Reviewed by Candy B. on 2019-11-16
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Easy & delightful! Beautiful home in great location. Responsive & helpful staff. Will stay again!
Manager response on 2019-11-17 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Candy, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this home and we hope to see you back again soon. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great place to stay

Reviewed by Barbara M. on 2019-10-20
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We came down with another couple. It was great having the bedrooms on separate levels. This place was very clean. More than enough towels and beach towels. Our concierge Brian was awesome! He responded immediately! The cocktail pool was great to come back
to and cool off in after a long hot day in Key West. The only thing I would recommend is the owner needs to put a larger stand up mirror over the master bath sink. The mirror by the toilet was awkward. By no means would I say this was a deal breaker to stay
here. Just a recommendation. Great place to stay!!!
Manager response on 2019-10-24 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Barbara, Thank you for your wonderful review! We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this home and hope to see you back again soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Conch Heaven

Reviewed by Unknown on 2019-12-15
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great location in Old Town..we walkex to Mallory Square..also Duval Street..the beach at FortZachary Taylor was beautiful..
Manager response on 2019-12-16 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Dianne, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you back again soon. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Very convenient , very relaxing.

Reviewed by Unknown on 2019-12-13
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great place to explore the town, engage in all the activities KW has to offer. Also a great place to grab a relaxing afternoon enjoying all the amenities. In addition, the management company was fantastic to work with. Highly recommend.
Manager response on 2019-12-13 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Kenneth, Thank you for your wonderful review! We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this home and we hope to see you back again! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Gorgeous Home

Reviewed by Jana E. on 2020-01-09
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We stayed here for a business trip and the two bedrooms gave us plenty of privacy and comfort. What a great location as well.
Manager response on 2020-01-09 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Jana, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and we hope to see you back soon. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

CONCH HEAVEN ~ Stylish 2B/2Ba, Sleeps 6 in Old Town w/ Heated Cocktail Pool!

Unit Code: CH

CONCH HEAVEN ~ Easy Breezy!

CONCH HEAVEN ~ 2Bd/ 2Ba w/ Sleeper Sofa Close to Beach and Duval w/ heated Cocktail Pool!
OLD TOWN LOCATION... A beautifully furnished and comfortable home, located just 5 short blocks to Duval Street.  Have bikes delivered and you will rarely need your vehicle to get around the Island if at all!  ***PRIMARY GUEST MUST BE AT LEAST 25 YEARS OF AGE FURNISHINGS... Updated furnishings throughout this charming 2 bedroom home.  The living room features vaulted ceilings and has several French doors which open to the deck and pool.  The kitchen is located off the living room and is fully equipped to meet all your cooking needs.  There are ceiling fans and flat screen TVs located in each bedroom as well as closets to store all your belongings. SLEEPING ARRANGEMENTS... The master bedroom is located on the second floor and is outfitted with a comfortable king size bed and full tiled bathroom en suite.  The guest bedroom in on the first floor and has two twin beds which can be conveniently converted to a king to meet your needs.  There is also a full bath located next to the guest bedroom. There is also a queen size sofa bed located in the living room for additional guest sleeping. POOL AND OUTDOOR LIVING... Open the rear French doors and step out to a private small heated pool where you can cool off.  The deck is equipped with two loungers and a small table for two.   PARKING... This home does not have designated parking but there is on street parking in the surrounding neighborhood.  Please refrain from parking in spots marked “residential”. Guests may also park at the Old Town Parking Garage which allows daily and monthly rates, and is 3 blocks away. PETS... One dog is considered at this home. DISTANCES TO BEACHES... Simonton Beach:  0.9  miles Fort Zachary Taylor Beach:  1.6 miles South Beach:  1.3 miles Higgs Beach:  1.2 miles Smathers Beach:  1.8 miles CONCIERGE SERVICES... Enjoy our concierge service to assist you with planning activities for your trip, from bike/scooter/golf cart rentals to any excursion you can think of including snorkeling and sunset cruises, jet ski rentals, parasailing, kayaking, fishing, paddle boarding and much more. They can also have your fridge stocked with all the necessities in advance of your arrival! CANCELLATION... Bookings canceled at least 30 days before the start of stay will receive a 100% refund. Bookings canceled at least 14 days before the start of stay will receive a 50% refund. ENJOY PARADISE!
May 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
June 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
 
July 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
Age 18 and under.
DatesPrice
05/09/2025 - 05/14/2025$304 /nt
05/15/2025 - 05/15/2025$326 /nt
05/16/2025 - 05/16/2025$344 /nt
05/17/2025 - 05/17/2025$346 /nt
05/18/2025 - 05/22/2025$338 /nt
05/23/2025 - 05/23/2025$491 /nt
05/24/2025 - 05/24/2025$514 /nt
05/25/2025 - 05/25/2025$495 /nt
05/26/2025 - 05/29/2025$338 /nt
05/30/2025 - 05/30/2025$467 /nt
05/31/2025 - 05/31/2025$566 /nt
06/01/2025 - 06/01/2025$462 /nt
06/02/2025 - 06/02/2025$421 /nt
06/03/2025 - 06/03/2025$403 /nt
06/04/2025 - 06/04/2025$405 /nt
06/05/2025 - 06/05/2025$489 /nt
06/06/2025 - 06/06/2025$701 /nt
06/07/2025 - 06/07/2025$741 /nt
06/08/2025 - 06/08/2025$584 /nt
06/09/2025 - 06/09/2025$490 /nt
06/10/2025 - 06/10/2025$480 /nt
06/11/2025 - 06/11/2025$544 /nt
06/12/2025 - 06/12/2025$635 /nt
06/13/2025 - 06/13/2025$768 /nt
06/14/2025 - 06/14/2025$680 /nt
06/15/2025 - 06/15/2025$503 /nt
06/16/2025 - 06/16/2025$473 /nt
06/17/2025 - 06/17/2025$493 /nt
06/18/2025 - 06/18/2025$503 /nt
06/19/2025 - 06/19/2025$614 /nt
06/20/2025 - 06/20/2025$649 /nt
06/21/2025 - 06/21/2025$655 /nt
06/22/2025 - 06/22/2025$589 /nt
06/23/2025 - 06/23/2025$533 /nt
06/24/2025 - 06/24/2025$529 /nt
06/25/2025 - 06/25/2025$553 /nt
06/26/2025 - 06/26/2025$642 /nt
06/27/2025 - 06/27/2025$665 /nt
06/28/2025 - 06/28/2025$661 /nt
06/29/2025 - 06/29/2025$523 /nt
06/30/2025 - 06/30/2025$476 /nt
07/01/2025 - 07/01/2025$515 /nt
07/02/2025 - 07/02/2025$557 /nt
07/03/2025 - 07/03/2025$752 /nt
07/04/2025 - 07/04/2025$835 /nt
07/05/2025 - 07/05/2025$812 /nt
07/06/2025 - 07/06/2025$664 /nt
07/07/2025 - 07/07/2025$567 /nt
07/08/2025 - 07/08/2025$485 /nt
07/09/2025 - 07/09/2025$541 /nt
07/10/2025 - 07/10/2025$651 /nt
07/11/2025 - 07/11/2025$738 /nt
07/12/2025 - 07/12/2025$743 /nt
07/13/2025 - 07/13/2025$618 /nt
07/14/2025 - 07/14/2025$575 /nt
07/15/2025 - 07/15/2025$573 /nt
07/16/2025 - 07/16/2025$590 /nt
07/17/2025 - 07/17/2025$682 /nt
07/18/2025 - 07/18/2025$744 /nt
07/19/2025 - 07/19/2025$765 /nt
07/20/2025 - 07/20/2025$556 /nt
07/21/2025 - 07/21/2025$525 /nt
07/22/2025 - 07/22/2025$528 /nt
07/23/2025 - 07/23/2025$577 /nt
07/24/2025 - 07/24/2025$674 /nt
07/25/2025 - 07/25/2025$742 /nt
07/26/2025 - 07/26/2025$809 /nt
07/27/2025 - 07/27/2025$774 /nt
07/28/2025 - 07/28/2025$754 /nt
07/29/2025 - 07/29/2025$809 /nt
07/30/2025 - 07/30/2025$956 /nt
07/31/2025 - 07/31/2025$1,062 /nt
08/01/2025 - 08/01/2025$825 /nt
08/02/2025 - 08/02/2025$839 /nt
08/03/2025 - 08/03/2025$670 /nt
08/04/2025 - 08/04/2025$605 /nt
08/05/2025 - 08/05/2025$603 /nt
08/06/2025 - 08/06/2025$626 /nt
08/07/2025 - 08/07/2025$750 /nt
08/08/2025 - 08/08/2025$884 /nt
08/09/2025 - 08/09/2025$906 /nt
08/10/2025 - 08/10/2025$738 /nt
08/11/2025 - 08/11/2025$681 /nt
08/12/2025 - 08/12/2025$621 /nt
08/13/2025 - 08/13/2025$625 /nt
08/14/2025 - 08/14/2025$774 /nt
08/15/2025 - 08/15/2025$872 /nt
08/16/2025 - 08/16/2025$859 /nt
08/17/2025 - 08/17/2025$650 /nt
08/18/2025 - 08/18/2025$584 /nt
08/19/2025 - 08/19/2025$501 /nt
08/20/2025 - 08/20/2025$493 /nt
08/21/2025 - 08/21/2025$618 /nt
08/22/2025 - 08/22/2025$720 /nt
08/23/2025 - 08/23/2025$709 /nt
08/24/2025 - 08/24/2025$505 /nt
08/25/2025 - 08/25/2025$432 /nt
08/26/2025 - 08/26/2025$390 /nt
08/27/2025 - 08/27/2025$385 /nt
08/28/2025 - 08/28/2025$505 /nt
08/29/2025 - 08/29/2025$880 /nt
08/30/2025 - 08/30/2025$865 /nt
08/31/2025 - 08/31/2025$666 /nt
09/01/2025 - 09/01/2025$577 /nt
09/02/2025 - 09/02/2025$432 /nt
09/03/2025 - 09/03/2025$436 /nt
09/04/2025 - 09/04/2025$554 /nt
09/05/2025 - 09/05/2025$671 /nt
09/06/2025 - 09/06/2025$675 /nt
09/07/2025 - 09/07/2025$510 /nt
09/08/2025 - 09/10/2025$338 /nt
09/11/2025 - 09/11/2025$414 /nt
09/12/2025 - 09/12/2025$526 /nt
09/13/2025 - 09/13/2025$539 /nt
09/14/2025 - 09/14/2025$376 /nt
09/15/2025 - 09/17/2025$338 /nt
09/18/2025 - 09/18/2025$433 /nt
09/19/2025 - 09/19/2025$590 /nt
09/20/2025 - 09/20/2025$604 /nt
09/21/2025 - 09/21/2025$419 /nt
09/22/2025 - 09/24/2025$372 /nt
09/25/2025 - 09/25/2025$503 /nt
09/26/2025 - 09/26/2025$615 /nt
09/27/2025 - 09/27/2025$633 /nt
09/28/2025 - 09/28/2025$451 /nt
09/29/2025 - 10/01/2025$372 /nt
10/02/2025 - 10/02/2025$499 /nt
10/03/2025 - 10/03/2025$582 /nt
10/04/2025 - 10/04/2025$634 /nt
10/05/2025 - 10/05/2025$459 /nt
10/06/2025 - 10/06/2025$383 /nt
10/07/2025 - 10/07/2025$372 /nt
10/08/2025 - 10/08/2025$411 /nt
10/09/2025 - 10/09/2025$547 /nt
10/10/2025 - 10/10/2025$745 /nt
10/11/2025 - 10/11/2025$779 /nt
10/12/2025 - 10/12/2025$591 /nt
10/13/2025 - 10/13/2025$512 /nt
10/14/2025 - 10/14/2025$453 /nt
10/15/2025 - 10/15/2025$432 /nt
10/16/2025 - 10/16/2025$550 /nt
10/17/2025 - 10/17/2025$1,320 /nt
10/18/2025 - 10/18/2025$1,359 /nt
10/19/2025 - 10/19/2025$1,129 /nt
10/20/2025 - 10/20/2025$1,257 /nt
10/21/2025 - 10/21/2025$1,341 /nt
10/22/2025 - 10/22/2025$1,524 /nt
10/23/2025 - 10/23/2025$1,772 /nt
10/24/2025 - 10/24/2025$1,928 /nt
10/25/2025 - 10/25/2025$1,722 /nt
10/26/2025 - 10/26/2025$1,233 /nt
10/27/2025 - 10/27/2025$574 /nt
10/28/2025 - 10/28/2025$595 /nt
10/29/2025 - 10/29/2025$576 /nt
10/30/2025 - 10/30/2025$716 /nt
10/31/2025 - 10/31/2025$866 /nt
11/01/2025 - 11/01/2025$1,344 /nt
11/02/2025 - 11/02/2025$1,157 /nt
11/03/2025 - 11/03/2025$1,074 /nt
11/04/2025 - 11/04/2025$1,092 /nt
11/05/2025 - 11/05/2025$1,069 /nt
11/06/2025 - 11/06/2025$1,265 /nt
11/07/2025 - 11/07/2025$1,384 /nt
11/08/2025 - 11/08/2025$1,389 /nt
11/09/2025 - 11/09/2025$1,220 /nt
11/10/2025 - 11/10/2025$1,103 /nt
11/11/2025 - 11/11/2025$914 /nt
11/12/2025 - 11/12/2025$679 /nt
11/13/2025 - 11/13/2025$821 /nt
11/14/2025 - 11/14/2025$891 /nt
11/15/2025 - 11/15/2025$913 /nt
11/16/2025 - 11/16/2025$740 /nt
11/17/2025 - 11/17/2025$622 /nt
11/18/2025 - 11/18/2025$645 /nt
11/19/2025 - 11/19/2025$646 /nt
11/20/2025 - 11/20/2025$800 /nt
11/21/2025 - 11/21/2025$857 /nt
11/22/2025 - 11/22/2025$860 /nt
11/23/2025 - 11/23/2025$694 /nt
11/24/2025 - 11/24/2025$825 /nt
11/25/2025 - 11/25/2025$833 /nt
11/26/2025 - 11/26/2025$825 /nt
11/27/2025 - 11/27/2025$960 /nt
11/28/2025 - 11/28/2025$1,013 /nt
11/29/2025 - 11/29/2025$1,019 /nt
11/30/2025 - 11/30/2025$629 /nt
12/01/2025 - 12/01/2025$531 /nt
12/02/2025 - 12/02/2025$549 /nt
12/03/2025 - 12/03/2025$569 /nt
12/04/2025 - 12/04/2025$980 /nt
12/05/2025 - 12/05/2025$1,068 /nt
12/06/2025 - 12/06/2025$1,175 /nt
12/07/2025 - 12/07/2025$892 /nt
12/08/2025 - 12/08/2025$653 /nt
12/09/2025 - 12/09/2025$637 /nt
12/10/2025 - 12/10/2025$645 /nt
12/11/2025 - 12/11/2025$744 /nt
12/12/2025 - 12/12/2025$1,033 /nt
12/13/2025 - 12/13/2025$1,037 /nt
12/14/2025 - 12/14/2025$916 /nt
12/15/2025 - 12/15/2025$660 /nt
12/16/2025 - 12/16/2025$630 /nt
12/17/2025 - 12/17/2025$627 /nt
12/18/2025 - 12/18/2025$707 /nt
12/19/2025 - 12/19/2025$963 /nt
12/20/2025 - 12/20/2025$979 /nt
12/21/2025 - 12/21/2025$1,004 /nt
12/22/2025 - 12/22/2025$1,033 /nt
12/23/2025 - 12/23/2025$1,063 /nt
12/24/2025 - 12/24/2025$1,220 /nt
12/25/2025 - 12/25/2025$1,247 /nt
12/26/2025 - 12/26/2025$1,552 /nt
12/27/2025 - 12/27/2025$1,574 /nt
12/28/2025 - 12/28/2025$1,711 /nt
12/29/2025 - 12/29/2025$1,782 /nt
12/30/2025 - 12/30/2025$1,794 /nt
12/31/2025 - 12/31/2025$1,824 /nt
01/01/2026 - 01/01/2026$1,844 /nt
01/02/2026 - 01/02/2026$1,392 /nt
01/03/2026 - 01/03/2026$1,398 /nt
01/04/2026 - 01/04/2026$1,376 /nt
01/05/2026 - 01/05/2026$960 /nt
01/06/2026 - 01/06/2026$919 /nt
01/07/2026 - 01/07/2026$883 /nt
01/08/2026 - 01/08/2026$926 /nt
01/09/2026 - 01/09/2026$1,060 /nt
01/10/2026 - 01/10/2026$1,084 /nt
01/11/2026 - 01/11/2026$990 /nt
01/12/2026 - 01/12/2026$854 /nt
01/13/2026 - 01/13/2026$839 /nt
01/14/2026 - 01/14/2026$869 /nt
01/15/2026 - 01/15/2026$1,210 /nt
01/16/2026 - 01/16/2026$1,316 /nt
01/17/2026 - 01/17/2026$1,447 /nt
01/18/2026 - 01/18/2026$1,324 /nt
01/19/2026 - 01/19/2026$1,058 /nt
01/20/2026 - 01/20/2026$1,045 /nt
01/21/2026 - 01/21/2026$1,064 /nt
01/22/2026 - 01/22/2026$1,144 /nt
01/23/2026 - 01/23/2026$1,219 /nt
01/24/2026 - 01/24/2026$1,242 /nt
01/25/2026 - 01/25/2026$924 /nt
01/26/2026 - 01/26/2026$1,086 /nt
01/27/2026 - 01/27/2026$1,128 /nt
01/28/2026 - 01/28/2026$1,122 /nt
01/29/2026 - 01/29/2026$1,109 /nt
01/30/2026 - 01/30/2026$1,053 /nt
01/31/2026 - 01/31/2026$1,068 /nt
02/01/2026 - 02/01/2026$1,036 /nt
02/02/2026 - 02/02/2026$997 /nt
02/03/2026 - 02/03/2026$1,020 /nt
02/04/2026 - 02/04/2026$1,068 /nt
02/05/2026 - 02/05/2026$1,160 /nt
02/06/2026 - 02/06/2026$1,225 /nt
02/07/2026 - 02/07/2026$1,260 /nt
02/08/2026 - 02/08/2026$1,160 /nt
02/09/2026 - 02/09/2026$1,147 /nt
02/10/2026 - 02/10/2026$1,164 /nt
02/11/2026 - 02/11/2026$1,303 /nt
02/12/2026 - 02/12/2026$1,498 /nt
02/13/2026 - 02/13/2026$1,505 /nt
02/14/2026 - 02/14/2026$1,564 /nt
02/15/2026 - 02/16/2026$1,424 /nt
02/17/2026 - 02/17/2026$1,202 /nt
02/18/2026 - 02/18/2026$1,238 /nt
02/19/2026 - 02/19/2026$1,301 /nt
02/20/2026 - 02/20/2026$1,346 /nt
02/21/2026 - 02/21/2026$1,361 /nt
02/22/2026 - 02/22/2026$1,286 /nt
02/23/2026 - 02/23/2026$1,278 /nt
02/24/2026 - 02/24/2026$1,266 /nt
02/25/2026 - 02/25/2026$1,274 /nt
02/26/2026 - 02/26/2026$1,306 /nt
02/27/2026 - 02/27/2026$1,320 /nt
02/28/2026 - 02/28/2026$1,313 /nt
03/01/2026 - 03/01/2026$1,241 /nt
03/02/2026 - 03/02/2026$1,229 /nt
03/03/2026 - 03/03/2026$1,218 /nt
03/04/2026 - 03/04/2026$1,346 /nt
03/05/2026 - 03/05/2026$1,274 /nt
03/06/2026 - 03/06/2026$1,600 /nt
03/07/2026 - 03/07/2026$1,608 /nt
03/08/2026 - 03/08/2026$1,553 /nt
03/09/2026 - 03/09/2026$1,562 /nt
03/10/2026 - 03/10/2026$1,560 /nt
03/11/2026 - 03/11/2026$1,579 /nt
03/12/2026 - 03/12/2026$1,625 /nt
03/13/2026 - 03/13/2026$1,644 /nt
03/14/2026 - 03/14/2026$1,648 /nt
03/15/2026 - 03/15/2026$1,271 /nt
03/16/2026 - 03/16/2026$1,266 /nt
03/17/2026 - 03/17/2026$1,250 /nt
03/18/2026 - 03/18/2026$1,252 /nt
03/19/2026 - 03/19/2026$1,290 /nt
03/20/2026 - 03/20/2026$1,301 /nt
03/21/2026 - 03/21/2026$1,296 /nt
03/22/2026 - 03/22/2026$1,194 /nt
03/23/2026 - 03/23/2026$1,189 /nt
03/24/2026 - 03/24/2026$1,175 /nt
03/25/2026 - 03/25/2026$1,193 /nt
03/26/2026 - 03/26/2026$1,249 /nt
03/27/2026 - 03/28/2026$1,279 /nt
03/29/2026 - 03/29/2026$1,157 /nt
03/30/2026 - 03/30/2026$1,146 /nt
03/31/2026 - 03/31/2026$1,124 /nt
04/01/2026 - 04/01/2026$1,134 /nt
04/02/2026 - 04/02/2026$1,194 /nt
04/03/2026 - 04/03/2026$1,222 /nt
04/04/2026 - 04/04/2026$1,213 /nt
04/05/2026 - 04/05/2026$1,070 /nt
04/06/2026 - 04/06/2026$1,045 /nt
04/07/2026 - 04/07/2026$1,138 /nt
04/08/2026 - 04/08/2026$1,042 /nt
04/09/2026 - 04/09/2026$1,122 /nt
04/10/2026 - 04/10/2026$1,159 /nt
04/11/2026 - 04/11/2026$1,145 /nt
04/12/2026 - 04/12/2026$967 /nt
04/13/2026 - 04/13/2026$907 /nt
04/14/2026 - 04/14/2026$870 /nt
04/15/2026 - 04/15/2026$888 /nt
04/16/2026 - 04/16/2026$992 /nt
04/17/2026 - 04/17/2026$1,045 /nt
04/18/2026 - 04/18/2026$1,254 /nt
04/19/2026 - 04/19/2026$872 /nt
04/20/2026 - 04/21/2026$820 /nt
04/22/2026 - 04/22/2026$896 /nt
04/23/2026 - 04/23/2026$1,038 /nt
04/24/2026 - 04/24/2026$1,098 /nt
04/25/2026 - 04/25/2026$1,108 /nt
04/26/2026 - 04/26/2026$919 /nt
04/27/2026 - 04/27/2026$847 /nt
04/28/2026 - 04/28/2026$812 /nt
04/29/2026 - 04/29/2026$880 /nt
04/30/2026 - 04/30/2026$1,025 /nt
05/01/2026 - 05/01/2026$1,230 /nt
05/02/2026 - 05/02/2026$1,079 /nt
05/03/2026 - 05/03/2026$871 /nt
05/04/2026 - 05/04/2026$787 /nt
05/05/2026 - 05/05/2026$752 /nt
05/06/2026 - 05/06/2026$833 /nt
05/07/2026 - 05/07/2026$991 /nt
05/08/2026 - 05/08/2026$1,072 /nt
05/09/2026 - 05/09/2026$1,074 /nt
4.9326
(89 Review)

Relaxing Getaway

November 2024
, Downers Grove, IL Unknown

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Conch Heaven was a perfect spot for my wife and another couple. We were close to everything yet tucked away enough to enjoy the front porch and backyard pool area in calm serenity. We hope to be back!

Relaxing Getaway

November 2024
, Downers Grove, IL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Conch Heaven was a perfect spot for my wife and another couple. We were close to everything yet tucked away enough to enjoy the front porch and backyard pool area in calm serenity. We hope to be back!

Great house

October 2024
, Park Ridge, IL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Enjoyed our stay.

Conch Heaven is Heaven

September 2024
, Centreville, VA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Conch Heaven is the cutest little place. Perfect getaway that is close to everything.

Cozy retreat close to everything

April 2024
, Brooklyn, NY US

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

We had a lovely time at this key west home, close to downtown but relaxing and peaceful street/neighborhood. The tiny pool was a cool welcome, and the home was clean. It would have been helpful if they were able to let us store our luggage or check in earlier, but management was easy to text with.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Jennifer, we are thrilled you enjoyed this property. We wish we could all our guest check in early and check out late. The cleaners are on a tight schedule on our busy island so we must respect that to make sure all our guest enjoy a squeaky clean rental. Our concierge service does offer luggage storage however although we understand it isn't as easy as staying in the home a little longer. We hope this won't keep you from staying with us again. Thank you for being our guest!

Fishing birthday trip

April 2024
, Merritt Island, FL US

Overall
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The place was very quaint, well decorated and comfortable. Close to restaurants on both sides of thee island. We would definitely stay here again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Cute little house. Great bathrooms

March 2024
, Davidson, NC United States

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
4
Property condition
4

The entire thing as far as the house itself went was A-plus! It was perfect for us. It had it all. The two down sides were the pool which was only a dipping pool was not clean. There was mold around the edges and inside. Yuck. Also, there was no allotted parking and we had to literally walk blocks to park. Not fun.

Manager's Response

We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us! We are looking into why the pool wasn't clean, please reach out to your property manager so we can fix any issue as soon as possible and make sure the rest of your trip goes smoothly. We would love to welcome you back!

Lovely

February 2024
, Butler, PA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The home was very clean and perfect for our family. We liked the experience better than staying in a hotel as we did the previous visit to Key West. It was nice to have a “home” to go to after sight seeing. This home is perfect for a small family. The rental process is super easy and Whitney did a fantastic job communicating with us about our stay. I wish we had booked an extra couple of days!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Brett. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Conch Heaven

February 2024
, Amherst, NY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Thank you for our stay! The home was clean and in a great location near the town of Key West. It is a quiet area & that's what we wanted. You could ride bikes into town. The Conch Train was fun for our 7 year old to ride with us and hear about Key West.The property manager responded to our questions quickly and we were able to check in a bit early.Since we drove from Buffalo, NY we were really ready to unpack. Thank you!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review Nancy. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Great experience

February 2024
, Rye Brook, NY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Well appointed well decorated lovely house in excellent neighborhood

Manager's Response

Thank you for this short and sweet five star review, we hope to have the pleasure to host you again next time you visit the island.

Great Stay!

January 2024
, Shelter Island, NY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

The description of the property was spot on. We rented bikes during our stay which made getting to and from the heart of town very easy. We had no issues during our stay so did not have to contact the property manager, but they were communicative and responsive prior to our arrival. We loved the heated cocktail pool for relaxing in the afternoon and evening. I would absolutely recommend this home to friends and family.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

key west conch heaven

December 2023
, Miramar, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great place. Very comfortable and close enough to everything.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Fantastic Property

December 2023
, Midlothian, VA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The property was perfect, just what we needed. It was comfortable, incredibly clean, in excellent condition and well appointed. Its location is within walking distance to all the popular spots, but still very quiet and private. I would highly recommend the property to others and would love to stay there again!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Key West Adventure

November 2023
, Manahawkin, NJ US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Fabulous! Perfect accommodations for 2 couples to share having basically 2 masters with 2 full baths. Walkable to everything!

Manager's Response

We are so happy you found this property and its location ideal for your get away in Key West Scott. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit!

Coch Heaven

November 2023
, East Amherst, NY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

If you want to stay in old town Key West this is the place. Clean and very nice. Close to walk for coffee and breakfast. 10 minute walk to Duval street. Full of character. The property manager was quick to respond to questions and everything was excellent. Will stay there again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay David. We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Super nice, cozy home.

July 2023
, Neptune Beach, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house was very clean and well appointed. It had all the amenities we needed for our short stay. The communication with the rental company was excellent and always prompt. We will come back and stay here again, no doubt.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Ashley, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

The perfect home away from home

June 2023
, Naples, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

It was our first visit to Key West and the house was absolutely perfect. It was in old town so it was quiet, except for the roosters lol but still close enough to walk to Duvall. We had so much fun and we were able to come back and relax each night. Absolutely, if we ever go to Key West again, we will stay in this home every time.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review Marcel. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Conch heaven was great

June 2023
, Atlanta, GA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a great time , good location, close to everything, the choices for food within walking distance was great. Parking was not a problem, we drove and rented a jeep. Pool was warm. Nice to cool off in . Relaxing .

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Alice, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

60th bday bash

June 2023
, Clarion, PA United States

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
4

First the pictured pool was creative photography. It was 4x6 or even less. Not what we planned. The raft was bigger than the pool and we never used it.
There was a smell of mold. The house manager was great and treated the house with an ionizer yo correct the problem. Otherwise location great and was comfortable.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your honest review Cynthia, the pool is smaller which is not uncommon in Key West, sorry you thought the photos were misleading. We will relay your complaints to the ownership and work on improvements in the future. Thank you for being our guest!

Please see terrific review posted on VRBO

May 2023
, Irvine, NA Unknown

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Hi there. Already left a review of my terrific stay on VRBO, which was posted.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review on VRBO Steve. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

Please see terrific review posted on VRBO

May 2023
, Wilton Manors, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Hi there. Already left a review of my terrific stay on VRBO, which was posted.

Charming and quiet

April 2023
, Chicago, IL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house is charming, on a quiet street a 15-minute walk from the nightlife on Duval, but with a couple of little restaurants and bakeries within only a few blocks. The upstairs room and bath are spacious, while the downstairs bedroom is fine for a couple but a bit cramped for two singles. The house was immaculate with a cute little backyard and plunge pool.

Manager's Response

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay Robert. We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Wonderful Home

April 2023
, Minneapolis, MN US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Couldn't have asked for a better place to stay. The pictures and description are 100% accurate. We were two families traveling with toddlers, the cocktail pool was perfect for the littles during the day, and adults lounging at night. Location is fantastic, quiet street within walking distance to restaurants, bars, and the water. 11/10!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Britta. We are thrilled you loved this home and hope to host you again soon!

Perfect in Paradise

March 2023
, Atlanta, GA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The Conch Heaven cottage was exactly as it is portrayed in the photos and description on VRBO. There were no surprises; only delights. The house is a quick bike ride or walk to most of Key West, and the free shuttle service, the Duval Loop, has a stop just a block away. If you're heading to Dry Tortugas National Park, the Yankee Freedom ferry is docked 2 blocks away. The house was spotless, and the beds were comfy.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review Grayson. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Perfect in Paradise

March 2023
, ATL, GA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The Conch Heaven cottage was exactly as it is portrayed in the photos and description on VRBO. There were no surprises; only delights. The house is a quick bike ride or walk to most of Key West, and the free shuttle service, the Duval Loop, has a stop just a block away. If you're heading to Dry Tortugas National Park, the Yankee Freedom ferry is docked 2 blocks away. The house was spotless, and the beds were comfy.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review Grayson. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Great Key West vacation

February 2023
, Wellington, FL United States

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
4
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Really well located vacation home in central Key West. We came for 2 nights with our kids which loved the small pool.

We would recommend this rental

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Charles! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Cute Key West Bungalow

January 2023
, Cleveland, OH Unknown

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house was fantastic. So cute. Perfect for 2-4 people. Great plunge pool in the back. Amazing location, walking distance from many restaurants and about 15 min to Duval.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Annie. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Conch Heaven

October 2022
, Lantana, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Our group enjoy the accommodations at the lovely home on Fleming Avenue. The small little dipping pool was perfect for our evening cocktail hour and we found everything we needed. The property manager was very responsive when we needed help.

Manager's Response

Thank you so much for your review Linda. We really appreciate you taking the time out to share your experience with us — and we agree, Brian is truly a gem to have on our team! We count ourselves lucky for guests like you. We look forward to hosting you again in the future!

Key West- Adults Only Getaway

August 2022
, Raleigh, NC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We were a group of two couples- looking to enjoy a kid-free getaway. This did not disappoint! We were in walking distance to everything, and the home was fully stocked with what we needed. A perfect mini-vacation!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Kati, we are so glad the property met your needs while staying with us. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit Key West.

Great place and great location

July 2022
, Cape Coral, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great communication, very responsive and I was able to text them which was convenient. We loved the place and will definitely be back. The little pool was perfect for cooling off and socializing after exploring all day.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Art, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much you are planning on coming back! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Walker Stay

July 2022
, Palm Beach Gardens, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had an amazing time at the house. Location was great house was great concierge service was great

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review Todd. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Off the Beaten Path, But in a Nice Way

May 2022
, Georgetown, KY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

Enjoyed this lovely little condo. Plenty or room for a couple (or two couples). The living space is open and comfortable and the little pool is a really nice bonus. While it isn't within walking distance of Duval Street, it is a quick Uber ride to get to anywhere on the island. The surrounding neighborhood is quiet and there is a little grocery store on the same block, which is handy for snacks.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Rick. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Would definitely stay again!

April 2022
, THORNTON, PA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Perfect, classy home in a great walkable location!

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Janice! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Great Vacation!

April 2022
, Henrico, VA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The property was exactly as described and pictured online. Perfect location, close enough to the best bars, restaurants and activities but far enough away to escape the noise and activity when ready. The property manager was very responsive and great to work with. Be sure to rent bikes, it's the best way to get around the island. Brunch at Blue Heaven is a must. The highlight of our trip was a full day charter with Captain Mike and Aquaholics Charters.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Michelle. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Heaven in Conch Heaven

March 2022
, Racine, WI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great location. Beautiful street and a few blocks from Duval. Spacious well appointed house. Small backyard with private dipping pool.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review Royal. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Conch Heaven is just right!

March 2022
, West Des Moines, IA Unknown

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Conch Heaven is a great house in the perfect location! We were close to our favorite restaurants in a very pedestrian friendly neighborhood. The house is immaculate, well appointed. Special thanks to our property manager, Ryan, for the extra attention and kind assistance during our stay. We enjoyed our visit!

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Mary! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Small charm great location and service

December 2021
, Ardmore, PA United States

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
3

Place is cozy but small. It needs a little love and TLC to look and feel more like the pictures. Walls are scuffy and things are starting to show some wear and tear. Kitchen could use a bit more of everything. It was well stocked with supplies to get our 10 day stay off and running which was nice. Brian the Prop Mgr was a great communicator and treated us with ultra white gloves as well.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Ari, we are glad you enjoyed your stay and will address the small issues you mentioned as best as we can. We hope to host you again next time you decide to visit Key West!

Key West Prime Location

December 2021
, Decatur, IL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great place for a stay in Key West. The neighborhood was very well kept, safe and quiet. Close to shopping, dining and fun. Very clean and maintained home.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Darren, it was a pleasure hosting you!

Fantastic getaway

December 2021
, Brentwood, TN US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house was located out of the fray, but near enough to walk anywhere. We rented mopeds to maximize our touring, and it was hands down the best choice. Another bonus was the Azur Restaurant, a block away. We enjoyed this Italian delight so much, we wished we hadn’t eaten anywhere else.

The house is very well appointed with everything you need, and you won’t find a better host!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Chad, we are glad you enjoyed your stay and hope to welcome you again next time you visit the island!

A wonderful stay...

November 2021
, Fort Lauderdale, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We have a wonderful stay at Conch Heaven. The house was perfect for our needs. The house was bright, clean, and easy to use. It was exactly as described. We had one minor issues (we flipped a breaker) and management was quick to respond (it was fixed in no time). Far better than any hotel. Thanks for everything!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your great review Edward! It was a pleasure hosting you!

Great house!

November 2021
, Maumee, OH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We really enjoyed staying at the house. It was very clean and nicely decorated. It was close to a lot of restaurants and shops.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Jenny, we are thrilled you enjoyed your stay so much and hope to host you again next time you visit Key West!

2021 getaway

September 2021
, Westville, IN US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Everything was perfect. House was clean and so pretty. Kitchen and bathrooms were well stocked and clean. Loved the back patio and cute pool! Brian was very helpful with check in and check out too!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Dawn. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back soon!

Getaway to Key West

September 2021
, Oakland, ME US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
4

It was a lovely getaway.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Melissa, we are thrilled you enjoyed your stay and hope to host you again in the future!

YES, this is a good one!

August 2021
, BURLINGTON, NC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Easy check in, we were fortunate enough to even get in a few hours early! Well appointed, we had everything we needed for light cooking. Very clean! A easy walk to Duvall Street. No problem finding street parking in the area.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back soon!

Cute!

August 2021
, Draper, UT US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This house is perfect! 2 couples stayed and there was plenty of room for all of us. It is a quiet neighborhood and has a store right down the street to get food and essentials. The pool is small but it was so fun to dip in and hang with friends. The property manager was easy to talk to when arriving and leaving. We will definitely be keeping this gem on our list to return to in the future!

Manager's Response

We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us Debra! We are looking forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Perfection

July 2021
, Watkinsville, GA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This house is absolute perfection... the location, the house, the neighbors... literally everything about this place was perfect. Property management was simple, easy, clears, and no issues at all! Just as described in the home details. The location couldn’t be more perfect for quiet yet in the midst of everything. Rent a golf cart and explore the island!!

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Cole, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much and hope you'll choose to stay with us again next time you visit Key West!

Great House

July 2021
, Old Hickory , TN US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

The house was beautiful and very clean. Brian was always very helpful and I would highly recommend this house to anyone. We will be staying here again.

Manager's Response

We are so glad you enjoyed your stay with us Wendy! We look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West!

Perfect place to stay in key west!

May 2021
, New Philadelphia, OH United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The home was spotless upon arrival. It had more than everything we needed. We stopped and bought food and cooked a lot of our meals in the well equipped kitchen. We loved the washer and dryer. The bed upstairs was extremely comfortable. The showers were awesome. Our favorite part was the privacy of the back deck and the cocktail pool. We enjoyed that every day. We were able to walk to Duval quite easily. I will absolutely stay here again! Thanks to Brian for staying up to date with me they texting and being so kind and courteous!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We are so happy you had a great time and hope to see you again!

Adorable

May 2021
, Long Beach, CA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This home is adorable and in a great location. We had bikes delivered and rode everywhere we needed to go. It was perfect. The property management people were great! I would absolutely stay here again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We hope to see you again soon!

Perfect February Getaway

February 2021
, MADISON, WI United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The home was lovely and it was easy to relax. The location was great - close to Duval St, but far enough away that it was quiet and calm. The host was easy to contact and very responsive to any questions that came up.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your recent review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back again soon!

Heated Pool

January 2021
, Clearwater, FL US

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

Nice little home. Clean, spacious and well maintained. Our main reason for renting this place was the heated pool since this was January trip. It was a really nice amenity. It's a quick walk to Duval street and there is a little store on the corner. The only complaint is parking, or lack thereof. Parking is nearly impossible. There is no designated parking spot and most are reserved for permit holders. On arrival we spent almost 90 minutes circling the neighboring blocks looking for a parking place. Once we found one a block away we left the rental car in the same spot for the whole visit. Even during the weekdays all of the spots on the block were filled or reserved.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your recent review. We are sorry if you had issues with parking - this home does not come with parking as advertised. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back soon!

Christmas Getaway

December 2020
, SHARPSBURG, GA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Rental was clean and comfortable. Great location with easy bike ride access to all of the sights and restaurants.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review! We hope to see you again soon!

Highly recommend! Will book again.

November 2020
, Washington, DC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The place was clean, comfortable, and well-appointed with plenty of linens, beach towels, and kitchen needs. The back is very private. The neighborhood is quiet and friendly and far enough away from Duval that you don't get any disruptions, though a nice, easy walk when you want to head that way. Parking was easy - there was always a nearby available space on the street. We will look to book this place again next year, or at least with this company. The property manager was very nice and responded quickly to all of our questions.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your incredible review. We hope to see you again soon!

Great overall experience

October 2020
, LAKE KIOWA, TX US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We were in Key West for my wife’s Birthday and wanted to be close enough to Duval and the other attractions that we could walk comfortably, yet far enough away to insure peace and quiet. Conch Heaven was a 100% match. The house is well appointed and everything works, The property manager, Brian, was very attentive and knowledgeable. We always felt that whatever our need, he would be available to accommodate. We didn’t expect the pool to be important, but we ended up enjoying it every afternoon after our activities. We would definitely recommend Conch Heaven to anyone.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled you had such a great time and hope to see you again soon!

The perfect getaway-every detail

September 2020
, Pompano Beach, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We were a part of six with a four year old. The house was immaculate. Beds were comfy. Kitchen has full cooking capabilities & utensils. We cooked every meal for three days. Washed our clothes. Rocking chairs on front porch for chilling. Back deck w/pool & gas grille was perfect also. Uber drivers flood the island and respond in 5 minutes. Although it's a very short walk to Duval. Fleming St is a central as you can get. For a family house, you can't beat iit.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to see you again soon!

Great Weekend Getaway

August 2020
, Weston, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Rented this cute home for a long weekend. Clean, spacious and had everything you would need. Quiet part of town but great location. Will definitely be back!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to see you again soon!

Beautiful home! Extremely clean.

August 2020
, Granbury, TX United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

Great little home! Super clean. Was perfect to walking to one of the trolly stops and restaurants.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to see you again soon!

Will always return to this home!

July 2020
, New york, NY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Everything was flawless!!! Absolutely the best communication with the rental company and the house was perfection!!!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review! We are thrilled that you enjoyed Conch Heaven, we hope to see you again soon!

Diving in key west

July 2020
, Marksvile, LA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The conch was perfect Bikeable to the dive boat and all the nice places on duval and everything else beautiful key west has to offer

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We hope to see you again soon!

A Needed Getaway

June 2020
, Fairfax, VA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

Despite the virus, we had a great time! The place was perfect for the 2 of us! Really enjoyed the 4 nights.

Manager's Response

Dear Steve,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you loved your stay and hope to see you again.


Best,


Wendy Zinsmaster and Team

Wonderful winter getaway

February 2020
, Marietta, GA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

What a cute little house. Everything we wanted to do was a walk or bike ride away. No car needed. The house was immaculate, and the property manager was kind and helpful throughout our stay. We can’t wait to visit again.

Manager's Response

Dear Deborah,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you enjoyed this rental and hope to see you back again soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Beautiful Home

January 2020
, Huron, OH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Spent 4 days with family, home was spacious and close to everything

Manager's Response

Dear Michelle,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this home and how to see you back soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Gorgeous Home

January 2020
, United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We stayed here for a business trip and the two bedrooms gave us plenty of privacy and comfort. What a great location as well.

Manager's Response

Dear Jana,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and we hope to see you back soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Very convenient , very relaxing.

December 2019
, Hawthorn Woods, IL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great place to explore the town, engage in all the activities KW has to offer. Also a great place to grab a relaxing afternoon enjoying all the amenities. In addition, the management company was fantastic to work with. Highly recommend.

Manager's Response

Dear Kenneth,


Thank you for your wonderful review! We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this home and we hope to see you back again!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Conch Heaven

November 2019
, PANAMA CITY, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great location in Old Town..we walkex to Mallory Square..also Duval Street..the beach at FortZachary Taylor was beautiful..

Manager's Response

Dear Dianne,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you back again soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Key West Dream

November 2019
, Ellicott CIty, MD United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a wonderful time. The house was lovely and it came with all of the essentials we would need. Even came with beach towels. Brian the manager was attentive and informed us of anything we needed to know

Manager's Response

Dear Charlene,


Thank you for your incredible review! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and we hope to see you back again soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Perfect!

October 2019
, Columbia, SC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
3
Property condition
5

Easy & delightful! Beautiful home in great location. Responsive & helpful staff. Will stay again!

Manager's Response

Dear Candy,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this home and we hope to see you back again soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great place to stay

October 2019
, Tinley Park, IL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We came down with another couple. It was great having the bedrooms on separate levels. This place was very clean. More than enough towels and beach towels. Our concierge Brian was awesome! He responded immediately! The cocktail pool was great to come back
to and cool off in after a long hot day in Key West. The only thing I would recommend is the owner needs to put a larger stand up mirror over the master bath sink. The mirror by the toilet was awkward. By no means would I say this was a deal breaker to stay
here. Just a recommendation. Great place to stay!!!

Manager's Response

Dear Barbara,


Thank you for your wonderful review! We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this home and hope to see you back again soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great House!

September 2019
, Pawnee, IL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Rented house for a birthday trip with family. Was able to check in early and the house was very clean. Nice bedrooms and bathrooms with plenty of towels. Kitchen was small but had full size appliances and a washer/dryer. The back deck was small but enough room for us and the pool was great for relaxing. Very private out on deck. Stairs to upstairs were a little narrow but the room was great. Location was quiet and not far from shopping and dining, most in walking distance. Also the Duval Loop free bus stop was just a short walk from house. Would definitely recommend this house!

Manager's Response

Dear Charlotte,


Thank you for your wonderful review! We are so thrilled to hear how perfect this home was for your Key West vacation. We appreciate your feedback and hope to see you back very soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great Stay in our little Key West House!

August 2019
, Pensacola, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a wonderful stay at the house. Everything was provided for, check in was super easy, all of the appliances worked perfectly, and we had an awesome property manager that not only responded quickly, but also made sure the house was perfectly comfortable and clean when we arrived. We would definitely recommend staying at this great house on Fleming which is near some of our favorite places in old town Key West!

Manager's Response

Dear Krystal,


Thank you for your kind words on your recent stay. We are so happy to hear that your entire experience was so incredible and we hope to have you back as our guest soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy ZIntsmaster and Team

Adorable house, great location!

June 2019
, United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

We went down with another couple to celebrate my birthday and had the absolute best time. The house is even cuter in person.

We walked almost everywhere that we needed to go and took full advantage of the kitchen. It is well stocked with dishes, utensils and cooking tools.

We thought that the pool might be too small from the pictures, but it turned out to be the perfect size for lounging. We had 4 adults staying on site and for the most part, we fit 3 people in the pool at a time and one person sun bathed. It was perf.

Brian, the home manager was stellar and made our stay very easy. Would definitely rent from both this company and this specific house again.

Manager's Response

Dear Emily,


Thank you for your incredible review on Conch Heaven. We are so thrilled to hear how wonderful your birthday celebration was at this incredible Key West home. We enjoyed hosting you in Paradise and hope to see you back very soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Awesome place

May 2019
, Lafayette, LA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great location
Great house
Perfect for Key West

Manager's Response

Dear Rory,


Thank you for your wonderful review on Conch Heaven! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this Key West retreat. We appreciate your incredible feedback and hope to see you back in Paradise very soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Adorable

April 2019
, Lenexa , KS US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Loved this place. Located in a charming neighborhood. The dipping pool is the perfect place to relax. We lucked out and found one of the few free parking spots nearby, so we just left our car parked and walked everywhere. (Just be sure the spot does not say resident permit) Perfect for two couples.

Manager's Response

Dear Karen,


Thank you for your wonderful 5 star review on Conch Heaven! We are so thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed the desirable location and refreshing dip pool. We hope you had the best time while in Key West and that you come back very soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Vacation

April 2019
, Boylston, MA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Had a wonderful time and the accommodations were fantastic.

Manager's Response

Dear Stephen,


Thank you for your 5 star review on Conch Heaven! We are so happy to hear that you loved this incredible Key West retreat. We loved having you as our guest in Paradise and hope to see you back here soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Conch HEAVEN! Truly is Heaven

April 2019
, Longboat Key, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This was an exclusive rental property. Clean, cheery and comfortable located in an awesome central location. Brian the rental manager was TOP NOTCH! I will only be contacting Best of Key West Rentals for my next vacation. They are a local company that responds to your concerns immediately.

Manager's Response

Dear Dia,


Thank you for your wonderful 5 star review on Conch Heaven! We are so thrilled to hear that your vacation in Key West was so amazing at this centrally located home. We loved having you as our guest and hope to see you back in Paradise soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great experience!

March 2019
, Cleveland, OH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Everything about our stay was great! Brian was very helpful with the up-front communication, check-in instructions, and even came out to check on the temperature of the pool for us. Location was great and house was in a quiet spot, yet a quick walk or bike ride to Duval street and other local attractions. Would definitely recommend and stay here again!

Manager's Response

Dear Danielle,


Thank you for your wonderful review on Conch Heaven! We are thrilled to hear how much you loved this incredible Key West home located in Old Town Key West. Brian is a real gem to our company and we are so happy to hear that he was so helpful during your stay. We loved having you as our guest and hope you come back and see us soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

A most relaxing and beautiful home!

March 2019
, West Melbourne, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We all loved Conch Heaven! Beautifully furnished, very clean, great open layout with kids downstairs and parents up, short walk to Pepe's, Old Town Bakery, marina, quiet residential area but close enough to Duval. Private back deck and dipping pool was kid's favorite! Brian was awesome and very responsive! An overall excellent stay and highly recommend Conch Heaven!

Manager's Response

Dear Anne,


Thank you for your incredible 5 star review on Conch Heaven! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this incredible Key West home and that your stay was relaxing and most enjoyable. The location is very convenient to some of the island's best restaurants. Thank you for being our guest and please come back and see us soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Loved Canch Heaven

March 2019
, Lewiston, NY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great place would stay again

Manager's Response

Dear Michele,


Thank you for your wonderful 5 star review on Conch Heaven! We are so happy to hear that you loved this incredible Key West home. We enjoyed having you as our guest in Paradise and hope to see you again very soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Girls Trip

March 2019
, New Albany, OH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a wonderful time. The home has a great location. Very central. Close enough to walk or bike, yet quite enough for relaxing. Everything was clean and organized and the management company did a great job with communication.

Manager's Response

Dear Lori,


Thank you for your 5 star review on Conch Heaven. We appreciate all your wonderful feedback on your recent Key West stay and are so happy that you loved this incredible home in the perfect location. We hope you come back to Key West soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

The Barbie Dream House

February 2019
, Hancock, NH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This was our second year staying in Conch Heaven for our annual girls getaway. We nicknamed it the our Barbie Dream House. The house and the neighborhood are perfect for our group of four. Easy walk to the crazy fun on and around Duval, but a quiet clean escape at the end of the night. The little pool was perfect for morning dip with coffee and evening dip before bed.

Brian, the property manager, was incredibly helpful and responsive to our questions and requests.

Manager's Response

Dear Kristen,


Thank you for your wonderful 5 star review on Conch Heaven aka The Barbie Dream House! We are thrilled to hear how much you enjoyed this unit in terms of location and amenities. We loved having you as our guest and hope to see you back in Paradise very soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great Getaway!

February 2019
, Saint Louis, MO US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

A lovely private rental with everything you need!

Manager's Response

Dear Andrew,


Thank you for your 5 star review on Conch Heaven! We are so happy to hear how much you loved this incredible Key West home and hope you decide to come back and see us soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great Bungalow

February 2019
, Bothell, WA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Perfect location just close enough to the action, but quiet at night. Parking can be a challenge, but we walked everywhere. Very cozy, clean and perfect for a small family or two couples. Very nice! Would definitely stay again!

Manager's Response

Dear Lorraine,


Thank you for your wonderful 5 star review on Conch Heaven. We are so happy to hear how much you enjoyed this incredible Key West home and it's perfect location to all the fun. Parking in Old Town Key West can be difficult so we don't recommend driving your personal vehicle around, but to take advantage of Uber on the island. We loved hosting you in Paradise and hope you return soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Nicely appointed, tastefully renovated and very clean!

January 2019

Overall
5

Our party of 5 women totally enjoyed this home! We felt the location was perfect to all things to enjoy in Old Town Key West. It was clean and totally met our needs in the way of household necessities. The "dipping" pool in the back felt more like a spa minus the jets, but perfect for having a cocktail and gathering in and around. We rented bikes, which for our group was the best way to get around. Any questions, or issues were answered immediately by a local contact and even a concierge service was available to assist with planning and arranging things to do. I would highly recommend this property!

Very Nice!

January 2019

Overall
5

This house was great. It was well stocked, clean, great location and really comfortable. The services of the management company was outstanding. Brian was attentive and very helpful. Everyone we encountered on the island was friendly. We felt perfectly safe in all areas and being by the harbor was outstanding. Eaton bikes was prompt and friendly, the bikes really nice. We were a bit worried about not having a parking space, but a car is really not needed there as long as you have the Uber app. The pool is really more of a large hot tub but we enjoyed it in the evening when it was cool. Grill was easy to use. We really enjoyed how dog friendly the island is, we were able to take the little guy almost everywhere. The house location in Old Town was convenient to everything that mattered.

Great stay

December 2018
, United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great location & spce. Brian was very helpful in setting us up for arrival and departure. Would definitely rent again.

Manager's Response

Dear Ryan,


Thank you for your wonderful review on Conch Heaven! We are so happy to hear how great your trip was in this perfectly located Key West home. We appreciate the great feedback and look forward to seeing you again in Paradise!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great Stay!

December 2018

Overall
5

Rating Details: The property manager was very helpful. The vacation rental was spotless. I was very happy with the location. I was very satisfied with the condition of the vacation rental. Overall, I recommend this vacation rental. Reviewer Comments: Great location & spce. Brian was very helpful in setting us up for arrival and departure. Would definitely rent again.

The property was perfect, exactly as shown

November 2018

Overall
5

We loved the property and are already working on plans to return.

Love at first sight!

November 2018

Overall
5

I knew I made the right choice as soon as I opened the door. Though it was only my husband and I staying, I can see how the layout would be absolutely perfect for two couples or a family of four. The private pool is small but PRIVATE! We felt completely comfortable our entire trip and our host, Brian was easily accessible. I loved it and if I return to Key West I will either stay here again or try to buy it ;)

Fantastic Key West Conch Home in Great Spot!!

September 2018

Overall
5

We loved every minute of it! Coffee on the porch, watching the world go by. Cocktails in the plunge pool... Amazing location within walking distance to everything. Very comfortable house, perfect for our needs. The upstairs bath is a little funky and missing a proper mirror but fine for a week's stay. The house could use a full length mirror somewhere too. Other than that, it was absolutely perfect. Will definitely be back!!

Leave a Review
2 Bed
2 Baths
Sleeps 6

Search Availability

BEACH HOUSE ~ Prestigious!

BEACH HOUSE ~ Home Set on Quaint, Private Lane and Close to Everything!

Location

316 Admiral Lane
33040 Key West , FL
United States
24° 33' 22.788" N, 81° 48' 21.78" W
See map: Google Maps
Florida US

BEACH HOUSE ~ Prestigious!

Request More Information

Beach House Key West

Reviewed by Unknown on 2025-04-16
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We much enjoyed our half month stay at the Beach House in Key West. It is located in the Truman Annex and almost everything is within walking distance. Quiet neighborhood mostly, except for the flight path overhead. Pool is very nice. The pool deck is warped and hazardous but still serviceable. The pool accumulates debries from the surrounding flora that needs to be removed by the tenant each day. The furnishings in the house are very nice. Bring your own toiletries.The products provided are in limited supply and not really worth using anyway. The host was gracious and very helpful. We appreciated their demeanor and would enjoy staying there again. We booked through VRBO. VRBO tacked on a substantial charge for a service that until recently was free. Overall, we were quite pleased and would rent again, only directly from Key West Rentals.

Beautiful home in the Truman Annex

Reviewed by Sallie C. on 2024-03-11
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Excellent location. The host was very responsive to our needs. The property functioned well for our group of six. We hoped to stay there next year but the price increase for 2025 was prohibitive for us.
Manager response on 2024-05-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Sallie, we are thrilled you enjoyed your stay so much you were planning on coming back! Unfortunately many factors including the rise in utilities, taxes and other necessities have prompted the increase for next year. Please reach out to our reservation team at your earliest convenience so we can help you find a similar property within the same budget. Thank you for being our guest!

Locatioon, location, location!

Reviewed by Unknown on 2024-12-15
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This was a family vacation with six adults and two babies. Location was key! Loved the little splash pad and park. Great walk-ability!
The only improvement needed is the quality of paper products(toilet paper and paper towels) provided.
Manager response on 2024-12-31 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Ron. It was a pleasure hosting you , we will send your suggestion to the cleaning crew. We hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

BEACH HOUSE IS PERFECT

Reviewed by Joseph S. on 2024-07-01
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Perfect location, accommodation, and management. The house is minutes from Ft Zachary, great restaurants, Mallory Square and nightlife. Our group was tough to impress (all KW veterans) and the jaws all dropped.
Manager response on 2024-12-31 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your fantastic review. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Key West Vacation at the Beach House!

Reviewed by Unknown on 2024-08-17
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Home was fantastic and we enjoyed every minute and will be coming back.
Manager response on 2024-12-31 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this great review! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

A wonderful place to call home

Reviewed by Molly D. on 2022-11-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The Beach House was perfect in so many ways -
1) Enough room for 4 couples to be together and apart - be it on the veranda overlooking the pool or on the comfort of your personal bedroom porch.
2) Location, Location, Location -The house is steps from all of the food and drinks Key West has to offer, yet it is a sanctuary from it too.
3) Property Manager Brian Yosit - Questions, problems, suggestions he was ALWAYS available
Do not hesitate to rent this property!
Manager response on 2022-12-30 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your great review Molly. At Best of Key West Rentals, we work hard to offer high-quality service to every guest. We made sure to share this feedback with Brian to give him the recognition that he deserves. He was delighted to hear your feedback. We are thrilled you and your group had such a wonderful stay and hope to welcome you again next time you visit the island!

Key West Trip

Reviewed by Unknown on 2022-12-19
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great location and beautiful home!
Manager response on 2022-12-30 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this great review Wendy! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

Getaway

Reviewed by Matthew M. on 2023-03-27
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The Beach House was more than we all expected. It location to Duval and Ft. Zachary State Park makes this location worth everything. I would recommend to any party of 8 or family. And being in Truman Annex is so peaceful and beautiful.
Manager response on 2023-11-08 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us Matthew! We would love to welcome you back!

Great house but

Reviewed by Unknown on 2022-12-26
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Overall well maintained
Well run rental house
Host is 5+ out of 5
But the proximity to neighbors and town is a mixed blessing
Noise from both can be disturbing if you are outdoors and they are partying hard
You dont want to be indoors
Its florida ........
Manager response on 2022-12-30 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your feedback on your recent stay Kenneth. We are so glad that you enjoyed your time in Key West and understand nearby live music can be an inconvenience. Please reach out to us for your next Key West vacation and we'll be sure to find you a home a little bit further from the night life. Thank you for being our guest!

Love this town!!

Reviewed by Gene M. on 2023-05-01
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Extremely nice house in Key West. Can't beat the location. Large pool compared to most houses in KW.
Manager response on 2023-11-08 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Gene. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Backyard beauty

Reviewed by Mark R. on 2023-04-17
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Our family of 7 with a baby had a great time at the Beach House!! We particularly loved the huge back porch overlooking the pool and beautiful tropical foliage. We spent lots of time together in that porch and in the pool. It was nice to relax and have peaceful time after spending time out and about in key west!
Manager response on 2023-12-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Mark. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Great Trip!

Reviewed by Kathy T. on 2023-05-30
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This house was perfect for our trip. Great location but in the quiet(er) part of Key West (Truman Annex is a beautiful neighborhood!). We had a wonderful week.
Manager response on 2023-12-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Kathy. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

Beach House - Truman Annex

Reviewed by Della L. on 2023-12-06
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Exceeded our expectations! Located close to many attractions and Duval St. Very clean and well maintained - it had everything we needed. The property manager was very nice. We would recommend this property to anyone wanting fantastic amenities.
Manager response on 2024-05-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

Amazing Location

Reviewed by Wendy B. on 2021-10-11
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Third time staying in this home. Great home and location. Rental agent is very helpful.
Manager response on 2021-11-09 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Wendy, we are thrilled you enjoyed another stay and look forward to welcoming you again soon!

Amazing Vacation Week

Reviewed by Pamela T. on 2021-05-30
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had 7 adults in our party - highly recommend this place for this scenario. The property was well maintained, clean, and provided enough space for all. The area was quiet and private, yet a short walk out to the hotspots of Duval. The management team was super responsive to any questions before our stay. Small issue with Annex gate key was handled swiftly. We are already thinking about our next year's stay here.
Manager response on 2021-06-01 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review. We are so happy you had a great time and hope to see you again!

Wedding getaway

Reviewed by Unknown on 2021-12-01
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Perfect!
Manager response on 2021-12-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so glad your stay was perfect Adina! Please come visit us again soon.

Perfect Winter Escape

Reviewed by Peggy R. on 2021-01-21
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This home was perfect for our winter escape from the cold. We loved how close it was to all the fun, but still very quiet and peaceful at the house. The pool and back porch were our favorite spot to spend time working remotely, relaxing with a cocktail, and enjoying a meal. Texting the property management with any questions always brought a very quick response from Brian. We will most definitely rent again!
Manager response on 2021-01-26 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your kind words. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you again very soon!

Key West Fun Times

Reviewed by Preston M. on 2021-05-17
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Outstanding house and location.
Manager response on 2021-05-17 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review. We hope to see you again soon!

Key West Charm w/Privacy

Reviewed by Brian T. on 2021-08-18
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We love staying at this beautiful pool home. It was a short walk to all the fun of Duval but far enough away that you had privacy from all the action when you wanted it. Would highly recomend it.
Manager response on 2021-08-23 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us Brian and hope to welcome you again soon!

Beach House 2021

Reviewed by Dennis D. on 2021-07-23
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Our party of eight (8) had a wonderful experience at the Beach House. The location, property and house amenities made for an enjoyable vacation.
The back porch and pool area accommodated the entire group from morning to night as the majority of the time was spent outdoors.
We would recommend this property to anyone.
Manager response on 2021-07-26 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dennis thank you so much for this great review! We are delighted to read you enjoyed the property and hope you will stay with us again for your next visit.

Great place to reconnect with friends

Reviewed by Juliann K. on 2021-11-26
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We really enjoyed our stay. Everyone had their own space plus we were able to gather together in the common areas. The pool was wonderful, and the house’s proximity to all the action was very convenient. We would highly recommend it!!
Manager response on 2021-12-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Juliann we are thrilled you and your friend were able to make memories in this home! It was a pleasure hosting you all, we hope to welcome you again next time you visit Key West!

Perfect Stay!

Reviewed by Unknown on 2021-08-23
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Our family had a wonderful stay at the Beach House. Brian, the property manager, was very responsive to our questions and made sure everything was ready for us to checkin as we were coming in right after Tropical Storm Fred. The location is quiet and feels very private which we liked but also very close to Duval Street. Would definitely stay here again!
Manager response on 2021-08-23 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Renata thank you for this wonderful review, we are so glad you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to host you again next time you visit the island!

Beach House in Truman Annex

Reviewed by Dennie B. on 2022-02-07
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house was perfect for our group of four couples who have traveled together and known each other for a long time. Plenty of space to spread out with equal opportunity to join together for meals and spending time together. Open kitchen, dining area and living room. Also lots of outdoor space - patio with pool, covered porch, balcony, heated enclosed porch and two screened in porches. Location was amazing - a few blocks from all the bars, restaurants and shops but in a quiet gated community. It was actually chilly the first few days of our stay and we called the property manager as we could not get the heat on to warm us up a bit. He responded immediately and checked in later to ensure that we had everything we needed. The house was clean with plenty of towels and linens.
We had a wonderful time and would definitely stay at this property again.
Manager response on 2022-02-08 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review Dennie, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Outstanding!

Reviewed by Jennie R. on 2022-05-18
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This was truly the best house I have ever rented, and I have rented many throughout the state of Florida. The property manager was very quick to respond, and very helpful with anything we needed. The house was outstanding, very clean, completely stocked with everything we needed. The dishes and such in the kitchen were more than adequate, especially if you were going to cook any meals at the house. They supplied enough toilet paper, paper towels, dishwasher soap, laundry soap to last the week. We never had to buy additional products. The pool area was lovely and very secluded, we very much enjoyed our time we spent out there. The house is in a lovely neighborhood and is within a very easy walking distance of all of the attractions in Key West. I cannot recommend this house enough or this property management company. I hope to return again to this home. Anything else will be hard to beat!
Manager response on 2022-05-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your incredible review Jennie! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this Key West retreat and we are looking forward to hosting you again next time you visit the island. Thank you for being our guest!

Beautiful House/Fantastic Location

Reviewed by Unknown on 2022-02-24
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house was beautiful and comfortable, all the amenities we needed. The location to the places we like to go was fantastic. We are only sad it is already rented for next year during the time we can vacation :-(.
Manager response on 2022-02-25 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your fantastic review Bonita. Indeed this house is very much in demand but we have many other great houses still available next winter, we would love to help you find a contender. It really was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit the island!

Beach House Stunner

Reviewed by Tina R. on 2021-09-20
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great location, beautiful home with everything you need and more! I particularly loved sitting on the porch overlooking the pool and fabulous garden.
Manager response on 2021-10-04 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review Tina, we are so glad you enjoyed the property and look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit Key West!

Beach House rental

Reviewed by Ed H. on 2022-05-16
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Love the house and location, but only one parking space for 4 bedrooms. The nearest parking lot charged $60 a day for none guests at the resort.
Manager response on 2022-05-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this great review Ed! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property so much! Brian, your property manager, always advises our guests to park at the old school lot as they only charges 15$ a day. It is right around the corner from the house. The house only provides one parking spot but this secondary option is definitely the best deal in town. We hope to have the pleasure to host you again in the future!

Beach House Key West

Reviewed by Justin B. on 2021-08-31
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Overall this house was amazing and we enjoyed our vacation!!
Manager response on 2021-08-31 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back soon!

Beach House-Truman Annex

Reviewed by Debra O. on 2021-09-13
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Four couples, friends for over thirty years decided to vacation together in Key West in one house. A disaster waiting to happen some might say. Not at this home. Each had their own bed/bath and we all got our own space to relax. The house and grounds were immaculate. Truly a tranquil paradise down the street from all the action. Brian of Truman Mgt couldn't have been more helpful. Great time!!
Manager response on 2021-10-04 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Debra we are thrilled your stay with us was so enjoyable. We hope to welcome you again next time you visit the island!

What an Oasis!

Reviewed by Shawne A. on 2019-05-03
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Love this home - we have stayed in several times over the years and keep returning for good reason. Perfect for 4 couples - everyone has private spaces indoors and out - plus plenty of shared space inside and out for wonderful times. Great kitchen too! Brian the property manager was very helpful and accommodating. We will be back!
Manager response on 2019-05-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Shawne, Thank you for your amazing 5 star review on Beach House! We are so thrilled to hear that your return to this incredible Key West home was another big success. The unbeatable indoor/outdoor space truly makes for great entertainment space which is really hard to leave. We loved having you and home to see you back again next year! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Beautiful Home!!!

Reviewed by Wendy B. on 2019-10-18
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This was our groups second time staying in this home. As before everything was great. Home has all the essentials. The location could not be better. Our property manager Brian did a fantastic job assisting us with the rental.
Manager response on 2019-10-18 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Wendy, Thank you for your wonderful review on Beach House. We are so thrilled that you had another great trip to this incredible home. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to have you back once again! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Family Get Away

Reviewed by Thomas R. on 2019-05-27
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Overall excellent experience. Property was great. Communication was very good. Clear and concise directions. We are considering a return trip to this property next year. Comfortable and fully equipt with everything for a weeks stay. I highly recommend this property. You will not be disappointed.
Manager response on 2019-05-28 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Thomas, Thank you for your wonderful review on Beach House! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this incredible home located in the Truman Annex community. We enjoyed having you as our guest in Paradise and hope you come back and see us soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Amazing Property

Reviewed by Unknown on 2019-08-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This home was amazing! Location cannot be beat. However I have to say one of the best experiences with this home was the ease of the booking process and the exceptional guest service of the rental team. Especially Brian! I have rented MANY homes and this by far was the easiest company to work with! Highly recommend renting from them!
Manager response on 2019-08-22 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Lynn, Thank you for your incredible review on Beach House! We are thrilled to hear how seamless your booking experience was. We absolutely enjoyed having you as our guest and hope to see you back soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

perfect key west vacation

Reviewed by Unknown on 2019-12-02
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
perfect location
Manager response on 2019-12-02 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear David, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled you loved this location and home and we hope to see you back soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Awesome rental

Reviewed by Unknown on 2019-09-10
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house is wonderful and in a great location for walking to restaurants a, shopping and of course bar hopping. The only negative is the way the neighborhood is laid out, there is a street that has closed access that gps tries to route you to. Nothing the property can do about it, and the house and outdoor space make up for the minor inconvenience. Would definitely recommend.
Manager response on 2019-09-11 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Sheryl, Thank you for your wonderful review on Beach House! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this incredible home in the Truman Annex community. We are aware of where the GPS leads you which is why we mention in the arrival instructions NOT to follow the GPS once you get to the community. We hope you had a wonderful Key West visit and hope to see you back soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

We loved the Beach House at Truman Annex

Reviewed by Unknown on 2020-01-25
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had an amazing family vacation at the rental. The house was beautiful, well kept, and very clean. It’s located in a beautiful gated neighborhood in the heart of Key West, and a walking distance from al the shops and restaurants. We highly recommend it to anyone who’s planning a vacation in Key West.
Manager response on 2020-01-26 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Yael, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you love this home and hope to see you back again some day. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Pleasantly Surprized

Reviewed by Debbie P. on 2019-12-20
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The house is very spacious and comfortable! Beautiful on the outside as the inside. Grandkids loved playing in the pool all day when not out on the town or hanging out on the beach.Diffantly would stay here again .
Manager response on 2019-12-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Debbie, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you loved this home and we hope to see you back soon. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Best Friends Retreat

Reviewed by Kenneth H. on 2020-08-03
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
My 2 best friends and their wives joined Julie and me for a week we’ll talk about for a long time. What a great place/house to have such a great time. The pool and deck was “spot on” and perfect setting for all of us to fellowship throughout the week. It became our home away from home. The Truman Annex neighborhood was the perfect get away. The house was decorated with excellent detail and clean as a whistle. We will return every year possible....same people, same place and same FUN.
Manager response on 2020-08-03 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review. We hope to host you again soon.

Great Family Vacation

Reviewed by R Jeffrey B. on 2020-06-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Great house & pool just 2 blocks off of Duval Street. Sleeps 8 in the quiet Truman Annex. Large rooms & multiple decks off of bedrooms for a relaxing environment. Property manager Brian very attentive, & concierge Beth was outstanding!
Manager response on 2020-06-23 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
We are so happy you had such an enjoyable experience! We hope we can host you again in the future! Thank you, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team.

Fantastic Stay and Service

Reviewed by Fausto S. on 2020-08-03
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a fantastic stay. Truman and Company are the leaders in the island for rentals and real estate so they made sure all our needs were met. Brian, our property manager, ensured all the necessary cleaning (during covid) was made and then was available for anything we needed. My experience with Truman and Co exceeded the other property management companies I’ve used in years past. Thank you very much!
Manager response on 2020-08-03 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this incredible review. We look forward to hosting you again soon.

Vacation Stay

Reviewed by Michael F. on 2020-10-20
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The family and I had a wonderful stay at the Beach House. It is close to everything and a very private setting making for a very relaxed time. Wendy’ s team, exp Brian and Cecilly,took care of our needs making the stay even more enjoyable. We’ll definitely be back!
Manager response on 2020-10-23 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review. We hope to see you again soon!

Perfect location

Reviewed by Regina F. on 2020-07-02
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We loved staying at the Beach House. It is located so close to everything - so convenient. The house was very clean and comfortable.
Manager response on 2020-07-02 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Regina, Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you soon. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Beach House Review

Reviewed by susan b. on 2020-10-19
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
A great location to get on a bike and go. The location was great. The A/C stopped working and the property manager had someone out to fix it quickly. Note: the parking will only allow one car and no parking is allowed on the street.Highly recommend this property and this rental company!
Manager response on 2020-10-19 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for the wonderful review! We hope to see you again soon!

Ringing in 2021

Reviewed by Dawn D. on 2021-01-04
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Perfect location for tours, shopping and eating. Check-in super accommodating. Great communication with agent. House is quiet and equipped with all the amenities for a long-term stay. Note: Only accommodates one car or Golf cart (not both).
Manager response on 2021-01-12 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

BEACH HOUSE ~ Stunning 4B/4Ba Home with Private Pool in Truman Annex!

Unit Code: ABH

BEACH HOUSE ~ Prestigious!

BEACH HOUSE ~ Home Set on Quaint, Private Lane and Close to Everything!
PRESTIGIOUS TROPICAL RETREAT... Indulge in this spectacular two-story home situated in the premier gated community of historic Truman Annex. Escape to a sun-kissed dream as soon you enter this picturesque community, surrounded by swaying palm trees inviting you to enter your island vacation home which is tucked away on a quiet lane. Totaling 4 beds and 4 baths, this home is perfect for family getaways or for those traveling with couples. A lazy walk will take you to all the local's favorite spots including Fort Zachary Taylor State Park, Truman White House and all the best local bars, restaurants and tourist attractions. ***PRIMARY GUEST MUST BE AT LEAST 25 YEARS OF AGE DETAILS AND AMENITIES... Enter this inviting open floor plan with incredible natural lighting throughout. Three sets of French doors take you from the living/kitchen space out to the outdoor entertainment area, consisting of a private heated lap pool all to yourself, propane gas grill, swing set, outdoor dining for 4, additional outdoor seating and pool loungers. Wood flooring, high ceilings and breezy ceiling fans in each room will keep you cool and refreshed on a sultry summer's day. Whip up your favorite family meals together in the gourmet kitchen that comes with gorgeous granite countertops, custom cabinetry, updated stainless steel appliances and dining for 6.  SLEEPING ARRANGEMENTS... The downstairs guest room comes with a queen size bed and a private porch. There is a full bathroom just outside of this bedroom with a walk in shower. Upstairs you will find the king master bedroom with an en suite full bathroom that comes with a desirable claw tub, walk in glass shower and washer/dryer set. Adjacent to the master bedroom is an enclosed, air-conditioned Florida room with cozy seating which then leads you out to an additional outdoor, covered balcony which incredible views of the lush topical pool area. Steps down the hall is another guest room with a queen size bed, an en suite full bathroom with a shower/tub combination and a private, covered balcony area. The colorful, teal-tiled poolside cottage comes with a queen size bed and an en suite full bath with a shower/tub combination, and it is air-conditioned. All bedrooms are equipped with a flat screen TV and ample closet space including the guest cottage. OUTDOOR LIVING... Cool your senses and quench your island craving with this magnificent outdoor space that offers your own exceptional private poolside lounging space. THIS POOL IS ALL YOURS--YOU DO NOT SHARE IT WITH ANYONE ELSE! Take advantage of the additional outdoor dining space for being able to enjoy your fresh catch of the day in the evening hours followed by swimming under the stars.  This community’s quaint pathways are just a few steps away from all the island's main attractions. PARKING... This home comes with one covered parking space. No trailers, boats, jet skis or motor homes are allowed. No vehicle length over 18’ long, including trailer hitches, or 80” wide is allowed on property. Additional vehicles may park in the Opal Key Resort parking garage just a five minute walk/drive away. PETS... Pets are ONLY permitted for a month stay with a $400 pet fee. Please provide pet size, breed and age upon booking. CONCIERGE SERVICES... Enjoy our concierge service to assist you with planning activities for your trip, from bike/scooter/golf cart rentals to any excursion you can think of including snorkeling and sunset cruises, jet ski rentals, parasailing, kayaking, fishing, paddle boarding and much more. They can also have your fridge stocked with all the necessities in advance of your arrival! CANCELLATION... Bookings canceled at least 30 days before the start of stay will receive a 100% refund. Bookings canceled at least 14 days before the start of stay will receive a 50% refund. SATISFY ALL YOU DESIRE...
May 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
June 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
 
July 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
Age 18 and under.
DatesPrice
05/09/2025 - 05/09/2025$742 /nt
05/10/2025 - 05/10/2025$810 /nt
05/11/2025 - 05/11/2025$689 /nt
05/12/2025 - 05/12/2025$741 /nt
05/13/2025 - 05/13/2025$715 /nt
05/14/2025 - 05/14/2025$809 /nt
05/15/2025 - 05/15/2025$972 /nt
05/16/2025 - 05/16/2025$1,052 /nt
05/17/2025 - 05/17/2025$1,062 /nt
05/18/2025 - 05/18/2025$911 /nt
05/19/2025 - 05/19/2025$731 /nt
05/20/2025 - 05/20/2025$696 /nt
05/21/2025 - 05/21/2025$753 /nt
05/22/2025 - 05/22/2025$886 /nt
05/23/2025 - 05/23/2025$1,331 /nt
05/24/2025 - 05/24/2025$1,337 /nt
05/25/2025 - 05/25/2025$1,402 /nt
05/26/2025 - 05/26/2025$885 /nt
05/27/2025 - 05/27/2025$812 /nt
05/28/2025 - 05/28/2025$868 /nt
05/29/2025 - 05/29/2025$1,008 /nt
05/30/2025 - 05/30/2025$1,104 /nt
05/31/2025 - 05/31/2025$1,350 /nt
06/01/2025 - 06/01/2025$1,152 /nt
06/02/2025 - 06/02/2025$1,087 /nt
06/03/2025 - 06/03/2025$1,051 /nt
06/04/2025 - 06/04/2025$1,109 /nt
06/05/2025 - 06/05/2025$1,283 /nt
06/06/2025 - 06/06/2025$1,400 /nt
06/07/2025 - 06/07/2025$1,419 /nt
06/08/2025 - 06/08/2025$1,076 /nt
06/09/2025 - 06/09/2025$941 /nt
06/10/2025 - 06/10/2025$930 /nt
06/11/2025 - 06/11/2025$939 /nt
06/12/2025 - 06/12/2025$1,080 /nt
06/13/2025 - 06/13/2025$1,155 /nt
06/14/2025 - 06/14/2025$1,158 /nt
06/15/2025 - 06/15/2025$966 /nt
06/16/2025 - 06/16/2025$883 /nt
06/17/2025 - 06/17/2025$881 /nt
06/18/2025 - 06/18/2025$907 /nt
06/19/2025 - 06/19/2025$1,074 /nt
06/20/2025 - 06/20/2025$1,131 /nt
06/21/2025 - 06/21/2025$1,201 /nt
06/22/2025 - 06/22/2025$1,112 /nt
06/23/2025 - 06/23/2025$1,068 /nt
06/24/2025 - 06/24/2025$1,070 /nt
06/25/2025 - 06/25/2025$1,110 /nt
06/26/2025 - 06/26/2025$1,269 /nt
06/27/2025 - 06/27/2025$1,321 /nt
06/28/2025 - 06/28/2025$1,328 /nt
06/29/2025 - 06/30/2025$1,152 /nt
07/01/2025 - 07/01/2025$1,142 /nt
07/02/2025 - 07/02/2025$1,199 /nt
07/03/2025 - 07/03/2025$1,575 /nt
07/04/2025 - 07/04/2025$1,635 /nt
07/05/2025 - 07/05/2025$1,641 /nt
07/06/2025 - 07/06/2025$1,436 /nt
07/07/2025 - 07/07/2025$1,141 /nt
07/08/2025 - 07/08/2025$1,086 /nt
07/09/2025 - 07/09/2025$1,134 /nt
07/10/2025 - 07/10/2025$1,289 /nt
07/11/2025 - 07/11/2025$1,452 /nt
07/12/2025 - 07/12/2025$1,460 /nt
07/13/2025 - 07/13/2025$1,249 /nt
07/14/2025 - 07/14/2025$1,164 /nt
07/15/2025 - 07/15/2025$1,149 /nt
07/16/2025 - 07/16/2025$1,177 /nt
07/17/2025 - 07/17/2025$1,335 /nt
07/18/2025 - 07/18/2025$1,435 /nt
07/19/2025 - 07/19/2025$1,462 /nt
07/20/2025 - 07/20/2025$1,089 /nt
07/21/2025 - 07/21/2025$1,003 /nt
07/22/2025 - 07/22/2025$1,004 /nt
07/23/2025 - 07/23/2025$1,073 /nt
07/24/2025 - 07/24/2025$1,211 /nt
07/25/2025 - 07/25/2025$1,315 /nt
07/26/2025 - 07/26/2025$1,335 /nt
07/27/2025 - 07/27/2025$1,220 /nt
07/28/2025 - 07/28/2025$1,209 /nt
07/29/2025 - 07/29/2025$1,541 /nt
07/30/2025 - 07/30/2025$1,711 /nt
07/31/2025 - 07/31/2025$1,908 /nt
08/01/2025 - 08/01/2025$1,565 /nt
08/02/2025 - 08/02/2025$1,594 /nt
08/03/2025 - 08/03/2025$1,292 /nt
08/04/2025 - 08/04/2025$1,127 /nt
08/05/2025 - 08/05/2025$1,113 /nt
08/06/2025 - 08/06/2025$1,139 /nt
08/07/2025 - 08/07/2025$1,341 /nt
08/08/2025 - 08/08/2025$1,563 /nt
08/09/2025 - 08/09/2025$1,589 /nt
08/10/2025 - 08/10/2025$1,289 /nt
08/11/2025 - 08/11/2025$1,226 /nt
08/12/2025 - 08/12/2025$1,137 /nt
08/13/2025 - 08/13/2025$1,157 /nt
08/14/2025 - 08/14/2025$1,447 /nt
08/15/2025 - 08/15/2025$1,623 /nt
08/16/2025 - 08/16/2025$1,605 /nt
08/17/2025 - 08/17/2025$1,244 /nt
08/18/2025 - 08/18/2025$1,132 /nt
08/19/2025 - 08/19/2025$1,016 /nt
08/20/2025 - 08/20/2025$1,036 /nt
08/21/2025 - 08/21/2025$1,290 /nt
08/22/2025 - 08/22/2025$1,497 /nt
08/23/2025 - 08/23/2025$1,509 /nt
08/24/2025 - 08/24/2025$1,178 /nt
08/25/2025 - 08/25/2025$1,067 /nt
08/26/2025 - 08/26/2025$1,006 /nt
08/27/2025 - 08/27/2025$1,007 /nt
08/28/2025 - 08/28/2025$1,234 /nt
08/29/2025 - 08/29/2025$1,712 /nt
08/30/2025 - 08/30/2025$1,701 /nt
08/31/2025 - 08/31/2025$1,418 /nt
09/01/2025 - 09/01/2025$1,190 /nt
09/02/2025 - 09/03/2025$1,059 /nt
09/04/2025 - 09/04/2025$1,272 /nt
09/05/2025 - 09/05/2025$1,469 /nt
09/06/2025 - 09/06/2025$1,471 /nt
09/07/2025 - 09/07/2025$1,166 /nt
09/08/2025 - 09/08/2025$865 /nt
09/09/2025 - 09/09/2025$804 /nt
09/10/2025 - 09/10/2025$823 /nt
09/11/2025 - 09/11/2025$1,036 /nt
09/12/2025 - 09/12/2025$1,220 /nt
09/13/2025 - 09/13/2025$1,244 /nt
09/14/2025 - 09/14/2025$961 /nt
09/15/2025 - 09/15/2025$844 /nt
09/16/2025 - 09/16/2025$825 /nt
09/17/2025 - 09/17/2025$864 /nt
09/18/2025 - 09/18/2025$1,092 /nt
09/19/2025 - 09/19/2025$1,280 /nt
09/20/2025 - 09/20/2025$1,308 /nt
09/21/2025 - 09/21/2025$1,016 /nt
09/22/2025 - 09/22/2025$894 /nt
09/23/2025 - 09/23/2025$866 /nt
09/24/2025 - 09/24/2025$912 /nt
09/25/2025 - 09/25/2025$1,150 /nt
09/26/2025 - 09/26/2025$1,326 /nt
09/27/2025 - 09/27/2025$1,353 /nt
09/28/2025 - 09/28/2025$1,060 /nt
09/29/2025 - 09/29/2025$856 /nt
09/30/2025 - 09/30/2025$862 /nt
10/01/2025 - 10/01/2025$907 /nt
10/02/2025 - 10/02/2025$1,142 /nt
10/03/2025 - 10/03/2025$1,330 /nt
10/04/2025 - 10/04/2025$1,363 /nt
10/05/2025 - 10/05/2025$1,081 /nt
10/06/2025 - 10/06/2025$968 /nt
10/07/2025 - 10/07/2025$932 /nt
10/08/2025 - 10/08/2025$987 /nt
10/09/2025 - 10/09/2025$1,180 /nt
10/10/2025 - 10/10/2025$1,484 /nt
10/11/2025 - 10/11/2025$1,525 /nt
10/12/2025 - 10/12/2025$1,206 /nt
10/13/2025 - 10/13/2025$1,078 /nt
10/14/2025 - 10/14/2025$970 /nt
10/15/2025 - 10/15/2025$958 /nt
10/16/2025 - 10/16/2025$1,163 /nt
10/17/2025 - 10/17/2025$2,668 /nt
10/18/2025 - 10/18/2025$2,755 /nt
10/19/2025 - 10/19/2025$2,361 /nt
10/20/2025 - 10/20/2025$2,416 /nt
10/21/2025 - 10/21/2025$2,538 /nt
10/22/2025 - 10/22/2025$2,821 /nt
10/23/2025 - 10/23/2025$3,198 /nt
10/24/2025 - 10/24/2025$3,424 /nt
10/25/2025 - 10/25/2025$3,066 /nt
10/26/2025 - 10/26/2025$2,470 /nt
10/27/2025 - 10/27/2025$1,145 /nt
10/28/2025 - 10/28/2025$1,151 /nt
10/29/2025 - 10/29/2025$1,101 /nt
10/30/2025 - 10/30/2025$1,320 /nt
10/31/2025 - 10/31/2025$1,551 /nt
11/01/2025 - 11/01/2025$2,653 /nt
11/02/2025 - 11/02/2025$2,337 /nt
11/03/2025 - 11/03/2025$2,404 /nt
11/04/2025 - 11/04/2025$2,416 /nt
11/05/2025 - 11/05/2025$2,350 /nt
11/06/2025 - 11/06/2025$2,592 /nt
11/07/2025 - 11/07/2025$2,780 /nt
11/08/2025 - 11/08/2025$2,841 /nt
11/09/2025 - 11/09/2025$2,532 /nt
11/10/2025 - 11/10/2025$2,330 /nt
11/11/2025 - 11/11/2025$1,251 /nt
11/12/2025 - 11/12/2025$1,220 /nt
11/13/2025 - 11/13/2025$1,480 /nt
11/14/2025 - 11/14/2025$1,632 /nt
11/15/2025 - 11/15/2025$1,702 /nt
11/16/2025 - 11/16/2025$1,428 /nt
11/17/2025 - 11/17/2025$1,236 /nt
11/18/2025 - 11/18/2025$1,285 /nt
11/19/2025 - 11/19/2025$1,287 /nt
11/20/2025 - 11/20/2025$1,561 /nt
11/21/2025 - 11/21/2025$1,675 /nt
11/22/2025 - 11/22/2025$1,696 /nt
11/23/2025 - 11/23/2025$1,418 /nt
11/24/2025 - 11/24/2025$1,577 /nt
11/25/2025 - 11/25/2025$1,610 /nt
11/26/2025 - 11/26/2025$1,582 /nt
11/27/2025 - 11/27/2025$1,835 /nt
11/28/2025 - 11/28/2025$1,995 /nt
11/29/2025 - 11/29/2025$1,926 /nt
11/30/2025 - 11/30/2025$1,294 /nt
12/01/2025 - 12/01/2025$1,107 /nt
12/02/2025 - 12/02/2025$1,129 /nt
12/03/2025 - 12/03/2025$1,148 /nt
12/04/2025 - 12/04/2025$1,867 /nt
12/05/2025 - 12/05/2025$2,817 /nt
12/06/2025 - 12/06/2025$2,668 /nt
12/07/2025 - 12/07/2025$1,330 /nt
12/08/2025 - 12/08/2025$1,200 /nt
12/09/2025 - 12/09/2025$1,173 /nt
12/10/2025 - 12/10/2025$1,189 /nt
12/11/2025 - 12/11/2025$1,371 /nt
12/12/2025 - 12/12/2025$2,027 /nt
12/13/2025 - 12/13/2025$1,956 /nt
12/14/2025 - 12/14/2025$1,771 /nt
12/15/2025 - 12/15/2025$1,333 /nt
12/16/2025 - 12/16/2025$1,288 /nt
12/17/2025 - 12/17/2025$1,285 /nt
12/18/2025 - 12/18/2025$1,422 /nt
12/19/2025 - 12/19/2025$1,894 /nt
12/20/2025 - 12/20/2025$1,902 /nt
12/21/2025 - 12/21/2025$1,906 /nt
12/22/2025 - 12/22/2025$1,916 /nt
12/23/2025 - 12/23/2025$1,931 /nt
12/24/2025 - 12/24/2025$2,345 /nt
12/25/2025 - 12/25/2025$2,371 /nt
12/26/2025 - 12/26/2025$2,732 /nt
12/27/2025 - 12/27/2025$2,758 /nt
12/28/2025 - 12/28/2025$2,947 /nt
12/29/2025 - 12/29/2025$3,062 /nt
12/30/2025 - 12/30/2025$3,072 /nt
12/31/2025 - 12/31/2025$3,208 /nt
01/01/2026 - 03/30/2026$1,161 /nt
03/31/2026 - 03/31/2026$1,982 /nt
04/01/2026 - 04/01/2026$2,016 /nt
04/02/2026 - 04/02/2026$2,138 /nt
04/03/2026 - 04/03/2026$2,209 /nt
04/04/2026 - 04/04/2026$2,208 /nt
04/05/2026 - 04/05/2026$1,966 /nt
04/06/2026 - 04/06/2026$1,926 /nt
04/07/2026 - 04/07/2026$1,891 /nt
04/08/2026 - 04/08/2026$1,914 /nt
04/09/2026 - 04/09/2026$2,053 /nt
04/10/2026 - 04/10/2026$2,105 /nt
04/11/2026 - 04/11/2026$2,084 /nt
04/12/2026 - 04/12/2026$1,769 /nt
04/13/2026 - 04/13/2026$1,674 /nt
04/14/2026 - 04/14/2026$1,610 /nt
04/15/2026 - 04/15/2026$1,646 /nt
04/16/2026 - 04/16/2026$1,841 /nt
04/17/2026 - 04/17/2026$1,942 /nt
04/18/2026 - 04/18/2026$2,356 /nt
04/19/2026 - 04/19/2026$1,637 /nt
04/20/2026 - 04/20/2026$1,540 /nt
04/21/2026 - 04/21/2026$1,517 /nt
04/22/2026 - 04/22/2026$1,633 /nt
04/23/2026 - 04/23/2026$1,894 /nt
04/24/2026 - 04/24/2026$2,015 /nt
04/25/2026 - 04/25/2026$2,041 /nt
04/26/2026 - 04/26/2026$1,718 /nt
04/27/2026 - 04/27/2026$1,608 /nt
04/28/2026 - 04/28/2026$1,572 /nt
04/29/2026 - 04/29/2026$1,686 /nt
04/30/2026 - 04/30/2026$1,961 /nt
05/01/2026 - 05/01/2026$2,086 /nt
05/02/2026 - 05/02/2026$2,051 /nt
05/03/2026 - 05/03/2026$1,666 /nt
05/04/2026 - 05/04/2026$1,510 /nt
05/05/2026 - 05/05/2026$1,435 /nt
05/06/2026 - 05/06/2026$1,560 /nt
05/07/2026 - 05/07/2026$1,841 /nt
05/08/2026 - 05/08/2026$1,984 /nt
05/09/2026 - 05/09/2026$1,997 /nt
4.9423
(52 Review)

Beach House Key West

April 2025
, Jacksonville, FL Unknown

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

We much enjoyed our half month stay at the Beach House in Key West. It is located in the Truman Annex and almost everything is within walking distance. Quiet neighborhood mostly, except for the flight path overhead. Pool is very nice. The pool deck is warped and hazardous but still serviceable. The pool accumulates debries from the surrounding flora that needs to be removed by the tenant each day. The furnishings in the house are very nice. Bring your own toiletries.The products provided are in limited supply and not really worth using anyway. The host was gracious and very helpful. We appreciated their demeanor and would enjoy staying there again. We booked through VRBO. VRBO tacked on a substantial charge for a service that until recently was free. Overall, we were quite pleased and would rent again, only directly from Key West Rentals.

St Patrick’s day vacation

March 2025
, Gallatin, TN United States

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
3
Cleanliness
3
Location
5
Property condition
2

I have stayed in this property for the last 4 years

Locatioon, location, location!

December 2024
, cincinnati, OH United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

This was a family vacation with six adults and two babies. Location was key! Loved the little splash pad and park. Great walk-ability!
The only improvement needed is the quality of paper products(toilet paper and paper towels) provided.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Ron. It was a pleasure hosting you , we will send your suggestion to the cleaning crew. We hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Key West Vacation at the Beach House!

August 2024
, Port St Lucie, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Home was fantastic and we enjoyed every minute and will be coming back.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

BEACH HOUSE IS PERFECT

June 2024
, Lanham, MD US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Perfect location, accommodation, and management. The house is minutes from Ft Zachary, great restaurants, Mallory Square and nightlife. Our group was tough to impress (all KW veterans) and the jaws all dropped.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Beautiful home in the Truman Annex

March 2024
, Gypsum, CO US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Excellent location. The host was very responsive to our needs. The property functioned well for our group of six. We hoped to stay there next year but the price increase for 2025 was prohibitive for us.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Sallie, we are thrilled you enjoyed your stay so much you were planning on coming back! Unfortunately many factors including the rise in utilities, taxes and other necessities have prompted the increase for next year. Please reach out to our reservation team at your earliest convenience so we can help you find a similar property within the same budget. Thank you for being our guest!

Beach House - Truman Annex

November 2023
, Saraland, AL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Exceeded our expectations! Located close to many attractions and Duval St. Very clean and well maintained - it had everything we needed. The property manager was very nice. We would recommend this property to anyone wanting fantastic amenities.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

Great Trip!

May 2023
, Raleigh, NC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This house was perfect for our trip. Great location but in the quiet(er) part of Key West (Truman Annex is a beautiful neighborhood!). We had a wonderful week.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Kathy. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

Love this town!!

April 2023
, Fairhope, AL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Extremely nice house in Key West. Can't beat the location. Large pool compared to most houses in KW.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Gene. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Backyard beauty

April 2023
, Ocean View, DE United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Our family of 7 with a baby had a great time at the Beach House!! We particularly loved the huge back porch overlooking the pool and beautiful tropical foliage. We spent lots of time together in that porch and in the pool. It was nice to relax and have peaceful time after spending time out and about in key west!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Mark. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Getaway

March 2023
, Platteville, WI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The Beach House was more than we all expected. It location to Duval and Ft. Zachary State Park makes this location worth everything. I would recommend to any party of 8 or family. And being in Truman Annex is so peaceful and beautiful.

Manager's Response

We are so happy to read you had such a good stay with us Matthew! We would love to welcome you back!

Great house but

December 2022
, Great neck, NY US

Overall
4
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

Overall well maintained
Well run rental house
Host is 5+ out of 5
But the proximity to neighbors and town is a mixed blessing
Noise from both can be disturbing if you are outdoors and they are partying hard
You dont want to be indoors
Its florida ........

Manager's Response

Thank you for your feedback on your recent stay Kenneth. We are so glad that you enjoyed your time in Key West and understand nearby live music can be an inconvenience. Please reach out to us for your next Key West vacation and we'll be sure to find you a home a little bit further from the night life. Thank you for being our guest!

Key West Trip

November 2022
, Liberty, NC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great location and beautiful home!

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Wendy! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property and hope to host you again in the future!

A wonderful place to call home

November 2022
, Baltimore, MD US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The Beach House was perfect in so many ways -
1) Enough room for 4 couples to be together and apart - be it on the veranda overlooking the pool or on the comfort of your personal bedroom porch.
2) Location, Location, Location -The house is steps from all of the food and drinks Key West has to offer, yet it is a sanctuary from it too.
3) Property Manager Brian Yosit - Questions, problems, suggestions he was ALWAYS available
Do not hesitate to rent this property!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your great review Molly. At Best of Key West Rentals, we work hard to offer high-quality service to every guest. We made sure to share this feedback with Brian to give him the recognition that he deserves. He was delighted to hear your feedback. We are thrilled you and your group had such a wonderful stay and hope to welcome you again next time you visit the island!

11/ 10 stars

June 2022
, Wenonah , NJ United States

Overall
5

By far the best rental property we have ever stayed in (Key West and beyond)! A patio perfect for quality time, relaxing salt water pool, ideal dinning table for at-home meals, each of the four rooms equipped with a full bath, and a friendly and helpful property manager (the cherry on top)! At the Beach House, you’re provided a private oasis within the gated community of Truman Annex, just a minutes from Duval Street. A short bike ride, 3-minute walk and you’re in the heart of the city. Would 11/10 recommend this home to anyone.

Beach House rental

April 2022

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Love the house and location, but only one parking space for 4 bedrooms. The nearest parking lot charged $60 a day for none guests at the resort.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this great review Ed! We are thrilled you enjoyed the property so much! Brian, your property manager, always advises our guests to park at the old school lot as they only charges 15$ a day. It is right around the corner from the house. The house only provides one parking spot but this secondary option is definitely the best deal in town. We hope to have the pleasure to host you again in the future!

Outstanding!

March 2022
, Traverse City, MI US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This was truly the best house I have ever rented, and I have rented many throughout the state of Florida. The property manager was very quick to respond, and very helpful with anything we needed. The house was outstanding, very clean, completely stocked with everything we needed. The dishes and such in the kitchen were more than adequate, especially if you were going to cook any meals at the house. They supplied enough toilet paper, paper towels, dishwasher soap, laundry soap to last the week. We never had to buy additional products. The pool area was lovely and very secluded, we very much enjoyed our time we spent out there. The house is in a lovely neighborhood and is within a very easy walking distance of all of the attractions in Key West. I cannot recommend this house enough or this property management company. I hope to return again to this home. Anything else will be hard to beat!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your incredible review Jennie! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this Key West retreat and we are looking forward to hosting you again next time you visit the island. Thank you for being our guest!

Beautiful House/Fantastic Location

February 2022
, Greensburg, IN United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house was beautiful and comfortable, all the amenities we needed. The location to the places we like to go was fantastic. We are only sad it is already rented for next year during the time we can vacation :-(.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review Bonita. Indeed this house is very much in demand but we have many other great houses still available next winter, we would love to help you find a contender. It really was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit the island!

Beach House in Truman Annex

January 2022
, Oak Hill, VA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

The house was perfect for our group of four couples who have traveled together and known each other for a long time. Plenty of space to spread out with equal opportunity to join together for meals and spending time together. Open kitchen, dining area and living room. Also lots of outdoor space - patio with pool, covered porch, balcony, heated enclosed porch and two screened in porches. Location was amazing - a few blocks from all the bars, restaurants and shops but in a quiet gated community. It was actually chilly the first few days of our stay and we called the property manager as we could not get the heat on to warm us up a bit. He responded immediately and checked in later to ensure that we had everything we needed. The house was clean with plenty of towels and linens.
We had a wonderful time and would definitely stay at this property again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Dennie, we are so glad you enjoyed the property so much and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you are in Key West.

Wedding getaway

November 2021
, Port Orange, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Perfect!

Manager's Response

We are so glad your stay was perfect Adina! Please come visit us again soon.

Wedding getaway

November 2021
, Port orange, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Perfect!

Manager's Response

We are so glad your stay was perfect Adina! Please come visit us again soon.

Wedding getaway

November 2021
, Port orange, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Perfect!

Manager's Response

We are so glad your stay was perfect Adina! Please come visit us again soon.

Great place to reconnect with friends

November 2021
, Erie, PA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We really enjoyed our stay. Everyone had their own space plus we were able to gather together in the common areas. The pool was wonderful, and the house’s proximity to all the action was very convenient. We would highly recommend it!!

Manager's Response

Juliann we are thrilled you and your friend were able to make memories in this home! It was a pleasure hosting you all, we hope to welcome you again next time you visit Key West!

Amazing Location

October 2021
, St. Charles, MO US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
4

Third time staying in this home. Great home and location. Rental agent is very helpful.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Wendy, we are thrilled you enjoyed another stay and look forward to welcoming you again soon!

Amazing Location

October 2021
, St. Charles, MO US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
4

Third time staying in this home. Great home and location. Rental agent is very helpful.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Wendy, we are thrilled you enjoyed another stay and look forward to welcoming you again soon!

Beach House Stunner

September 2021
, Point Pleasant, WV US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great location, beautiful home with everything you need and more! I particularly loved sitting on the porch overlooking the pool and fabulous garden.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Tina, we are so glad you enjoyed the property and look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit Key West!

Beach House-Truman Annex

September 2021
, Whiting, NJ US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Four couples, friends for over thirty years decided to vacation together in Key West in one house. A disaster waiting to happen some might say. Not at this home. Each had their own bed/bath and we all got our own space to relax. The house and grounds were immaculate. Truly a tranquil paradise down the street from all the action. Brian of Truman Mgt couldn't have been more helpful. Great time!!

Manager's Response

Debra we are thrilled your stay with us was so enjoyable. We hope to welcome you again next time you visit the island!

Beach House Key West

August 2021
, West Palm Beach, FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Overall this house was amazing and we enjoyed our vacation!!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back soon!

Perfect Stay!

August 2021
, Cliffside Park, NJ US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Our family had a wonderful stay at the Beach House. Brian, the property manager, was very responsive to our questions and made sure everything was ready for us to checkin as we were coming in right after Tropical Storm Fred. The location is quiet and feels very private which we liked but also very close to Duval Street. Would definitely stay here again!

Manager's Response

Renata thank you for this wonderful review, we are so glad you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to host you again next time you visit the island!

Key West Charm w/Privacy

July 2021
, Sarasota , FL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We love staying at this beautiful pool home. It was a short walk to all the fun of Duval but far enough away that you had privacy from all the action when you wanted it. Would highly recomend it.

Manager's Response

We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us Brian and hope to welcome you again soon!

Beach House 2021

July 2021
, Salem, OH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Our party of eight (8) had a wonderful experience at the Beach House. The location, property and house amenities made for an enjoyable vacation.
The back porch and pool area accommodated the entire group from morning to night as the majority of the time was spent outdoors.
We would recommend this property to anyone.

Manager's Response

Dennis thank you so much for this great review! We are delighted to read you enjoyed the property and hope you will stay with us again for your next visit.

Amazing Vacation Week

May 2021
, Allison Park, PA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had 7 adults in our party - highly recommend this place for this scenario. The property was well maintained, clean, and provided enough space for all. The area was quiet and private, yet a short walk out to the hotspots of Duval. The management team was super responsive to any questions before our stay. Small issue with Annex gate key was handled swiftly. We are already thinking about our next year's stay here.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We are so happy you had a great time and hope to see you again!

Key West Fun Times

May 2021
, Augusta , GA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Outstanding house and location.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review. We hope to see you again soon!

Perfect Winter Escape

January 2021
, Glenview, IL US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This home was perfect for our winter escape from the cold. We loved how close it was to all the fun, but still very quiet and peaceful at the house. The pool and back porch were our favorite spot to spend time working remotely, relaxing with a cocktail, and enjoying a meal. Texting the property management with any questions always brought a very quick response from Brian. We will most definitely rent again!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your kind words. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you again very soon!

Ringing in 2021

December 2020
, Alexandria, VA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Perfect location for tours, shopping and eating. Check-in super accommodating. Great communication with agent. House is quiet and equipped with all the amenities for a long-term stay. Note: Only accommodates one car or Golf cart (not both).

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to see you back in Key West again soon!

Beach House Review

October 2020
, lake elmo, MN United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

A great location to get on a bike and go. The location was great. The A/C stopped working and the property manager had someone out to fix it quickly. Note: the parking will only allow one car and no parking is allowed on the street.Highly recommend this property and this rental company!

Manager's Response

Thank you for the wonderful review! We hope to see you again soon!

Vacation Stay

September 2020
, Punta Gorda, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

The family and I had a wonderful stay at the Beach House. It is close to everything and a very private setting making for a very relaxed time. Wendy’ s team, exp Brian and Cecilly,took care of our needs making the stay even more enjoyable. We’ll definitely be back!

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review. We hope to see you again soon!

Best Friends Retreat

July 2020
, Raleigh, NC US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

My 2 best friends and their wives joined Julie and me for a week we’ll talk about for a long time. What a great place/house to have such a great time. The pool and deck was “spot on” and perfect setting for all of us to fellowship throughout the week. It became our home away from home. The Truman Annex neighborhood was the perfect get away. The house was decorated with excellent detail and clean as a whistle. We will return every year possible....same people, same place and same FUN.

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review. We hope to host you again soon.

Fantastic Stay and Service

July 2020
, Jupiter, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a fantastic stay. Truman and Company are the leaders in the island for rentals and real estate so they made sure all our needs were met. Brian, our property manager, ensured all the necessary cleaning (during covid) was made and then was available for anything we needed. My experience with Truman and Co exceeded the other property management companies I’ve used in years past. Thank you very much!

Manager's Response

Thank you for this incredible review. We look forward to hosting you again soon.

Perfect location

June 2020
, Marietta, GA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
4
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We loved staying at the Beach House. It is located so close to everything - so convenient. The house was very clean and comfortable.

Manager's Response

Dear Regina,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Great Family Vacation

June 2020
, Bay Point, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Great house & pool just 2 blocks off of Duval Street. Sleeps 8 in the quiet Truman Annex. Large rooms & multiple decks off of bedrooms for a relaxing environment. Property manager Brian very attentive, & concierge Beth was outstanding!

Manager's Response

We are so happy you had such an enjoyable experience! We hope we can host you again in the future! Thank you, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team.

We loved the Beach House at Truman Annex

January 2020
, Waldwick , NJ US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had an amazing family vacation at the rental. The house was beautiful, well kept, and very clean. It’s located in a beautiful gated neighborhood in the heart of Key West, and a walking distance from al the shops and restaurants. We highly recommend it to anyone who’s planning a vacation in Key West.

Manager's Response

Dear Yael,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled to hear how much you love this home and hope to see you back again some day.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Pleasantly Surprized

December 2019
, Murtaugh, ID US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house is very spacious and comfortable! Beautiful on the outside as the inside. Grandkids loved playing in the pool all day when not out on the town or hanging out on the beach.Diffantly would stay here again .

Manager's Response

Dear Debbie,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so happy to hear how much you loved this home and we hope to see you back soon.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

perfect key west vacation

November 2019
, Tucson, AZ United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

perfect location

Manager's Response

Dear David,


Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled you loved this location and home and we hope to see you back soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Beautiful Home!!!

October 2019
, St. Charles, MO US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This was our groups second time staying in this home. As before everything was great. Home has all the essentials. The location could not be better. Our property manager Brian did a fantastic job assisting us with the rental.

Manager's Response

Dear Wendy,


Thank you for your wonderful review on Beach House. We are so thrilled that you had another great trip to this incredible home. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to have you back once again!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Beautiful Home!!!

October 2019
, St. Charles, MO US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This was our groups second time staying in this home. As before everything was great. Home has all the essentials. The location could not be better. Our property manager Brian did a fantastic job assisting us with the rental.

Manager's Response

Dear Wendy,


Thank you for your wonderful review on Beach House. We are so thrilled that you had another great trip to this incredible home. We enjoyed hosting you and hope to have you back once again!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Awesome rental

August 2019
, indianapolis, IN US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
4
Location
5
Property condition
5

The house is wonderful and in a great location for walking to restaurants a, shopping and of course bar hopping. The only negative is the way the neighborhood is laid out, there is a street that has closed access that gps tries to route you to. Nothing the property can do about it, and the house and outdoor space make up for the minor inconvenience. Would definitely recommend.

Manager's Response

Dear Sheryl,


Thank you for your wonderful review on Beach House! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this incredible home in the Truman Annex community. We are aware of where the GPS leads you which is why we mention in the arrival instructions NOT to follow the GPS once you get to the community. We hope you had a wonderful Key West visit and hope to see you back soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Amazing Property

July 2019
, Orlando, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This home was amazing! Location cannot be beat. However I have to say one of the best experiences with this home was the ease of the booking process and the exceptional guest service of the rental team. Especially Brian! I have rented MANY homes and this by far was the easiest company to work with! Highly recommend renting from them!

Manager's Response

Dear Lynn,


Thank you for your incredible review on Beach House! We are thrilled to hear how seamless your booking experience was. We absolutely enjoyed having you as our guest and hope to see you back soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Family Get Away

May 2019
, Cathedral City, CA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Overall excellent experience. Property was great. Communication was very good. Clear and concise directions. We are considering a return trip to this property next year. Comfortable and fully equipt with everything for a weeks stay. I highly recommend this property. You will not be disappointed.

Manager's Response

Dear Thomas,


Thank you for your wonderful review on Beach House! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this incredible home located in the Truman Annex community. We enjoyed having you as our guest in Paradise and hope you come back and see us soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

What an Oasis!

April 2019
, St Petersburg, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Love this home - we have stayed in several times over the years and keep returning for good reason. Perfect for 4 couples - everyone has private spaces indoors and out - plus plenty of shared space inside and out for wonderful times. Great kitchen too! Brian the property manager was very helpful and accommodating. We will be back!

Manager's Response

Dear Shawne,


Thank you for your amazing 5 star review on Beach House! We are so thrilled to hear that your return to this incredible Key West home was another big success. The unbeatable indoor/outdoor space truly makes for great entertainment space which is really hard to leave. We loved having you and home to see you back again next year!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Awesome!

January 2019

Overall
5

Great Place! Very convenient to everything, and in a quiet gated community!

ONE WORD - AMAZING!

January 2019

Overall
5

Everything about this house was amazing. From the time we stepped through the gate to the time we left, our group of seven loved every single thing! There were 3 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms in the main house and 1 bedroom and 1 full bath in the guest house. There is a heated pool in between the house and the guest house which we spent a great deal of time in - in January! Coffee, creamer, soap, dishwashing tablets, detergent, spices, dishes, playing cards, games, puzzles, etc were provided! There wasn't a thing we needed that we couldn't find in the house! The location was also perfect. The house is located within a gated community less than two blocks from Duval Street and about two blocks from Mallory Square! My husband and I were also able to walk to the Ernest Hemingway house, the Southernmost Point and Fort Zachary Taylor Park easily. The only place we drove to during our stay was to the grocery store. We will definitely stay in this house again the next time we visit Key West!

Leave a Review
4 Bed
4 Baths
Sleeps 8

Search Availability

THE SEASHELL ~ Spectacular!

THE SEASHELL ~Private 3B/3Ba Home w/ Heated Pool, Luxury Sound System and Updated Kitchen!

Location

311 William St
33040 Key West , FL
United States
24° 33' 35.7048" N, 81° 48' 1.8216" W
See map: Google Maps
Florida US

THE SEASHELL ~ Spectacular!

Request More Information

Another February at The Seashell

Reviewed by Llewellyn B. on 2025-03-16
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This is a charming rental!
Manager response on 2025-03-19 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Llewellyn thank you for trusting us again. with your Key West get away. We look forward to seeing you again next time you visit the island!

Super location, close to everything

Reviewed by HEIDI D. on 2025-01-03
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Classic Key West house, lots of character and charm. Something for everyone in the family to do, or just chill by the pool
Manager response on 2025-01-03 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Heidi. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Great location

Reviewed by HEIDI D. on 2024-03-28
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Close to everything
Manager response on 2024-07-23 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Heindi, thank you for this short and sweet 5 star review! We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you again soon!

Another day in paradise!

Reviewed by Rick B. on 2024-05-01
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This was the 2d year we rented The Seashell for the month of April. The house is perfect for a small group or family. Its location is perfect and within easy walking distance of all that makes Key West special. More importantly to me, however, is and was the attention to detail and responsiveness of the property manager, Shana Yoest. She is always available to answer a question, attend to a problem or simply offer suggestions, if asked. Truman and Company could not have a better representative of excellent customer service!
Manager response on 2024-07-23 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for sharing a review of your April stay at The Seashell. Our team here at Best of Key West Rentals is committed to providing high-quality guest service, and we’re thrilled to hear that Shana made a good impression on you. We hope you’ll visit us again soon!

Perfect KW Rental

Reviewed by Unknown on 2024-09-30
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We have rented 3x in Key West over the years: 3/2020, 3/2022, and Sept. 2024. This was our favorite rental thus far. Let me first speak about the flexibility and great customer service of the listing company, Best of Key West. They handled our scheduling needs graciously when we needed change the date of our rental and to another listing a few months before our scheduled rental. Also, thank you Shana for being a great property manager.
The house, The Seashell, was spectacular and obviously well cared for by the owners. A highlight is the location, which is in Old town, within a few blocks from the Seaport (2 min walk to Schooner's Wharf) and a 6 minute walk to Duval. Central to everything. The pictures of the house don't do the property justice..... comfortable beds, big glass doors off the family room and porch over looking the amazing pool, fenced in yard WITH DRIVEWAY with a sliding gate for security and privacy. I can go on and on about this quaint, clean, and comfortable location at 311 William Street. We will certainly be back!
Manager response on 2024-09-30 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your incredible review Cristen! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this Key West retreat and we are looking forward to hosting you again next time you visit the island. Thank you for being our guest!

Backyard Paradise!

Reviewed by Sharon S. on 2024-09-13
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We have visited Key West several years every August, but this is the first time we did a monthly rental and also our first time staying in Old Town. We have worked with Truman and Company every year, and their immediate communication and attention to positive guest experience is unrivaled. We had one issue with a faulty appliance, and Shana (the property manager) had a new one delivered the very next day! As for the home, the Seashell provided the quintessential Key West experience--all the charm of an older home with modern decor and conveniences. While we loved everything about our stay, our favorite area was the back porch and pool--especially at night. It was so private, and the perfectly placed lighting in the surrounding foliage created a lovely oasis after a hot day in the sun. Thank you for a wonderful vacation!

Wonderful !

Reviewed by Cliff F. on 2021-05-17
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The home was fantastic. An authentic Key West home. Enjoyed the privacy of the back porch and lounging in the pool in the afternoon. The location is perfect for walking to all the bars, restaurants, entertainment, and the grocery store. When we had questions, Shana was responsive and took care of our issues. I would highly recommend this property and can't wait to return. Thank you.
Manager response on 2021-06-01 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review! We hope to see you back again in the future!

Wonderful home in a wonderful location

Reviewed by Thomas H. on 2021-11-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Absolutely wonderful home in an excellent location: quiet street 3 blocks from Duval & 1.5 blocks from the marina area. The large outside area with a relatively large heated pool area was beautiful, couldn’t have been better. Pictures provide an accurate portrayal of the home. The 3 en suite bedrooms were a plus. Already rented for 2022
Manager response on 2021-11-23 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for this wonderful review Thomas, we are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and look forward to welcoming you again next year!

Great Location!

Reviewed by Sharon S. on 2022-08-16
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We loved staying at The Seashell! Great location! Nice house and nice pool!
Manager response on 2022-09-06 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your fantastic review Sharon. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Great place, great location.

Reviewed by Thomas H. on 2022-11-06
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Our second stay at this property. Great location in the northern marina area. 3 blocks from Duval and 1 block from the marina. 3 bedrooms each with it's own bathroom. Best backyard with beautiful pool and large porch. Wouldn't think of staying anywhere else.
Manager response on 2022-11-08 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for taking the time to post a review of your stay at The Seashell Thomas. We are so happy to hear that you enjoyed another stay in Key West. Our goal is always to exceed your expectations! If there's anything we can help you with during your next visit, please don't hesitate to let us know. Thank you for being our guest!

Great rental in KW

Reviewed by Unknown on 2022-12-16
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Fantastic time in rental. Great location. Staff and support team were very attentive and responsive.
Manager response on 2022-12-16 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Steve, we are so glad the property met your needs while staying with us. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit Key West.

Key West Vacation

Reviewed by william h. on 2022-10-19
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This place was awesome! Back yard very private with a amazing pool. Was a bonus with parking in yard.Easy walking distance to restaurants, grocery store and Duval street.
Property manager Shana was so helpful and took care of everything,
Property very clean and the yard was well maintained.
Five star experience all around.
Manager response on 2022-10-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you so much for your kind words William. We really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience with us — and we agree, Shana is truly a gem to have on our team! We count ourselves lucky for guests like you. We look forward to hosting you again in the future!

Jewel on William Street

Reviewed by Llewellyn B. on 2024-03-07
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This house was charming, nicely decorated and beautifully landscaped. The few problems were addressed promptly by our professional and personable manager, Shana Yoest. Thank you, Shana!
While I wish the owner took credit cards, I thoroughly enjoyed his home and plan to stay again.
Manager response on 2024-03-07 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for taking the time to review your stay Llewellyn. We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Wonderful Historic House in Great Location

Reviewed by Susan S. on 2023-11-14
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We absolutely loved this property. The two things I would like to suggest is for such a beautiful/expensive property there should be better lounge chairs. The ones there are cheap and on has legs that bend when you sit in it. One of our previous rentals had wonderful chairs with rubber/waterproof pads that can also be used in the pool. Also, there should be an empty cabinet for food. No one could possible use all of the dishes/pans etc that fill the cabinets.
Manager response on 2023-11-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your feedback on your recent stay Susan. We are so glad that you enjoyed your time spent at this home. We appreciate your feedback that we will relay back to the owners for consideration. Thank you again and please reach out to us for your next Key West vacation!

Fabulous Backyard

Reviewed by Bridget D. on 2019-05-23
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a lovely stay at this beautiful house. The back yard is amazing--very lush. The pool was the perfect size for our 4 children (very large by Key West standards). Can't beat the location. Walk to everything on the North end of Key West.
Manager response on 2019-05-24 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Bridget, Thank you for your incredible review on The Seashell! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this wonderful Key West home located in the Old Town area of town. The location and amenities make this a great island getaway and we are so happy that you had a great time. Please come back and see us soon! Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Old Town Key West home away from home.

Reviewed by Richard H. on 2020-04-11
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Always a welcoming place for us and our visiting family and friends. Wonderful flowing floor plan compliments our vacation snow bird lifestyle. Great heated pool and convenient off street parking. This past season was our sixth in this great old house.
Manager response on 2020-04-13 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Dear Dr. Hirsh, Thank you for this wonderful review. We always enjoy hosting you at this incredible home and look forward to seeing you again next year. Best Regards, Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Review of The Seashell

Reviewed by Unknown on 2020-08-18
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
This vacation rental was awesome! Two blocks from the Marina where we kept our boat and walking distance to all the wonderful places in Key West. The house was very clean and the manager was amazing. Always available to answer any questions. I would highly recommend this home to anyone who is looking for a great family rental in Key West.
Manager response on 2020-08-20 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you back soon!

Amazing Stay in Key West

Reviewed by Buxton M. on 2020-12-22
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
The moment we arrived at The Seashell we felt completely at home and at ease. Every detail was organized from the beautiful furnishings, layout and art to the chefs kitchen with a full range of cookware and utensils and tableware. Our family of five fit perfectly in this beautiful home.

The landscaped gardens and lovely heated pool were a true escape. As many things as there are to do in Key West, we enjoyed many peaceful hours reading (and napping) by the pool.

The location in Old Town was perfect, very quiet but central. We loved Eaton Street Seafood down the street for great stone crab as well as the Half Shell for oysters at the Marina and the Market Bakery for amazing pastries.

The property was meticulously maintained. Shana the property manager was always extremely responsive and made our stay a pleasure. We look forward to returning soon.
Manager response on 2020-12-30 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your incredible review! We loved hosting you in Paradise. We hope to see you again soon!

Seashell rental

Reviewed by Theodore T. P. on 2021-04-02
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Excellent stay.
Manager response on 2021-04-05 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled you had a wonderful time and look forward to seeing you again next year!

THE SEASHELL ~ Classic, Luxury Old Town Gem with Private Pool & Gardens!

Unit Code: SS

THE SEASHELL ~ Spectacular!

THE SEASHELL ~Private 3B/3Ba Home w/ Heated Pool, Luxury Sound System and Updated Kitchen!
**Please note that this rental only allows for payment by check/E-check. Credit card payment will be subject to additional credit card fees. CLASSIC KEY WEST.... When only the best will do! The Seashell is the classic Old Town Key West home. Perfect setting for your dream island vacation. Located in Old Town and just steps away from the Historic Seaport.  You are in walking distance to some of Key West's best restaurants and boating adventures. ***PRIMARY GUEST MUST BE AT LEAST 25 YEARS OF AGE AMENITIES... This beautifully landscaped home with gracious sitting porch awaits you and your family. Newly renovated master king bedroom and bath are located on the main floor as well as a queen guest room with bath. A spacious great room that flows to the porches, pool and great outdoor space allows for family gatherings and hours of entertaining.  Updated kitchen looks over Sawyer Lane and opens to the pool area for easy outdoor dining.  Lovely Dade County Pine floors throughout and plenty of natural Key West sunshine from the many windows and doors. The second floor has a bonus room featuring a king, bath, office and rooftop sun deck. PARKING... There is parking for up to two vehicles in gated driveway. PETS... This home is not pet-friendly, however the owner may consider making exceptions for certain sizes/breeds. Please feel free to inquire in advance of booking. MULTI MONTH RESERVATIONS... For monthly reservations, the following fees will be added PER MONTH: Mid-stay clean Pool/hot tub heating fee (if applicable) Pet fee (if applicable) BOOKING DATES... This home is only available as a monthly rental (28 night minimum). We prefer to book by the calendar month (first day of the month to the last). We may consider alternate dates if the calendar allows or if the owner will make an exception. CONCIERGE SERVICES... Enjoy our concierge service to assist you with planning activities for your trip, from bike/scooter/golf cart rentals to any excursion you can think of including snorkeling and sunset cruises, jet ski rentals, parasailing, kayaking, fishing, paddle boarding and much more. They can also have your fridge stocked with all the necessities in advance of your arrival! CANCELLATION... Bookings canceled at least 90 days before the start of stay will receive a 100% refund. Cancellations inside of 90 days may receive a refund if we are able to re-rent any or all of the dates of the stay. The refund amount is dependent upon the rate of the new reservation. For multi-month reservations for January through March, a refund will only be offered in the event we are able to re-rent. The refund amount is dependent upon the rate of the new reservation(s). LIVE THE CHARMED LIFE...
May 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
June 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
 
July 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
Age 18 and under.
DatesPrice
05/09/2025 - 05/31/2025$373 /nt
06/01/2025 - 06/30/2025$405 /nt
07/01/2025 - 07/31/2025$408 /nt
08/01/2025 - 08/31/2025$356 /nt
09/01/2025 - 09/30/2025$375 /nt
10/01/2025 - 10/31/2025$447 /nt
11/01/2025 - 11/30/2025$465 /nt
12/01/2025 - 12/31/2025$572 /nt
01/01/2026 - 01/31/2026$929 /nt
02/01/2026 - 02/28/2026$1,032 /nt
03/01/2026 - 03/31/2026$929 /nt
04/01/2026 - 04/30/2026$643 /nt
05/01/2026 - 05/09/2026$429 /nt
5.0000
(24 Review)

Another February at The Seashell

February 2025
, Washington, DC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This is a charming rental!

Manager's Response

Llewellyn thank you for trusting us again. with your Key West get away. We look forward to seeing you again next time you visit the island!

Another February at The Seashell

February 2025
, Washington , DC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This is a charming rental!

Manager's Response

Llewellyn thank you for trusting us again. with your Key West get away. We look forward to seeing you again next time you visit the island!

Super location, close to everything

December 2024
, Leesburg, VA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Classic Key West house, lots of character and charm. Something for everyone in the family to do, or just chill by the pool

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Heidi. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Perfect KW Rental

September 2024
, Marco Island, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We have rented 3x in Key West over the years: 3/2020, 3/2022, and Sept. 2024. This was our favorite rental thus far. Let me first speak about the flexibility and great customer service of the listing company, Best of Key West. They handled our scheduling needs graciously when we needed change the date of our rental and to another listing a few months before our scheduled rental. Also, thank you Shana for being a great property manager.
The house, The Seashell, was spectacular and obviously well cared for by the owners. A highlight is the location, which is in Old town, within a few blocks from the Seaport (2 min walk to Schooner's Wharf) and a 6 minute walk to Duval. Central to everything. The pictures of the house don't do the property justice..... comfortable beds, big glass doors off the family room and porch over looking the amazing pool, fenced in yard WITH DRIVEWAY with a sliding gate for security and privacy. I can go on and on about this quaint, clean, and comfortable location at 311 William Street. We will certainly be back!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your incredible review Cristen! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this Key West retreat and we are looking forward to hosting you again next time you visit the island. Thank you for being our guest!

Backyard Paradise!

August 2024
, Malvern, PA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We have visited Key West several years every August, but this is the first time we did a monthly rental and also our first time staying in Old Town. We have worked with Truman and Company every year, and their immediate communication and attention to positive guest experience is unrivaled. We had one issue with a faulty appliance, and Shana (the property manager) had a new one delivered the very next day! As for the home, the Seashell provided the quintessential Key West experience--all the charm of an older home with modern decor and conveniences. While we loved everything about our stay, our favorite area was the back porch and pool--especially at night. It was so private, and the perfectly placed lighting in the surrounding foliage created a lovely oasis after a hot day in the sun. Thank you for a wonderful vacation!

Location, Location, Location!

June 2024

Overall
5

The Seashell Spectacular is a beautifully landscaped property located in near everything! Located in Old Town, just steps to the Historic Seaport area and a couple of blocks to Duval! The home is beautifully furnished and our family truly enjoyed the month of June. We work remote so having the large office upstairs was great! We definitely plan on renting this amazing home again!

Another day in paradise!

April 2024
, United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This was the 2d year we rented The Seashell for the month of April. The house is perfect for a small group or family. Its location is perfect and within easy walking distance of all that makes Key West special. More importantly to me, however, is and was the attention to detail and responsiveness of the property manager, Shana Yoest. She is always available to answer a question, attend to a problem or simply offer suggestions, if asked. Truman and Company could not have a better representative of excellent customer service!

Manager's Response

Thank you for sharing a review of your April stay at The Seashell. Our team here at Best of Key West Rentals is committed to providing high-quality guest service, and we’re thrilled to hear that Shana made a good impression on you. We hope you’ll visit us again soon!

Jewel on William Street

February 2024
, Washington, DC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

This house was charming, nicely decorated and beautifully landscaped. The few problems were addressed promptly by our professional and personable manager, Shana Yoest. Thank you, Shana!
While I wish the owner took credit cards, I thoroughly enjoyed his home and plan to stay again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay Llewellyn. We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Jewel on William Street

February 2024
, Washington, DC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

This house was charming, nicely decorated and beautifully landscaped. The few problems were addressed promptly by our professional and personable manager, Shana Yoest. Thank you, Shana!
While I wish the owner took credit cards, I thoroughly enjoyed his home and plan to stay again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay Llewellyn. We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Jewel on William Street

February 2024
, Washington , DC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
5

This house was charming, nicely decorated and beautifully landscaped. The few problems were addressed promptly by our professional and personable manager, Shana Yoest. Thank you, Shana!
While I wish the owner took credit cards, I thoroughly enjoyed his home and plan to stay again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for taking the time to review your stay Llewellyn. We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Great location

October 2023
, Leesburg, VA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Close to everything

Manager's Response

Heindi, thank you for this short and sweet 5 star review! We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you again soon!

Great location

October 2023
, Leesburg, VA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Close to everything

Manager's Response

Heindi, thank you for this short and sweet 5 star review! We are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and hope to welcome you again soon!

Wonderful Historic House in Great Location

October 2023
, Lemont, IL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We absolutely loved this property. The two things I would like to suggest is for such a beautiful/expensive property there should be better lounge chairs. The ones there are cheap and on has legs that bend when you sit in it. One of our previous rentals had wonderful chairs with rubber/waterproof pads that can also be used in the pool. Also, there should be an empty cabinet for food. No one could possible use all of the dishes/pans etc that fill the cabinets.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your feedback on your recent stay Susan. We are so glad that you enjoyed your time spent at this home. We appreciate your feedback that we will relay back to the owners for consideration. Thank you again and please reach out to us for your next Key West vacation!

Great rental in KW

November 2022
, Margate, NJ US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
3

Fantastic time in rental. Great location. Staff and support team were very attentive and responsive.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Steve, we are so glad the property met your needs while staying with us. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit Key West.

Great place, great location.

October 2022
, Allison Park, PA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Our second stay at this property. Great location in the northern marina area. 3 blocks from Duval and 1 block from the marina. 3 bedrooms each with it's own bathroom. Best backyard with beautiful pool and large porch. Wouldn't think of staying anywhere else.

Manager's Response

Thank you for taking the time to post a review of your stay at The Seashell Thomas. We are so happy to hear that you enjoyed another stay in Key West. Our goal is always to exceed your expectations! If there's anything we can help you with during your next visit, please don't hesitate to let us know. Thank you for being our guest!

Key West Vacation

September 2022
, chilliwack, BC Canada

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This place was awesome! Back yard very private with a amazing pool. Was a bonus with parking in yard.Easy walking distance to restaurants, grocery store and Duval street.
Property manager Shana was so helpful and took care of everything,
Property very clean and the yard was well maintained.
Five star experience all around.

Manager's Response

Thank you so much for your kind words William. We really appreciate you taking the time to share your experience with us — and we agree, Shana is truly a gem to have on our team! We count ourselves lucky for guests like you. We look forward to hosting you again in the future!

Great Location!

July 2022
, Tampa, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We loved staying at The Seashell! Great location! Nice house and nice pool!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your fantastic review Sharon. It was a pleasure hosting you and we look forward to welcoming you again next time you visit the island!

Wonderful home in a wonderful location

October 2021
, Allison Park, PA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Absolutely wonderful home in an excellent location: quiet street 3 blocks from Duval & 1.5 blocks from the marina area. The large outside area with a relatively large heated pool area was beautiful, couldn’t have been better. Pictures provide an accurate portrayal of the home. The 3 en suite bedrooms were a plus. Already rented for 2022

Manager's Response

Thank you for this wonderful review Thomas, we are thrilled you enjoyed your stay with us and look forward to welcoming you again next year!

Wonderful !

April 2021
, Savannah, GA United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The home was fantastic. An authentic Key West home. Enjoyed the privacy of the back porch and lounging in the pool in the afternoon. The location is perfect for walking to all the bars, restaurants, entertainment, and the grocery store. When we had questions, Shana was responsive and took care of our issues. I would highly recommend this property and can't wait to return. Thank you.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review! We hope to see you back again in the future!

Seashell rental

March 2021
, Sag Harbor, NY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
4
Property condition
4

Excellent stay.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review. We are so thrilled you had a wonderful time and look forward to seeing you again next year!

Amazing Stay in Key West

November 2020
, New York, NY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

The moment we arrived at The Seashell we felt completely at home and at ease. Every detail was organized from the beautiful furnishings, layout and art to the chefs kitchen with a full range of cookware and utensils and tableware. Our family of five fit perfectly in this beautiful home.

The landscaped gardens and lovely heated pool were a true escape. As many things as there are to do in Key West, we enjoyed many peaceful hours reading (and napping) by the pool.

The location in Old Town was perfect, very quiet but central. We loved Eaton Street Seafood down the street for great stone crab as well as the Half Shell for oysters at the Marina and the Market Bakery for amazing pastries.

The property was meticulously maintained. Shana the property manager was always extremely responsive and made our stay a pleasure. We look forward to returning soon.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your incredible review! We loved hosting you in Paradise. We hope to see you again soon!

Review of The Seashell

July 2020
, Sarasota, FL United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

This vacation rental was awesome! Two blocks from the Marina where we kept our boat and walking distance to all the wonderful places in Key West. The house was very clean and the manager was amazing. Always available to answer any questions. I would highly recommend this home to anyone who is looking for a great family rental in Key West.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you back soon!

Old Town Key West home away from home.

January 2020
, Akron, OH US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Always a welcoming place for us and our visiting family and friends. Wonderful flowing floor plan compliments our vacation snow bird lifestyle. Great heated pool and convenient off street parking. This past season was our sixth in this great old house.

Manager's Response

Dear Dr. Hirsh,


Thank you for this wonderful review. We always enjoy hosting you at this incredible home and look forward to seeing you again next year.


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Fabulous Backyard

April 2019
, Yougstown, NY US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a lovely stay at this beautiful house. The back yard is amazing--very lush. The pool was the perfect size for our 4 children (very large by Key West standards). Can't beat the location. Walk to everything on the North end of Key West.

Manager's Response

Dear Bridget,


Thank you for your incredible review on The Seashell! We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this wonderful Key West home located in the Old Town area of town. The location and amenities make this a great island getaway and we are so happy that you had a great time. Please come back and see us soon!


Best Regards,


Wendy Zintsmaster and Team

Leave a Review
3 Bed
3 Baths
Sleeps 6

Search Availability

Roxane Test

Submitted by Best of Key Wes... on Fri, 05/10/2024 10:26

Roxane Test

HEART AND SOUL ~ Island Elegance!

HEART AND SOUL ~ Sophisticated and Newly Renovated 5 Bedroom, 4 Bathroom Spacious Home with Incredible Outdoor Lounge Space and Heated Pool!

Location

1701 Atlantic Blvd.
33040 Key West , FL
United States
24° 33' 4.3992" N, 81° 46' 47.6184" W
See map: Google Maps
Florida US

HEART AND SOUL ~ Island Elegance!

Request More Information

Excellent experience

Reviewed by Unknown on 2024-08-29
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a thoroughly enjoyable experience. Management was informative and responsive. The home was fabulous. Pristine in its upkeep and very comfortable.
Manager response on 2024-08-29 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Neil. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

HEART AND SOUL ~ Sophisticated 5 BR / Near Beach / Perfect Fireworks Spot!

Unit Code: HS

HEART AND SOUL ~ Island Elegance!

HEART AND SOUL ~ Sophisticated and Newly Renovated 5 Bedroom, 4 Bathroom Spacious Home with Incredible Outdoor Lounge Space and Heated Pool!
GORGEOUS COASTAL FAMILY ABODE... Modern luxury surrounds you as you enter this stunning renovation that welcomes a large family to gather and unwind in a beautiful coastal setting. This exquisite home boasts 5 bedrooms with 3 custom ensuite bathrooms and an additional fourth shared bathroom for your traveling crew in a perfect Midtown location which is only a brief walk to 2 pristine beaches! Enjoy a dedicated pedestrian/exercise path, dog park, beachfront dining and tennis/pickleball courts nearby. This spacious beauty is your perfect retreat in paradise. ***PRIMARY GUEST MUST BE AT LEAST 25 YEARS OF AGE. DETAILS AND AMENITIES... An open concept floor plan with stunning coastal decor delights your senses and sets the stage for a magical getaway. Luxuriate with loved ones in the modern great room with cushioned seating and a large wall-mounted TV. The generous adjacent kitchen overlooking the pool offers state of the art appliances and tools. The kitchen island with seating is ideal for breakfast conversations and the pass through window with seating invites peaceful enjoyment with a view of the pool area. Break bread with your crew in the dining room that comfortably seats 8. A full size washer/dryer closet is located downstairs. This home is equipped with YouTube TV streaming. SLEEPING ARRANGEMENTS... Downstairs: A primary king bedroom with ensuite bathroom resides on the main floor. Bask in your ultramodern double vanity and walk-in glass door rain shower as you wash away your cares. Open the sliding doors to your delightful outdoor sitting area under swaying palms and sultry breezes. The second bedroom offers a queen bed and the third bedroom is outfitted with a trundle bed (2 twin beds). A full bathroom with a shower/tub combination is located in the bedroom hallway. Upstairs: Travel upstairs to a fabulous bonus space, perfect for a cozy nook to read on the couch or catch up with work at the writing table. The second primary king bedroom is equipped with a walk-in closet, a sitting area for two, a contemporary ensuite bathroom with double vanity and walk-in glass door rain shower. Open your doors to the porch, perfect for sipping on coffee. The second king bedroom upstairs also offers an ensuite bath with glass door walk-in rain shower and single vanity. All bedrooms feature TVs, closets and clothing dressers. OUTDOOR LIVING... Situated on a corner parcel, this home is a veritable outdoor oasis, offering multiple covered patios, a maintenance free green space, a large sparkling heated pool with loungers, a shaded outdoor sectional and a dining table with seating for 6. Lush landscaping envelops your island soul and quiets your mind for hours of serenity and bliss. PARKING.... This home offers covered parking for your vehicle. PETS... This home considers dogs (NO CATS) only. Please include the size and breed when inquiring. MULTI MONTH RESERVATIONS... For monthly reservations, the following fees will be added PER MONTH: Mid-stay clean Pool/hot tub heating fee (if applicable) Pet fee (if applicable) CONCIERGE SERVICES... Enjoy our concierge service to assist you with planning activities for your trip. They can also have your fridge stocked with all the necessities in advance of your arrival! BOOKING DATES... This home is only available as a monthly rental (28 night minimum). We prefer to book by the calendar month (first day of the month to the last). We may consider alternate dates if the calendar allows or if the owner will make an exception. CANCELLATION... Bookings canceled at least 90 days before the start of stay will receive a 100% refund. Cancellations inside of 90 days may receive a refund if we are able to re-rent any or all of the dates of the stay. The refund amount is dependent upon the rate of the new reservation. For multi-month reservations for January through March, a refund will only be offered in the event we are able to re-rent. The refund amount is dependent upon the rate of the new reservation(s). EASE ON DOWN TO WONDERLAND...
May 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
June 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
 
July 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
Age 18 and under.
DatesPrice
05/09/2025 - 05/31/2025$356 /nt
06/01/2025 - 06/30/2025$414 /nt
07/01/2025 - 07/31/2025$375 /nt
08/01/2025 - 08/31/2025$475 /nt
09/01/2025 - 09/30/2025$500 /nt
10/01/2025 - 10/31/2025$536 /nt
11/01/2025 - 11/30/2025$572 /nt
12/01/2025 - 12/31/2025$715 /nt
01/01/2026 - 01/31/2026$947 /nt
02/01/2026 - 02/28/2026$994 /nt
03/01/2026 - 03/31/2026$947 /nt
04/01/2026 - 04/30/2026$715 /nt
05/01/2026 - 05/09/2026$572 /nt
5.0000
(1 Review)

Excellent experience

July 2024
, Webster Groves, MO United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a thoroughly enjoyable experience. Management was informative and responsive. The home was fabulous. Pristine in its upkeep and very comfortable.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Neil. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Leave a Review
5 Bed
4 Baths
Sleeps 10

Search Availability

PELICAN PEARL ~ Paradise!

THE PELICAN PEARL ~ Charming 2nd Floor 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom Condo in Truman Annex w/ Community Pool!

Location

206-4 Southard St.
33040 Key West , FL
United States
24° 33' 8.496" N, 81° 48' 17.2584" W
See map: Google Maps
Florida US

PELICAN PEARL ~ Paradise!

Request More Information

Great location

Reviewed by Christopher C. on 2025-03-31
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
We had a great time staying in Truman Annex and The Pelican Pearl. We were a short walk from everything, the location worked great for us. The community was clean and quiet. We enjoyed many quiet mornings and evenings on the deck out back. The hosts were wonderful, couldn’t have asked for anything more.

Vacation 2024

Reviewed by Kim R. on 2024-04-28
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Pleasant stay and good atmosphere
Manager response on 2024-07-23 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Kin, thank you for this short and sweet five star review, we hope to have the pleasure to host you again next time you visit the island.

Pelican Pearl

Reviewed by Unknown on 2024-05-05
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Enjoyed our stay. Very professional and responsive company.
Manager response on 2024-07-23 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Lynn. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Key West Getaway

Reviewed by Anthony T. on 2024-10-16
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Met all expectations.

Perfection in Paradise

Reviewed by Sherri G. on 2024-09-05
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
My sister and I rented the Pelican Pearl for a weeks get away.. it was absolutely perfect for us. The property is well maintained, gated for security, and other guests were friendly and courteous. The pool is chilled which means it’s a very welcomed relief from the heat!! Close to Duval but far enough you leave the madness behind. We loved it and plan on booking next year.

February 2024

Reviewed by Marianna G. on 2024-02-29
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Truman and Company was very quick to respond when we had a few little problems. The staff was very friendly and helpful.
If only there was a way to eliminate 13 steps to the second floor!
Manager response on 2024-03-01 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your wonderful review Marianna. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Awesome Condo

Reviewed by Jeanie F. on 2024-04-15
Overall satisfaction
Services from rental manager
Cleanliness
Location
Property condition
Recommend to Others
Loved Pelican Pearl. Spent lots of time on the front porch and the back balcony when we were there. Beds very comfortable and the condo was nicely decorated. Would definitely stay here again.
Manager response on 2024-07-23 - Response from Best of Key West Rentals
Thank you for your review Jeanie, we are so glad the property met your needs while staying with us. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit Key West.

THE PELICAN PEARL ~ Charming 2 BR/1 Ba Condo in Truman Annex!

Unit Code: PP

PELICAN PEARL ~ Paradise!

THE PELICAN PEARL ~ Charming 2nd Floor 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom Condo in Truman Annex w/ Community Pool!
CHARMING 2ND FLOOR CONDO IN STUNNING "SHIPYARD" COMMUNITY OF TRUMAN ANNEX… Delight in this cozy gem of southernmost island living, a 2 bedroom, 1 bath second floor dwelling with a balcony that overlooks verdant landscaping and a sparkling shared pool! Slide on your comfiest sandals and immerse yourself in the excitement of Duval Street, just 2 blocks away. You are walking distance to the island's hot spots: Fort Zachary State Park Beach, The Green Parrot, Sloppy Joe's, Hemingway's Home and Mallory Square - home of the famous nightly "Sunset Celebration". ***PRIMARY GUEST MUST BE AT LEAST 25 YEARS OF AGE DETAILS AND AMENITIES... Enter this light and airy open living area that is colorfully and tastefully decorated to ease you into a sense of well-being and tropical tranquility. You and your loved ones will enjoy a cool respite after a day in the sultry sun, sharing relaxed conversation on the cozy furnishings or decompressing with your favorite movies on the wall-mounted TV. The fully equipped and well-stocked kitchen will inspire you to practice your culinary skills, complete with granite countertops, stainless steel appliances and all the tools a chef will need. Dine or play your favorite board game at the table for 4. SLEEPING ARRANGEMENTS… Slip into a peaceful sleep in one of the two bedrooms with plush queen beds. Both rooms offer flat screenTVs, cooling ceiling fans, clothing dressers and nightstands with power ports. The shared bathroom has been updated with a walk-in shower and there is a full washer/dryer closet for your convenience. OUTDOOR LIVING… Open the French doors of the coastal living room to your balcony with umbrella table and chairs, a superb spot for morning coffee or dining outdoors. a second balcony resides just off the kitchen, with a lounge chair for napping or reading your favorite novel. The Shipyard in Truman Annex is a charming, tree-shrouded hideaway with serene walking paths and lanes. The beautiful community pool is lined with lounge chairs and is perfect for soaking up the Key West sun. PARKING... This home does offer parking for one vehicle, just steps from the front door - (vehicle cannot exceed 18 ft), but oversized trucks and extra large SUVs are not permitted and will have to park outside of this community. PETS... This is not not a pet friendly home for weekly guests, however, monthly stays may bring a pet (a required $150 pet fee will be applied) that must be registered with the HOA prior to approval. CANCELLATION... Bookings canceled at least 30 days before the start of stay will receive a 100% refund. Bookings canceled at least 14 days before the start of stay will receive a 50% refund. CONCIERGE SERVICES... Enjoy our concierge service to assist you with planning activities for your trip, from bike/scooter/golf cart rentals to any excursion you can think of including snorkeling and sunset cruises, jet ski rentals, parasailing, kayaking, fishing, paddle boarding and much more. They can also have your fridge stocked with all the necessities in advance of your arrival! YOUR SLICE OF PARADISE IS CALLING...
May 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
June 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
 
July 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
Age 18 and under.
DatesPrice
05/09/2025 - 05/09/2025$168 /nt
05/10/2025 - 05/10/2025$183 /nt
05/11/2025 - 05/11/2025$157 /nt
05/12/2025 - 05/12/2025$169 /nt
05/13/2025 - 05/13/2025$162 /nt
05/14/2025 - 05/14/2025$140 /nt
05/15/2025 - 05/15/2025$167 /nt
05/16/2025 - 05/16/2025$234 /nt
05/17/2025 - 05/17/2025$236 /nt
05/18/2025 - 05/18/2025$203 /nt
05/19/2025 - 05/19/2025$164 /nt
05/20/2025 - 05/20/2025$157 /nt
05/21/2025 - 05/21/2025$170 /nt
05/22/2025 - 05/22/2025$200 /nt
05/23/2025 - 05/24/2025$299 /nt
05/25/2025 - 05/25/2025$312 /nt
05/26/2025 - 05/26/2025$206 /nt
05/27/2025 - 05/27/2025$187 /nt
05/28/2025 - 05/28/2025$198 /nt
05/29/2025 - 05/29/2025$227 /nt
05/30/2025 - 05/30/2025$247 /nt
05/31/2025 - 05/31/2025$299 /nt
06/01/2025 - 06/01/2025$253 /nt
06/02/2025 - 06/02/2025$233 /nt
06/03/2025 - 06/03/2025$225 /nt
06/04/2025 - 06/04/2025$239 /nt
06/05/2025 - 06/05/2025$278 /nt
06/06/2025 - 06/06/2025$305 /nt
06/07/2025 - 06/07/2025$310 /nt
06/08/2025 - 06/08/2025$236 /nt
06/09/2025 - 06/09/2025$218 /nt
06/10/2025 - 06/10/2025$216 /nt
06/11/2025 - 06/11/2025$219 /nt
06/12/2025 - 06/12/2025$253 /nt
06/13/2025 - 06/13/2025$271 /nt
06/14/2025 - 06/14/2025$272 /nt
06/15/2025 - 06/15/2025$227 /nt
06/16/2025 - 06/16/2025$212 /nt
06/17/2025 - 06/17/2025$213 /nt
06/18/2025 - 06/18/2025$219 /nt
06/19/2025 - 06/19/2025$259 /nt
06/20/2025 - 06/20/2025$273 /nt
06/21/2025 - 06/21/2025$290 /nt
06/22/2025 - 06/22/2025$268 /nt
06/23/2025 - 06/23/2025$243 /nt
06/24/2025 - 06/24/2025$244 /nt
06/25/2025 - 06/25/2025$252 /nt
06/26/2025 - 06/26/2025$289 /nt
06/27/2025 - 06/27/2025$301 /nt
06/28/2025 - 06/28/2025$303 /nt
06/29/2025 - 06/29/2025$263 /nt
06/30/2025 - 06/30/2025$254 /nt
07/01/2025 - 07/01/2025$251 /nt
07/02/2025 - 07/02/2025$263 /nt
07/03/2025 - 07/03/2025$347 /nt
07/04/2025 - 07/04/2025$360 /nt
07/05/2025 - 07/05/2025$361 /nt
07/06/2025 - 07/06/2025$316 /nt
07/07/2025 - 07/07/2025$259 /nt
07/08/2025 - 07/08/2025$245 /nt
07/09/2025 - 07/09/2025$254 /nt
07/10/2025 - 07/10/2025$288 /nt
07/11/2025 - 07/11/2025$324 /nt
07/12/2025 - 07/12/2025$327 /nt
07/13/2025 - 07/13/2025$279 /nt
07/14/2025 - 07/14/2025$264 /nt
07/15/2025 - 07/15/2025$263 /nt
07/16/2025 - 07/16/2025$268 /nt
07/17/2025 - 07/17/2025$304 /nt
07/18/2025 - 07/18/2025$328 /nt
07/19/2025 - 07/19/2025$334 /nt
07/20/2025 - 07/20/2025$248 /nt
07/21/2025 - 07/22/2025$239 /nt
07/23/2025 - 07/23/2025$256 /nt
07/24/2025 - 07/24/2025$289 /nt
07/25/2025 - 07/25/2025$313 /nt
07/26/2025 - 07/26/2025$319 /nt
07/27/2025 - 07/27/2025$290 /nt
07/28/2025 - 07/28/2025$265 /nt
07/29/2025 - 07/29/2025$338 /nt
07/30/2025 - 07/30/2025$375 /nt
07/31/2025 - 07/31/2025$418 /nt
08/01/2025 - 08/01/2025$342 /nt
08/02/2025 - 08/02/2025$349 /nt
08/03/2025 - 08/03/2025$282 /nt
08/04/2025 - 08/04/2025$245 /nt
08/05/2025 - 08/05/2025$243 /nt
08/06/2025 - 08/06/2025$248 /nt
08/07/2025 - 08/07/2025$292 /nt
08/08/2025 - 08/08/2025$340 /nt
08/09/2025 - 08/09/2025$346 /nt
08/10/2025 - 08/10/2025$278 /nt
08/11/2025 - 08/11/2025$253 /nt
08/12/2025 - 08/12/2025$230 /nt
08/13/2025 - 08/13/2025$229 /nt
08/14/2025 - 08/14/2025$291 /nt
08/15/2025 - 08/15/2025$329 /nt
08/16/2025 - 08/16/2025$326 /nt
08/17/2025 - 08/17/2025$250 /nt
08/18/2025 - 08/18/2025$233 /nt
08/19/2025 - 08/19/2025$207 /nt
08/20/2025 - 08/20/2025$210 /nt
08/21/2025 - 08/21/2025$265 /nt
08/22/2025 - 08/22/2025$309 /nt
08/23/2025 - 08/23/2025$310 /nt
08/24/2025 - 08/24/2025$236 /nt
08/25/2025 - 08/25/2025$208 /nt
08/26/2025 - 08/26/2025$194 /nt
08/27/2025 - 08/27/2025$196 /nt
08/28/2025 - 08/28/2025$245 /nt
08/29/2025 - 08/29/2025$349 /nt
08/30/2025 - 08/30/2025$348 /nt
08/31/2025 - 08/31/2025$291 /nt
09/01/2025 - 09/01/2025$242 /nt
09/02/2025 - 09/02/2025$216 /nt
09/03/2025 - 09/03/2025$219 /nt
09/04/2025 - 09/04/2025$267 /nt
09/05/2025 - 09/05/2025$312 /nt
09/06/2025 - 09/06/2025$315 /nt
09/07/2025 - 09/07/2025$253 /nt
09/08/2025 - 09/08/2025$197 /nt
09/09/2025 - 09/09/2025$184 /nt
09/10/2025 - 09/10/2025$189 /nt
09/11/2025 - 09/11/2025$237 /nt
09/12/2025 - 09/12/2025$277 /nt
09/13/2025 - 09/13/2025$282 /nt
09/14/2025 - 09/14/2025$218 /nt
09/15/2025 - 09/15/2025$188 /nt
09/16/2025 - 09/16/2025$182 /nt
09/17/2025 - 09/17/2025$190 /nt
09/18/2025 - 09/18/2025$239 /nt
09/19/2025 - 09/19/2025$279 /nt
09/20/2025 - 09/20/2025$286 /nt
09/21/2025 - 09/21/2025$223 /nt
09/22/2025 - 09/22/2025$196 /nt
09/23/2025 - 09/23/2025$191 /nt
09/24/2025 - 09/24/2025$203 /nt
09/25/2025 - 09/25/2025$254 /nt
09/26/2025 - 09/26/2025$293 /nt
09/27/2025 - 09/27/2025$299 /nt
09/28/2025 - 09/28/2025$236 /nt
09/29/2025 - 09/29/2025$194 /nt
09/30/2025 - 09/30/2025$195 /nt
10/01/2025 - 10/01/2025$204 /nt
10/02/2025 - 10/02/2025$255 /nt
10/03/2025 - 10/03/2025$296 /nt
10/04/2025 - 10/04/2025$304 /nt
10/05/2025 - 10/05/2025$240 /nt
10/06/2025 - 10/06/2025$212 /nt
10/07/2025 - 10/07/2025$204 /nt
10/08/2025 - 10/08/2025$216 /nt
10/09/2025 - 10/09/2025$258 /nt
10/10/2025 - 10/10/2025$325 /nt
10/11/2025 - 10/11/2025$335 /nt
10/12/2025 - 10/12/2025$266 /nt
10/13/2025 - 10/13/2025$238 /nt
10/14/2025 - 10/14/2025$215 /nt
10/15/2025 - 10/15/2025$212 /nt
10/16/2025 - 10/16/2025$254 /nt
10/17/2025 - 10/25/2025$550 /nt
10/26/2025 - 10/26/2025$525 /nt
10/27/2025 - 10/27/2025$242 /nt
10/28/2025 - 10/28/2025$244 /nt
10/29/2025 - 10/29/2025$234 /nt
10/30/2025 - 10/30/2025$283 /nt
10/31/2025 - 10/31/2025$336 /nt
11/01/2025 - 11/01/2025$574 /nt
11/02/2025 - 11/02/2025$507 /nt
11/03/2025 - 11/03/2025$521 /nt
11/04/2025 - 11/04/2025$527 /nt
11/05/2025 - 11/05/2025$516 /nt
11/06/2025 - 11/06/2025$573 /nt
11/07/2025 - 11/07/2025$614 /nt
11/08/2025 - 11/08/2025$627 /nt
11/09/2025 - 11/09/2025$560 /nt
11/10/2025 - 11/10/2025$517 /nt
11/11/2025 - 11/11/2025$366 /nt
11/12/2025 - 11/12/2025$275 /nt
11/13/2025 - 11/13/2025$330 /nt
11/14/2025 - 11/14/2025$356 /nt
11/15/2025 - 11/15/2025$365 /nt
11/16/2025 - 11/16/2025$299 /nt
11/17/2025 - 11/17/2025$252 /nt
11/18/2025 - 11/19/2025$261 /nt
11/20/2025 - 11/20/2025$319 /nt
11/21/2025 - 11/21/2025$343 /nt
11/22/2025 - 11/22/2025$348 /nt
11/23/2025 - 11/23/2025$286 /nt
11/24/2025 - 11/24/2025$325 /nt
11/25/2025 - 11/25/2025$336 /nt
11/26/2025 - 11/26/2025$333 /nt
11/27/2025 - 11/27/2025$391 /nt
11/28/2025 - 11/28/2025$428 /nt
11/29/2025 - 11/29/2025$415 /nt
11/30/2025 - 11/30/2025$278 /nt
12/01/2025 - 12/01/2025$213 /nt
12/02/2025 - 12/02/2025$216 /nt
12/03/2025 - 12/03/2025$218 /nt
12/04/2025 - 12/04/2025$397 /nt
12/05/2025 - 12/05/2025$602 /nt
12/06/2025 - 12/06/2025$570 /nt
12/07/2025 - 12/07/2025$279 /nt
12/08/2025 - 12/08/2025$252 /nt
12/09/2025 - 12/09/2025$248 /nt
12/10/2025 - 12/10/2025$251 /nt
12/11/2025 - 12/11/2025$292 /nt
12/12/2025 - 12/12/2025$433 /nt
12/13/2025 - 12/13/2025$416 /nt
12/14/2025 - 12/14/2025$310 /nt
12/15/2025 - 12/15/2025$282 /nt
12/16/2025 - 12/16/2025$274 /nt
12/17/2025 - 12/17/2025$275 /nt
12/18/2025 - 12/18/2025$306 /nt
12/19/2025 - 12/19/2025$409 /nt
12/20/2025 - 12/20/2025$415 /nt
12/21/2025 - 12/21/2025$419 /nt
12/22/2025 - 12/22/2025$424 /nt
12/23/2025 - 12/23/2025$429 /nt
12/24/2025 - 12/24/2025$518 /nt
12/25/2025 - 12/25/2025$523 /nt
12/26/2025 - 12/26/2025$600 /nt
12/27/2025 - 12/27/2025$602 /nt
12/28/2025 - 12/28/2025$640 /nt
12/29/2025 - 12/29/2025$662 /nt
12/30/2025 - 12/30/2025$664 /nt
12/31/2025 - 12/31/2025$692 /nt
01/01/2026 - 01/01/2026$695 /nt
01/02/2026 - 01/02/2026$506 /nt
01/03/2026 - 03/28/2026$500 /nt
03/29/2026 - 03/29/2026$440 /nt
03/30/2026 - 03/30/2026$437 /nt
03/31/2026 - 03/31/2026$428 /nt
04/01/2026 - 04/01/2026$433 /nt
04/02/2026 - 04/02/2026$457 /nt
04/03/2026 - 04/03/2026$473 /nt
04/04/2026 - 04/04/2026$470 /nt
04/05/2026 - 04/05/2026$418 /nt
04/06/2026 - 04/06/2026$410 /nt
04/07/2026 - 04/07/2026$404 /nt
04/08/2026 - 04/08/2026$412 /nt
04/09/2026 - 04/09/2026$446 /nt
04/10/2026 - 04/10/2026$462 /nt
04/11/2026 - 04/11/2026$461 /nt
04/12/2026 - 04/12/2026$396 /nt
04/13/2026 - 04/13/2026$379 /nt
04/14/2026 - 04/14/2026$368 /nt
04/15/2026 - 04/15/2026$378 /nt
04/16/2026 - 04/16/2026$419 /nt
04/17/2026 - 04/17/2026$439 /nt
04/18/2026 - 04/18/2026$529 /nt
04/19/2026 - 04/19/2026$376 /nt
04/20/2026 - 04/20/2026$359 /nt
04/21/2026 - 04/21/2026$358 /nt
04/22/2026 - 04/22/2026$382 /nt
04/23/2026 - 04/23/2026$439 /nt
04/24/2026 - 04/24/2026$463 /nt
04/25/2026 - 04/25/2026$468 /nt
04/26/2026 - 04/26/2026$396 /nt
04/27/2026 - 04/27/2026$370 /nt
04/28/2026 - 04/28/2026$360 /nt
04/29/2026 - 04/29/2026$383 /nt
04/30/2026 - 04/30/2026$442 /nt
05/01/2026 - 05/01/2026$468 /nt
05/02/2026 - 05/02/2026$461 /nt
05/03/2026 - 05/03/2026$379 /nt
05/04/2026 - 05/04/2026$346 /nt
05/05/2026 - 05/05/2026$332 /nt
05/06/2026 - 05/06/2026$358 /nt
05/07/2026 - 05/07/2026$419 /nt
05/08/2026 - 05/08/2026$450 /nt
05/09/2026 - 05/09/2026$452 /nt
5.0000
(8 Review)

Great location

March 2025
, Ocean View, DE US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

We had a great time staying in Truman Annex and The Pelican Pearl. We were a short walk from everything, the location worked great for us. The community was clean and quiet. We enjoyed many quiet mornings and evenings on the deck out back. The hosts were wonderful, couldn’t have asked for anything more.

Key West Getaway

October 2024
, Fair Lawn, NJ US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Met all expectations.

Perfection in Paradise

August 2024
, ELLWOOD CITY, PA US

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

My sister and I rented the Pelican Pearl for a weeks get away.. it was absolutely perfect for us. The property is well maintained, gated for security, and other guests were friendly and courteous. The pool is chilled which means it’s a very welcomed relief from the heat!! Close to Duval but far enough you leave the madness behind. We loved it and plan on booking next year.

Pelican Pearl

April 2024
, United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
4

Enjoyed our stay. Very professional and responsive company.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Lynn. We are so thrilled to hear how much you loved this home and hope to see you again!

Vacation 2024

April 2024
, Lexington , SC United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Pleasant stay and good atmosphere

Manager's Response

Kin, thank you for this short and sweet five star review, we hope to have the pleasure to host you again next time you visit the island.

Awesome Condo

March 2024
, United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Loved Pelican Pearl. Spent lots of time on the front porch and the back balcony when we were there. Beds very comfortable and the condo was nicely decorated. Would definitely stay here again.

Manager's Response

Thank you for your review Jeanie, we are so glad the property met your needs while staying with us. We hope you'll stay with us again next time you visit Key West.

February 2024

January 2024
, North Bend, OH United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Truman and Company was very quick to respond when we had a few little problems. The staff was very friendly and helpful.
If only there was a way to eliminate 13 steps to the second floor!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Marianna. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

February 2024

January 2024
, North Bend, OH United States

Overall
5
Services from rental manager
5
Cleanliness
5
Location
5
Property condition
5

Truman and Company was very quick to respond when we had a few little problems. The staff was very friendly and helpful.
If only there was a way to eliminate 13 steps to the second floor!

Manager's Response

Thank you for your wonderful review Marianna. It was a pleasure hosting you and we hope to welcome you again next time you visit paradise!

Leave a Review
2 Bed
1 Bath
Sleeps 4

Search Availability

STAR OF THE SEA ~ Simply Irresistible!

STAR OF THE SEA ~ Renovated 2 Bedroom, 2.5 Bathroom Townhome in Quaint Neighborhood Perfectly Located w/ Shared Pool!

Location

1023 Simonton St.
33040 Key West , FL
United States
24° 32' 59.8956" N, 81° 47' 46.3596" W
See map: Google Maps
Florida US

STAR OF THE SEA ~ Simply Irresistible!

Request More Information

STAR OF THE SEA ~ Renovated 2 BR, 2.5 Ba Townhome w/ Shared Pool!

Unit Code: SOT

STAR OF THE SEA ~ Simply Irresistible!

STAR OF THE SEA ~ Renovated 2 Bedroom, 2.5 Bathroom Townhome in Quaint Neighborhood Perfectly Located w/ Shared Pool!
OLD TOWN CUTIE CABANA… Bask in the charm of Old Town Key West as you approach this intimate and picturesque 2 bedroom townhome, located in the cozy enclave of Southernmost Cabana Community, just one block from famous Duval Street and the island's most popular spots. A rare find, this quaint getaway promises both proximity to all of the southernmost excitement yet tucked into a peaceful nest of serenity. Your perfect island retreat awaits you! ***PRIMARY GUEST MUST BE AT LEAST 25 YEARS OF AGE DETAILS AND AMENITIES… A classic white picket fence greets you as you enter your tropical front yard and welcomes you to sit on your porch for a lovely cup of morning coffee and people watching. Ease into the entry where high ceilings and modern touches envelop you and open living and kitchen areas invite you to congregate with loved ones for entertaining and relaxation. Craft your favorite meals in the kitchen that boasts spacious countertops, stainless steel appliances and chef tools galore. Converse and dine at the breakfast bar for 3 or the cozy dining table for 4, then sprawl out on plush furnishings and enjoy a movie escape on your large wall-mounted TV. A full size washer/dryer closet and a full shower bathroom are located downstairs for your convenience. SLEEPING ARRANGEMENTS... Follow the stairs up to 2 plush king bedrooms that will tuck you in for an amazing night of slumber and rejuvenation. The primary bedroom offers an ensuite shower/tub combination and a private balcony for star-gazing and a nightcap. The guest bedroom features an ensuite shower bathroom. Both rooms are equipped with clothing dressers, storage closets and TVs for your enjoyment. OUTDOOR LIVING... Step outside to your spacious private back deck with ample and comfy seating and toss your fresh catch and steaks on the grill while sipping on a frosted cocktail. Enjoy the peace of listening to balmy breezes tickling swaying palms and the joyful sounds of nature in this ultimate serene setting. Follow the beautiful stone pathway that ambles throughout the cabana community and delights your senses with the grandeur of mature treescapes and lush gardens. You are only steps away from the gorgeous shared pool with a soothing waterfall feature. This home comes with 1 off street covered parking spot. PETS... This home does not allow pets. MULTI MONTH RESERVATIONS... For monthly reservations, the following fees will be added PER MONTH: Mid-stay clean Pool/hot tub heating fee (if applicable) Pet fee (if applicable) BOOKING DATES... This home is only available as a monthly rental (28 night minimum). We prefer to book by the calendar month (first day of the month to the last). We may consider alternate dates if the calendar allows or if the owner will make an exception. CONCIERGE SERVICES... Enjoy our concierge service to assist you with planning activities for your trip, from bike/scooter/golf cart rentals to any excursion you can think of including snorkeling and sunset cruises, jet ski rentals, parasailing, kayaking, fishing, paddle boarding and much more. They can also have your fridge stocked with all the necessities in advance of your arrival! CANCELLATION... Bookings canceled at least 90 days before the start of stay will receive a 100% refund. Cancellations inside of 90 days may receive a refund if we are able to re-rent any or all of the dates of the stay. The refund amount is dependent upon the rate of the new reservation. For multi-month reservations for January through March, a refund will only be offered in the event we are able to re-rent. The refund amount is dependent upon the rate of the new reservation(s). SETTLE DOWN IN HEAVEN…
May 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
June 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
 
July 2025
SuMoTuWeThFrSa
 1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 
Age 18 and under.
DatesPrice
05/09/2025 - 05/31/2025$161 /nt
06/01/2025 - 06/30/2025$170 /nt
07/01/2025 - 07/31/2025$187 /nt
08/01/2025 - 08/31/2025$170 /nt
09/01/2025 - 09/30/2025$179 /nt
10/01/2025 - 10/31/2025$197 /nt
11/01/2025 - 11/30/2025$215 /nt
12/01/2025 - 12/31/2025$358 /nt
01/01/2026 - 01/31/2026$536 /nt
02/01/2026 - 02/28/2026$563 /nt
03/01/2026 - 03/31/2026$536 /nt
04/01/2026 - 04/30/2026$250 /nt
05/01/2026 - 05/09/2026$188 /nt
Leave a Review
2 Bed
3 Baths
Sleeps 4

Search Availability

Pages

Subscribe to Best of Key West Rentals RSS